2 research outputs found
A Critical Analysis of Peer Reviewer Comments on Systematic Review Search Strategies
No full textThis document is a working draft, presented as-is. The authors do not plan to complete and submit it for publication.The full dataset for this project is available at:
Townsend, W. A., MacEachern, M. P., Song, J. (2020). Analyzing Reviewer Responses to Systematic Review Search Methodology through Open Peer Review [Data set], University of Michigan - Deep Blue Data. https://doi.org/10.7302/acjm-cz18Introduction: Numerous studies have demonstrated the poor quality of systematic reviews. While many groups provide methodology recommendations to increase the quality of search strategies and compliance with reporting standards, it is unclear how often or how rigorously the search strategies are actually reviewed during the manuscript peer review process. The peer review process should address egregious methodology and reporting issues, but we hypothesize that this process seldom adequately addresses the search methods. Through Open Peer Review (OPR), we were able to investigate how peer review handles the search process of systematic review studies.
Methods:
We conducted a search through one publisher's 54 medicine and public health journals that provide OPR documentation in order to identify systematic review papers published in 2017. For each article we determined if OPR data, reviewer and author comments, were accessible. If so, we assessed the search methodology and reporting quality of the search process with a grading rubric based on PRISMA and PRESS standards, and then mined peer reviewer comments for references to the search methodology.http://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/193519/1/FOR DEPOSIT Manuscript Outline_Open Peer Review.docxDescription of FOR DEPOSIT Manuscript Outline_Open Peer Review.docx : Draft articleSEL
Voorstudie basisdocument grof stof
No full textDit rapport is een voorstudie t.b.v. het mogelijk opstellen van een basisdocument grof stof in het kader van het effectgericht milieubeleid.Abstract not availableDGMH/BWS-S /Cornet JPWijnen HLT
