Brigham Young University Law School

BYU Law Review 
Volume 2019 Issue 4 Article 1 
Summer 8-21-2020 
2019-2020 BYU Law Review Masthead 
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview 
Recommended Citation 
2019-2020 BYU Law Review Masthead, 2019 BYU L. Rev. (2020). 
Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview/vol2019/iss4/1 
This Frontmatter is brought to you for free and open access by the Brigham Young University Law Review at BYU 
Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in BYU Law Review by an authorized editor of BYU Law 
Digital Commons. For more information, please contact hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu. 
CMASTHEAD (2019-2020 BYU LR).2019-4.docx 7/17/20 12:28 PM 
Brigham Young University 
Law Review 
 
VOLUME 2019 NUMBER 4 
Editor in Chief 
SCOTT MAUGHAN 
Managing Editor of Administration 
TAYLOR J. SMITH 
 
Managing Editor of Publication 
ALEXANDRA POULSON 
 
Managing Editor of Technology 
PAUL D. FIFE 
 
Lead Articles Editors 
MAKADE CLAYPOOL 
SYDNEY CORRY 
ANNEMARIE GARRETT 
TYLER KIVLEY 
TAYLOR M. SMITH 
 
 
 
Executive Editors 
STEPHEN R. ARROYO 
JACOB BLACK 
BRADLEY STEWART 
JACKSON WALKER 
 
Symposium Articles Editors 
AUSTIN ATIKINSON 
 
Lead Note & Comment Editors 
EMMA BALLS 
JAROM HARRISON 
KEVIN MOSCON 
MARY FRANDSEN 
ASHLEY WADDOUPS 
 
 
 
 
Senior Editors 
 
STEPHANIE ALDOUS 
CHASE BECKSTEAD 
BRITTNEY HERMAN 
CHARLES SHERRIL 
 
SIMONE ALDREDGE 
MATTHEW HAVILI 
BROOKE MCLAIN 
CRAIG WESTERGARD 
  
	
CMASTHEAD (2019-2020 BYU LR).2019-4.docx 7/17/20 12:28 PM 
BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW 
	
 
Associate Editors 
AVERY G. BENESCH 
BENJAMIN FORSGREN 
RAHGAN JENSEN 
JARED KEETCH 
BRIANNE KINGERY 
GARRETT MEISMAN 
ANDREW NAVARRO 
MCKENNA RAMMELL 
KODY RICHARDSON 
TANNER SCHENEWARK 
MIRANDA CHERKAS SHERRILL 
GRACE STEPHENSON NIELSEN 
VIVIAN TSE 
MICHAEL VAIL 
MCKINNEY VOSS 
 
D. MICHELLE BEUS 
JOHN GEILMAN 
RACHEL JONES 
GRIFFITH KIMBALL 
HANNAH LEAVITT-HOWELL 
WILL MORRISON 
ALYSSA NIELSEN 
JAIMEE RASMUSSEN 
CLINT SAYLOR 
DOMINIC SHAW 
DANIEL SORENSON 
MELISSA JO TOWNSEND 
BRITTANY URNESS 
JESSICA VOLMAR 
EMILY WALTER 
 
	


English

2019-2020 BYU Law Review Masthead

BYU Law Review 
Volume 2019 Issue 5 Article 4 
Summer 8-31-2020 
Table of Contents 
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview 
Recommended Citation 
Table of Contents, 2019 BYU L. Rev. (2020). 
Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview/vol2019/iss5/4 
This Frontmatter is brought to you for free and open access by the Brigham Young University Law Review at BYU 
Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in BYU Law Review by an authorized editor of BYU Law 
Digital Commons. For more information, please contact hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu. 
ETOFC(5).FIN .docx 8/5/20 9:54 PM 	
Brigham Young University 
Law Review 
 
VOLUME 2019 NUMBER 5 
ARTICLES 
 
Owning Nothingness: Between the Legal and the Social 
Norms of the Art World 
 Guy A. Rub ......................................................................... 1147 
 
Caught by the Cat’s Paw 
 Sandra F. Sperino ............................................................... 1219 
	
Reputation Systems Bias in the Platform Workplace 
E. Gary Spitko .................................................................... 1271 
 
COMMENTS 
 
It’s Whose Party? Accurately Defining Political Parties in First 
Amendment Cases 
 MaKade Claypool ................................................................ 1333 
	
The California Coastal Commission’s Efforts to Provide 
Affordable Overnight Accommodations by Preempting Cities’ 
Constitutional Police Power 
 Taylor Smith ....................................................................... 1369 
 
Corpus Linguistics and Gun Control: Why Heller Is Wrong 
 Kyra Babcock Woods ........................................................... 1401 
 
 


BYU Law Review 
Volume 2019 Issue 6 Article 3 
Summer 9-1-2020 
BYU Law Review Subscription Information 
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview 
 Part of the Law Commons 
Recommended Citation 
BYU Law Review Subscription Information, 2019 BYU L. Rev. (2020). 
Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview/vol2019/iss6/3 
This Frontmatter is brought to you for free and open access by the Brigham Young University Law Review at BYU 
Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in BYU Law Review by an authorized editor of BYU Law 
Digital Commons. For more information, please contact hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu. 
BSUBSCRIP.2019-6.docx 9/25/20 11:28 AM 	
Brigham Young University 
Law Review 
 
VOLUME 2019 NUMBER 6 
 
 
BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW (ISSN 0360-151X) 
will publish six issues in Volume 2019 (July, August, October, November, 
and December of 2019; February of 2020). Business Office: J. Reuben Clark 
Law School, Accounting Office, 368 JRCB, Provo, Utah 84602-8000.  
 
SUBSCRIPTIONS: The subscription rate for subscribers in the United States 
is $36 for one year, $65 for two years, and $90 for three years. Foreign 
subscriptions are $44 for one year, $81 for two years, and $114 for three 
years. All claims on issues not received must be made within three months 
of publication if within the United States, or within six months for foreign 
subscriptions. Subscriptions are entered for an entire year only and are 
payable in advance. All subscriptions are renewed automatically unless 
timely notice of cancellation is given. Please send all correspondence 
regarding subscriptions to Accounting Office, 368 JRCB, Provo, Utah 
84602-8000. Issues older than one year may be obtained for $16.00 to $20.00 
from William S. Hein & Co., Inc., 1285 Main Street, Buffalo, New York 
14209-1987; phone (800) 828-7571. Back issues are also available at 
HeinOnline, http://heinonline.org. 
 
SUBMISSIONS: The Law Review is pleased to accept electronic submissions 
for publication through Scholastica or by email: lawrev@lawgate.byu.edu.  
The Law Review no longer accepts hardcopy submissions for publication.  
All other communications pertaining to articles should be sent to the 
attention of the Managing Editor of Administration, 215 JRCB, Brigham 
Young University, Provo, Utah 84602-8000. 
 
CONTENT: All citations conform to The Bluebook: A Uniform System of 
Citation (20th ed. 2010) and The Chicago Manual of Style (17th ed. 2017). 
Views expressed herein are to be attributed to their authors and not to the 
Brigham Young University Law Review or Brigham Young University, 
unless otherwise indicated. 
 
COPYRIGHT: Except as otherwise noted, the Law Review is pleased to grant 
permission for copies of articles to be made for noncommercial classroom 
use, provided that (1) a proper notice of copyright is affixed to each copy, 
(2) the author and source are identified, (3) copies are distributed at or below 
cost, and (4) the Brigham Young University Law Review is notified of the 
use. 
 
Copyright © 2019 Brigham Young University Law Review 


BYU Law Review Subscription Information

Hyman, David A.

Kovacic, William E.

State Enforcement in a Polycentric World

BYU Law Review 
Volume 2020 Issue 2 Article 4 
Fall 11-1-2020 
Table of Contents 
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview 
 Part of the Law Commons 
Recommended Citation 
Table of Contents, 2020 BYU L. Rev. (2020). 
Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview/vol2020/iss2/4 
This Frontmatter is brought to you for free and open access by the Brigham Young University Law Review at BYU 
Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in BYU Law Review by an authorized editor of BYU Law 
Digital Commons. For more information, please contact hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu. 
Brigham Young University 
Law Review 
VOLUME 2020 NUMBER 2 
ARTICLES 
Medical Disputes and Conflicting Values: 
Is There a “Right to Die” Later? 
Janet L. Dolgin ........................................................................ 95 
Information Matters in Tax Enforcement 
Leandra Lederman & Joseph C. Dugan ................................ 145 
Debunking Intellectual Property Myths:  
Cross-Cultural Experiments on Perceptions of Property 
Gregory N. Mandel, Kristina R. Olson, 
& Anne A. Fast .................................................................... 219 
In Defense of Immutability 
Nicholas Serafin .................................................................... 275 
COMMENT 
Fan Films and Fanworks in the Age of Social Media:  
How Copyright Owners Are Relying on Private Ordering 
to Avoid Angering Fans 
Kagen Despain ...................................................................... 333 


An Appeal from Order Granting Motion to Dismiss, Entered by the Fourth District Court, Utah County, Before the Honorable Jared Eldridge
Michael Winn, Winn at Law PLLC, Counsel for Appellants
Aaron P. Dodd (10239), Fillmore Spencer LLC, Counsel for Appellee

Utah Court of Appeals

Chad Laney Holmes and Holmes4SALE, LLC, Plaintiffs/ Appellants v. GARRETT FAUCETTE, Defendants/ Appellees : Brief of Appellee

On appeal from the Third Judicial District Court, Salt Lake County, Commissioner Joana Sagers and Judge Richard McKelvie, District Court No. 134901200
Angilee K. Dakic (12722), Pearson Butler, LLC, Attorney for Appellant
Martin N. Olsen, Olsen & Olsen, LLC, Attorney for Appelle

SARA WARD, Appellant v. MEREDITH MCGARRY, Appellee : Reply Brief

Brigham Young University Journal of Public Law 
Volume 35 Issue 1 Article 1 
Fall 11-30-2020 
Frontmatter 
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/jpl 
 Part of the Law Commons 
Recommended Citation 
Frontmatter, 35 BYU J. Pub. L. (2020). 
Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/jpl/vol35/iss1/1 
This Frontmatter is brought to you for free and open access by BYU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for 
inclusion in Brigham Young University Journal of Public Law by an authorized editor of BYU Law Digital Commons. 
For more information, please contact hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu. 
 
BYU Journal of Public Law 
Volume 35  Number 1 
2020 
 
The BYU Journal of Public Law  publishes two issues per year  at the J. 
Reuben Clark Law School, Provo, Utah. ISSN 0896-2383. Standard Mail 
prepaid at Lincoln, Nebraska, and at additional mailing offices.  
 
Postmaster:  
Send address changes to the BYU Journal of Public Law, Accounting Office, 
368 JRCB, Provo, Utah 84602. 
 
Subscriptions:  
Rates:  United States: $14/issue, $20/year, $36/2 years, $50/3 years. 
 International:  $17/issue, $25/year, $46/2 years, $65/3 years. 
 
Subscriptions are renewed automatically unless a discontinuance request is 
received. Claims for undelivered issues must be made within          three 
months of publication for U.S. subscribers or six months for        international 
subscribers. Send all subscriptions correspondence to      the BYU Journal of 
Public Law, Accounting Office, 368 JRCB, Provo, Utah 84602. 
 
Back issues in complete sets, volumes, or single issues may be obtained from 
William S. Hein & Co., Inc., 1285 Main Street, Buffalo, New York 14209; 
(800) 828-7571; http://heinonline.org. 
 
Submissions: 
The Journal welcomes manuscript submissions. Each manuscript should be 
in Microsoft Word format, double-spaced, 12-point serif font.      Submissions 
should include the author’s CV and a cover letter with a short description of 
the manuscript. The Journal prefers submissions via  
Scholastica. Authors may also submit manuscripts electronically to 
lawjour@byulaw.net. 
 
Copyright Requests: 
Send all articles communications to the BYU Journal of Public Law, 471H 
JRCB, Provo, Utah 84602. Except as indicated in individual         articles, the 
Journal grants permission for articles to be copied for classroom use if (1) a 
proper notice of copyright is affixed to each copy, (2) the author and source 
are identified, (3) copies are distributed at or     below cost, and (4) the BYU 
Journal of Public Law is notified of the use. 
 
Content: 
All views expressed in this publication belong to the authors alone and not 
the BYU Journal of Public Law or the J. Reuben Clark Law School. Citations 
follow the rules of The Bluebook: A Uniform System of  Citation (19th ed. 
2010) and The Chicago Manual of Style (16th        ed. 2010). Unless otherwise 
indicated, all editors are students at the J.    Reuben Clark Law School. 
 
Cite as: BYU J. Pub. L. 
 
Copyright © 2020 BYU Journal of Public Law 
  
 
BYU Journal of Public Law 
Volume 35  Number 1 
2020 
 
Editor-in-Chief 
RYNDAN RILEY 
Managing Articles Editor 
 
Managing Publication Editor 
PHILIP BARR   SARAH HATTON  
Managing Administration Editor 
 
Managing Submissions Editor 
KARA BLOOMER   MACKENZIE CANNON  
   
Executive Editors  Lead Editors 
ALICIA CONLEY   BRANDON GRAVES  
HANNAH LEAVITT-HOWELL   BROOKE GLEDHILL  
ALLYSON MORTELL   CHRISTINA CHAN  
MJ TOWNSEND   JAYCE DAVIS  
VIVIAN TSE   MIKA HILLERY 
   
 
Associate Editors 
 
ABIGAIL W. BROWN  
ANDREW L. JUERGENS  
CATHERINE L. GRANTHAM  
CLARA E. HUBBARD 
ETHAN A. SCHOW  
HAYDEN B. EARL  
JACKSON M. SKINNER  
JADEN COWDIN 
 
 JARED S. EREKSON 
KADE A. ALLRED 
MASON L. GARDNER  
MORGAN K. FARNSWORTH  
RHETT F. HUNT 
TANNER R. HAFEN  
WAYNE VANDEGRAAFF 
 
 
BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY 
J. REUBEN CLARK LAW SCHOOL FACULTY 
 
 
ANDERSON, CURTIS B. (2015), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1991, J.D., 1994, Brigham Young 
University. 
 
ASAY, CLARK D. (2014), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2001, Brigham Young University; M.A., 2002, 
University of Cambridge; J.D., 2007, Stanford Law School. 
 
AUGUSTINE-ADAMS, KIF (1995), Charles E. Jones Professor of Law. B.A., 1988, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 1992, Harvard Law School. 
 
BAIR, STEPHANIE P. (2015), Associate Professor of Law. B.S., 2001, University of Prince Edward Island; 
Ph.D., 2008, University of Utah; J.D., 2012, Harvard Law School. 
 
CLARK, ELIZABETH A. (2000), Associate Director for the International Center for Law and Religion Studies. 
B.A., 1994, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1997, Brigham Young University.  
 
CLAYTON, WILLIAM W. (2018), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2006, Stanford University; M.B.A., 
2010, Stanford University; J.D., 2011, Yale Law School.  
 
COLLINGS, JUSTIN M. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2006, Brigham Young University; J.D., 
2010, Ph.D., 2013, Yale University. 
 
COOK, BENJAMIN J. (2016), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1998, M.A./M.Ed., 2001, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 2005, Georgetown University Law Center. 
 
DANIELS, BRIGHAM (2010), Associate Professor of Law. M.P.A., 2000, University of Utah; J.D., 2003, 
Stanford Law School; Ph.D., 2010, Duke University. 
 
DISHMAN, ELYSA (2016), Distinguished Practitioner in Residence. B.A., 2003, Brigham Young           
University; J.D., 2007, University of Virginia School of Law. 
 
DOXEY, GARY B. (2005), Associate Director of International Center for Law and Religion Studies. B.A., 
1980, J.D., 1984, Brigham Young University; Ph.D., 1992, Cambridge University. 
 
FEE, JOHN E. (2000), Professor of Law. B.A., 1992, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1995, University of 
Chicago. 
 
FLEMING, J. CLIFTON JR. (1974), Ernest L. Wilkinson Chair and Professor of Law. B.S., 1964, Brigham 
Young University; J.D., 1967, George Washington University. 
 
GEDICKS, FREDERICK M. (1990), Guy Anderson Chair and Professor of Law. B.A., 1977, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 1980, University of Southern California. 
 
HERNANDEZ, CARL III (2001), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1988, J.D./M.P.A., 1992, Brigham 
Young University. 
 
HURT, A. CHRISTINE (2014), Associate Dean and Rex J. and Maureen E. Rawlinson Professor of Law. B.A., 
1990, Texas Tech University; J.D., 1993, University of Texas School of Law. 
 
JENNEJOHN, MATTHEW C. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2002, Brigham Young University; 
MSc, 2004, London School of Economics; J.D., 2007, Columbia University School of Law. 
 
JENSEN, ERIC TALBOT (2011), Professor of Law. B.A., 1989, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1994, 
University of Notre Dame; LL.M., 2001, The Judge Advocate General’s School; LL.M., 2006, Yale 
Law School. 
 
JONES, CREE (2020), Associate Professor of Law. B.S., 2006, Brigham Young University; M.A., 2009, John 
Hopkins University; J.D./M.P.P., 2013, University of Michigan; Ph.D., 2018, University of Chicago.  
 
KYLE, KRISTIN B. GERDY (1995), Teaching Professor and Director of Rex E. Lee Advocacy Program. B.A., 
1992, J.D., 1995, Brigham Young University.  
 
MOORE, DAVID H. (2008), Associate Dean and Wayne M. and Connie C. Hancock Professor of Law. B.A., 
1992, J.D., 1996, Brigham Young University. 
 
NIELSON, AARON L. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2003, University of Pennsylvania;  LL.M. 
2006, University of Cambridge; J.D., 2007, Harvard Law School. 
 
NÚÑEZ, D. CAROLINA (2007), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2001, J.D., 2004, Brigham Young 
University. 
 
SCHARFFS, BRETT G. (1997), Francis R. Kirkham Professor of Law and Director of International Center for 
Law and Religion Studies. B.S.B.A., 1986, M.A., 1987, Georgetown University; B.Phil., 1989, Oxford 
University; J.D., 1992, Yale Law School. 
 
SHOBE, GLADRIEL D. (2016), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2003, Brigham Young University; J.D., 
2010, Yale Law School; LL.M., 2011, New York University. 
 
SHOBE, JARROD E. (2016), Associate Professor of Law. B.S./B.A., 2005, Arizona State University; J.D., 
2011, Yale Law School. 
 
SMITH, D. GORDON (2007), Dean and Glen L. Farr Professor of Law. B.S., 1986, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 1990, University of Chicago Law School. 
 
STAHELI, KORY D. (2007), Director of Law Library. B.A., 1984, J.D., 1987, M.L.I.S., 1991, Brigham Young 
University.  
 
STANCIL, PAUL J. (2014), Professor of Law. B.A., 1993, University of Virginia; J.D., 1996, University of 
Virginia School of Law. 
 
STEELE, MICHALYN (2011), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 1992, M.A., 1994, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 2001, Georgetown University Law Center. 
 
SUN, LISA GROW (2008), Associate Professor of Law. B.S., 1994, University of Utah; J.D., 1997, Harvard 
Law School. 
 
THORLEY, DANE R. (2019), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2012, Brigham Young University; M.A., 
2015, Columbia University; M.Phil. 2017, Columbia University; J.D., 2017, Yale Law School; Ph.D., 
2019, Columbia University. 
 
WELCH, JOHN W. (1980), Robert K. Thomas University Professor of Law. B.A., 1970, M.A., 1970, Brigham 
Young University; J.D., 1975, Duke University. 
 
WORTHEN, KEVIN J. (1987), University President, and Hugh W. Colton Professor of Law. B.A., 1979, J.D., 
1982, Brigham Young University. 
ADJUNCT FACULTY 
 
AFFLECK, ADAM S. 
ARMSTRONG, RICHARD J. 
BALLARD, MIKE 
BARGER, W. BRADLEY 
BARLOW, MATTHEW A. 
BAUGHMAN, KRISTIN 
BENSON, DEE V. 
BRAMBLE, CATHERINE E. 
CUNDICK, TED 
DISHMAN, LAKE 
DUTCHER, DAVID 
FARNSWORTH, DENISE 
FERRELL, JAMES 
FIENE, AMY 
FRANDSEN, BRITTANY 
GIGGER, JOSHUA G. 
GLADE, LEEANN 
GOODWIN, SCOTT 
 
GRAHAM, ATHELIA 
GRIFFITH, SUSAN W. 
HORTON, KEN 
JENSEN, MARY O. 
KIMBALL, DALE A. 
KULBETH, K. MARIE 
LEE, THOMAS R. 
LINTON, MORRIS D. 
LORIMER, BRENT 
MATIS, GREGORY J. 
MCBRIDE, RYAN 
MCCULLOUGH, LEE S. 
MOURITSEN, STEPHEN C. 
NORMAN, KRISTIN 
OWEN, STANFORD B. 
PARKER, KIMBALL 
PEAD, DUSTIN B. 
 
PERRY, AUDREY L. 
PHILLIPS, SPENCER D. 
ROGERS, STEVEN M. 
SCHAERR, GENE C. 
TAYLOR, RYAN J. 
TENNEY, RYAN 
THOMAS, SUSANNAH 
THOMPSON, DOUGLAS 
TIPPETT, ROBERT S. JR. 
TODD, DAVID R. 
VAN WOERKOM, DANIEL 
WALKER, JEFFERY N. 
WARNER, PAUL M. 
WATERMAN, STEVEN T. 
WEILER, TODD D. 
WELCH, MEGAN 
WISE, JANE H. 
 
 
  
 
BYU Journal of Public Law 
Volume 35  Number 1 
2020 
 
Table of Contents 
 
ARTICLES 
 
 
The Little Statute that Gets No Respect: How Courts Have  
Ignored the Administrative Procedure Act with Respect to  
Whether Pre-Enforcement Challenge Provisions are Exclusive 
        Arthur Sapper 
 
  1 
Are Government Shutdowns Unconstitutional? 
        Allen Shoenberger 
 
19 
Re-Victimization of Domestic Violence Victims 
        Angela de la Garza 
 
34 
 
  
COMMENTS 
 
 
FHA Sexual Harassment Claims: Title VII Applications and  
Departures through Caselaw and HUD’s 2016 Rule 
        Brittany Urness 
 
80 
Extending NEPA to Disaster Mitigation 
        Kevin Alden 
 
128 
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
 


Frontmatter

Reply Brief of Cross-Appellant  On appeal from the Third Judicial District Court, Salt Lake County,  Honorable Randall N. Skanchy, District Court No. 16090269

Utah Supreme Court

LARRY BOYNTON, Appellee/Corss-Appellant, v. KENNECOTT UTAH COPPER LLC, Appellant/Corss-Appellee, PHILLIPS 66 COMPANY, CONOCOPHILLIPS COMPANY, PACIFICORP, Cross-Appellees,

Reply Brief of the Appellant and  Cross-Appellee Kennecott Utah Cooper, LL

Brigham Young University

Not a member yet

2019-2020 BYU Law Review Masthead

Table of Contents