Brigham Young University Law School

Utah Court of Appeals

Brigham Young University Law School 
BYU Law Digital Commons 
Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– ) 
2017 
Utah v. Lopez 
Utah Court of Appeals 
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/byu_ca3 
 Part of the Law Commons 
Original Brief Submitted to the Utah Supreme Court; digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law 
Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah. 
Recommended Citation 
Legal Brief, Utah v Lopez, No. 20160752 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2017). 
https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/byu_ca3/3632 
This Legal Brief is brought to you for free and open access by BYU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for 
inclusion in Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– ) by an authorized administrator of BYU Law Digital Commons. 
Policies regarding these Utah briefs are available at http://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/utah_court_briefs/
policies.html. Please contact the Repository Manager at hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu with questions or feedback. 
STATE OF UTAH 
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL 
··-· FILED 
UTAH APPEl..l.ATE C".)URTS 
Spencer E. Austin 
Chief Criminal Deputy 
Parker Douglas 
Chief Federal Deputy 
& General Counsel 
SEAN D. REYES 
ATTORNEY GENERAL 
Tyler R. Green 
Solicitor General 
Missy W. Larsen 
Chief Of Staff 
May 3, 2017 
Ms. Lisa Collins 
Clerk, Utah Court of Appeals 
PO Box 140230 
Salt Lake City, Utah 84114-0230 
Re: State v. Lopez, case no. 20160752-CA 
Dear Ms. Collins: 
MAY - 3 ::;7 
Bridget K. Romano 
Chief Civil Deputy 
I write to inform the Court that the State does not concede error in this appeal, but 
it will not be filing a brief here because of the Criminal Appeals Division's resource 
constraints and the recent changes in this Court's approach to granting extensions of 
briefing deadlines. 
In the past, this Court addressed each request for extension on its merits in 
accordance with Utah R. App. P. 22, and without capping in advance the number of 
extensions it would grant. But several months ago, the Court began capping the number of 
extensions in all cases at three. To be sure, the Court has since accepted a few briefs filed 
after that third extension, albeit with language threatening sanctions on plenary review. 
The Court's extension orders now state that it will not accept "for any reason" briefs 
filed after the third deadline extension. And the Utah Supreme Court grants no extensions 
for cases on certiorari review. 
The State lacks the resources to file briefs in every case under these time constraints. 
This case is one where it has determined not to file a brief. 
Deputy Solicitor General 
cc: Kimberly Trupiano 
HEBER WELLS BUILDING• 160 EAST 300 SOUTH, 6TH FLOOR• P.O. Box 140854, SALT LAKE CITY, UT 84114-0854 
TELEPHONE: (801) 366-0180 • EMAIL: criminalappeals@utah.gov 
Digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, BYU. 
Machine-generated OCR, may contain errors.


English

Utah v. Lopez

Brigham Young University Law School 
BYU Law Digital Commons 
Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– ) 
2017 
Mark Elden Erickson, Petitioner/Appellant v. Alfred Bigelow, 
Respondent/Appellee. 
Utah Court of Appeals 
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/byu_ca3 
 Part of the Law Commons 
Original Brief Submitted to the Utah Supreme Court; digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law 
Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah. 
Recommended Citation 
Legal Brief, Erickson v Bigelow, No. 20170073 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2017). 
https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/byu_ca3/3661 
This Legal Brief is brought to you for free and open access by BYU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for 
inclusion in Utah Court of Appeals Briefs (2007– ) by an authorized administrator of BYU Law Digital Commons. 
Policies regarding these Utah briefs are available at http://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/utah_court_briefs/
policies.html. Please contact the Repository Manager at hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu with questions or feedback. 
-~ 
AP PELLA TE COURTS 
POSTMARKED 
SEP 2 5 2017 
vtT&H CcJu/2.-T .tP,r:'° ,4r:>1'2 'D4L 5 
> 
. · 1111f~~ v,t?,.,. z/qc~~uu, 
~ f1en~ / t?ryw 11,,,..~-:-, 
. . .. _ ' . , /') I;:;;;,/, ... ¢.> l f ;" M.v I Jl/!--rJ/~ ~)"-'7>J., . 
~J/-'~A2:!I' /.,4,,~ /k<s. 
l 
. I /.,,. /?-<77T'i P~_e/?-.· 
I 
> . . 
.) 
> 
-· ·• > 
-· .. ' ........... ,· , ...... . 
. . II. • ,~ ..,, 
". 1r.d, ,:,_.,,,,,,·,{Jrr..-.-v.->.~ I~£/ -<U ,vl,f;/,~ ',. /-J,,,.....;2 . .3-e',Ut,i/./7 ..,.'f:,.,h;_/r.-
'--~--- 5;.,r-<flt•re 4 s-~..e73 ~.,,,:r ~- o>J 17 >oaar,.,r,,.., .6--c,,,j 
I 
I 
· I 
.. _t:;:,&,1iy~7~cl. ,-..... ~- & .. :Jn->.77--t✓.e /'j . . ~ ~ f~ D $7,t}-r-c £,-d_s ~ 
6.,,~ u :Je-../ rz;:, ~-i'7'12/6w~ ?"' 6/✓-c;.7JP1,'-5' -rz:;, ;:V.M<"rr.f /~ ,:;, C tAe.,,C 
5"::r.a-:. . t; ,e.J2e4,n~ ;::;i~,/4 ~ . 1":,< ~ ,7,:,, .6 hc;..n;h,,..,r. . ""'s..e· . 
..re:i<<-cAIII .-R~r>11~;r ,;:7.-e ~&k .,Vu~, ;: i 6-6 .diJ, .. /1.r,,,.,._~.v..e< /) 
.. r4e. -w/20 /..e . .$TJ:7T"1"'Tf1!. )~ k;,_, c.4,::#//-.,~7 -,:-.,,/ •. 
! 3 - ~.ry,,j_,/~ c..,A.,;./l,~.('-.J...1-,N.S .. 7-U ""·; .b.:2..,,.,/< 7. ~;,,r..~&!lf'..,.,:,e:1'1 
' I 
,, I /" .g ,, ' 
·- (),11~7"',,:;,:,.__, _$(!?',.1,,t.,,:,) 1 e")(.111/c.,lr .t?IZ. k..,-.r,,,,=- ,V,h,::,('_:-7} ·I .. .Ol!f";,½ 
. ... ttl.-e, .. n~pf /·w-4,~·-,. ~ . 4.'4?C... .. ·co,V~/e,.s tt;hJ /'"') e . ·;;- 5'8, /;),1,,1{) 
,s:,>,j rie--x e. 3. .... .l)k o n,~-,..~~ ~..v ;........✓s,.,. I, ...n-! .. ' pt11,u:, 1 '~' J, J 
. 
$'C',d./"-<! 7· ~ "5 T.ifPTZ,;h:!' '5. ~,,,,.,,_,-:rr.-·r. r.s , w,e,,:,,.r-19. i . 7'71 ,e, ~ ....-.n.-e.e j .t ... fo.c ~:r-..,.~ 
... •4 e,e,,,,,_a('~. {$.€.:-.1;,. ,{?.,<.,,,..,..p«.-7~1.) ,../.;,.«. .a...:v..., b~~ 7 .rl",.s·'",.""""'-
1
. .. -') -~ ·.(>.,s,pt,e,.~.:., ,v,A..,.,,u -e·~,qc,rf~ --~ 0/1/'""'/l .,'7-f l'.r ~ .. /."flMJ .,i,_ 
,A I• _.,., . 
_ .. V' -b9+.i .'4,yJ~/1-- C'HA:l,3' .-:; · ~I/I~-- 7,,,g,e, c"'~"~ S.S:-.,1-, ,v~')" I _µ_I) ~..C,z,t,-,._,e.! 72;? ~ - _/ ;,h.-,e. C-q~ ;~ .. 71? -'.J 4/l.~~7'-11'1'271~. /' .r q 
-.... · I .n a-'.~ ... P . ..tr:::a-,, ,~.;"'j J -- (!.;,,i,v1. I !,_-,.,.,-r ....,_,;,--;; . rG., ,, S ))9,-,,,,,">,e, ''. (6,t./-1 :J~ 9) -
,,,, ~, ~ s ~. p..a r7~,C. • _,t, ~~ · /U_e;I · rz,.,,5 'h.r- rn 
Digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, BYU. 
Machine-generated OCR, may contain errors.
·.), I 3 
~ 
_ ..f-: -~ . ~,-c.ic • .r., .. C,4-e. 
.... · ... . 4.~ .... e:Jtt.-:-:-. b<?4'P~.,. wA,~, c/.,...,..,o1,7 . ..-ne..,~· ~ r:->e.4-r-71--s. ,<:-"' 
I •c l- .'l!'.,1~·4,.,.n,;--r,:'j.tfJl'Z "'.,,,.a.'¥V.,,,1::-J ,!'.,,--;r..,,,,._.,, ~ -~ _ . .s:»4~ .#!11:$t?~ ~«0 
· f ·. ,,,.~-~ :. _w,,:,.;,-1.,. '7:1,,.,n.c .. o n/,:!> .. ,a""..-..,.......,:-1 ✓-·r .·.p7..e-,a-, d.e..-e-x~p.71~.s' ·1 rk.. 
.. ·- 'Snbm-e.-/ .4'.-J r-.s i,) aw./.,. ~N-.,C/4 ~/,.,,/""',/. («. 12-c..13. -~) .:s~ 
.... ~.,,11~ .a.'t'. /J1, '-1.,.:'N." . . {A.'!,.,~ ~--~1-"'''~.;) ;,. ,•.: · · 
.'2.~_fo71-i,~,u. e-4,,11.,,,..,., ~J; _,e;;~ ..,t;4 ,("d' ..... ,?)~.,;,.,.,.,...(,7) 1 r.Z. s~>-(. 
, .. 4...,~ ~ e:t.S __ .sf('J;:'/;~J'. .. c/2.s...1.L,..-f-<..J t-1.s..,,,vl _,:z/,.;., ....... ~.gd.J ,6 . __ _ I · -.. ?t:.. • . (',,._, m;,.,n.,:..'., . ..0=. fod-,., &'. - ,.. { ~/,,.,,,, ., 4'4~ !, ,:, ,,,. ,,_, ? t,#-r,,.,._, 
·t . ; 4_,._/ .-rl.e. -hA e:_..,.~ f;;..,~7:-<'".""'""-rt:- ~_ .... /,..,..~ U• s. (l-..s.,'n-,11..c,,...')( fe.-'! S' 8 
i 4 -r ;2 I /?"e"" r nc,o h o.) a-~ 4nc.c.. 1, . ~<!. "'/ 17 u~, ;t"A.,, R,,:,4. 
., . C./,llf·,,,_ U .{ .,;;,1/11;,,,/,, .,,,./,~· .I tJ e·/",,,R_.r_,r 7't... -r!-'--1 ('tz.e ,s ,..,;<?,e,.t: ') 7 ~. Z.;- 4 T; 
· i ~ .,,f ___,, · 1 · ft._. , ,,A. 5 . C'-.;.,r7l.~-:71 ..;_ .. J;' r.. h:11 ~e ~ P"-! '} ,/-'-ff!.,/; ,u ,M! $, 
--·-··· ···1·· .. _.41-.ier r7;r~,6/./uJ; ,,C'.f='.!J·:1""'e,..:;-__ -~~T ~..$ -4--~1.· .a.v-.e:.1 b64 .. ~' 7Z,~&-7 ~./~c, 
I /t),. ~ 5"~"""'~- e,..,_c.,d-4::. {'its-'1.'Ji p.,,p;,4,:,;'J)r!,-- ~,I lr!-b.7 E?.e,~~-~ 
r .i ~ & _- 'I i W.~R,,e t-p.Le,r;.f' J '7"1.,,,_, 4Q'fl,,w!.S • QI,<./'']• C,I ,,.,.,.,.... 1/Jt:!'~I., .,~ JA.A.. 
i .. /'2',(t'vr..~ . . ,.,,i;t,_;~1'-<.1- wk~,e. -4.,1! ... <. ><A .. .._.s:-r:.../;--,- ;_ . ~<!'k .. 7."Jve; 5~.,..~-;s 
-- I .etne .i!\14?tr.:. r,~;,,6/1/t' 77:1,. !'¥/J"P.';'",. J'eJ lfl,Jr 1 ~_, •·.1·J -z:"/V:77441? 
.1'..l'S::<j AJ.f,,,u~77",i,,..,.b.C.: 6,.rt,,.;.·r.:=,.,,z:;: 1 wA,~ l'?,-,-k.:.'~.] ,.Jin,,,; 
--·. -1},z_.,. &A-t:..J?.A-pp-~-P. ) .. pnn4..>-e,#J a.> ~-e/27.?t:1.,_s .,,?-. ,C,:.,.-, , :6a-~.(1- _.Ju, 
1.'o""'·"-·/.$.,,q_<.,· l,/_•'S .• S-.Lr . .l!: o~-:-?PS-1!:, &l . .e'h.l!...,A .;).4,ti~_.)11,,t,-:-.A.--~.w,N.e/ :• 
1/::- .. R.'1:J ~-w...~/3 ....... .d~i M.a-r @-1 1,,1.1~-,.-P"c..-t:,•Jm-..~ -~ s .. ,,,C.12. ~S-d 
~ . 
. -· .'f'-P-c7.'T.1~. ,.-,,.'M' ,.--r.Ji:.;.r,- ~,1-r.,,7-1,i.,.$ -7· <',.&-< /M~ p...,/. ;.,,.--1" _..,,,,.~.,,~,n:eJ 
,,.-ze ~,::;.-r ne-1,1-,,-e..,e/ 77:7 ~ Criv.,./ /4.e.,.,-.,:' /,_, .4,. '.'<!./,-.,.a._....._,,/ 
..1Au12r Sr-,9,;;,.,-,....,.,..,, 7 -/4.ery u J.A-'/2.r-' -/21/..J ✓ .:..i,.;.,~ r7h .. d"-fs .J ~"'~ 
~<-7"-. 7."lc. c:.-,.n:13. wrl.L ~fe°~ :rt,. I Aw q-7-,z~,,..l'l ~- :rl, n, .Jn..:4:?.~. ~ .5?box.J 
. ,, [l.)~7" (/?rze.s-e.1t.,,...,.,d' -~. (L./,,,,,m ~S. /.5 ~/_4,.fl'""'"~ :zl1) ",L' f;,z;;,-~~ 
./2,_;:hrs /il'l"-d- .. ~ -j-~, ... :;?1 .. 1 ~ .--rel'd l,7.J:,,,,"'J··{~-11;i~ec."t-r,.f' J7 
~ .. J/!%. c1~,p~n:....... .. ~. o'-:4e £-1, .A-J~~ .te.111.in)crJ ~Xf'.rze-,5') 
.. ,/ej t,.,e.;,.t?_ .6y. t/.J~ . L.,,q_,.J ii ,,,J . .-,t,_ /4c,n : ,,,{,~ f'~.?- . S,,7-.,,.,._/,~ _,,...c,/ 
4 '9nk'. .7b · di(_~g-r,-, '-"-4. w &.,;- · L'.,_.,.,r,~ ]Z .:.-.I'./.._.,,.,_,, . eff'.P I 1? J'· I' ·n J ~ 
. · t .e,.--J.t-7~n l,,<,/,?/? el'.,:'., l'.J . .• .,.'~ ;,,.'...;.,,.:.,._ ? 1. ......... . ,~ . . c,pf ~ l-rvv .. " h_, . ~ ,.(~,'ll.,,;.,.. - /.),c;,'I J ~,-Jr Digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, BYU. 
Machine-generated OCR, may contain errors.
/41,J-J_4_,u/_ ~lJc_,_,,¢.,,.s-,, i ~;~4,-;z,,;,,.__,;,,..f' $°~"lkYe.,1A~ ,~,e. .,(;_J;,.11\AJ~ 
~~5"JJ.-r.._/,c,µ_ __ d,,~~.,.....s ,,:T\d-'1--Hro4.I e.,:,,....,/ ~-.;;;:.. • :,:11;;':<u-h.,J,,-.,,<1-<rfel 
I' • ,,,, 
2,4:!.t,_ 1/J. 'i,.f'"~~-=-11., .. ·- ~tr.:, u .,. ~ ~(!a,,ed.,,/ .,~, (',t:1yJ$ ,1/4.-71~ "' 
.~_-__ 71:v.J~e-~r·"r . .r.s.;v,v. tt;t.J/re~'h-/,. /.s -~ ~ie¥> ~~,µ;- w.,_rt;, ~ 
--r.;)~.LV~~ __ -:n;,_. ee,.,,::,,/1,4.tf.:T __ ·. ~- 5~':IC. I' -s ,...,u A..., __ lt11.:-~ .. c,.ua.r 
___ .~.£..~ :_J~ ... d ~- _,,,, ~ .. r ~ _ ~ ..,_, u ,-d ./:r... !:,.,,,,,d#. .. ro . --~ ~ _.,. n-<.-
. _________ --,P•.,.-4L1~---''11J .. ,r;, __ ~-.l✓---T · "'·fl::d1 . _ ~ wkl~ . f.'J>l:.-:n,,r"l:f!., ... ,No~ . . J',-4!r::. ✓75-
--~- -- C4')\J::(l!~.,.R, in.,..;,,.,._r a ,uK Id-"-' C°"-'tv:S-n:;,z.,:,31_~_ ✓-~f'h<~-1--~-£:e..sr,__ 
- ·-------- -~-/:..~.a.~~~ .. ~J.~-;s .. ~_'l.d. 4. "'·'' J.MidA-.2' ·3 _k:;,~"h. lJ 
___ -~- ---~~c~_!j_lJ_~~L"J...::<.,..-,4~.ss--:- t., $-.I.in-., ~~ wo✓-2...'.r.'"JJ _l,f,;'_~ri /J 
-----· -• ----··-- __ _b_-e._ T.D..._L...;.v.,.h:. .. A.-'Jv~lt. .• :12,:::,:,,.,.__t:/.._ i ~1,M.~.z--d1~~,1.~. u/2._ ...l,"":'.,.:.R 
.. --·-')- _/A"V ~l'-f'hr.';,,'J)d,.., ~ ~ . p/~,.;._ ,;u,_J ~,,tJc:.,.s.c . -6a..:-✓,r-11 ~- S.T..fr..,:e__ 
.. _. ____ . _ __ ____ .A~.:rs- _1:;M~-~--'1>:1.41'1-,,_ I·"' ~--·7.t..c.-..- f2-e.n:'71~ .. we2:~...., __ -tfe,.?..C=p,;;...11.<..~ 4_· f:r"'-) 
r,,. \" '') 
--- --- __ 'inr.~~,.~ __ :J~~&-l!>t:: ~[f"',..,19) /·~~Ji .eevwol.l,,(eu~_s,,.,.. . 
_I?~_ llfJ,11...; ,, __ J 1~-u: . .• ~, 5 . &?.,.,an. ___ ,a_ck' ,...,.wl .... d,_~....:;:;- -~- .,5--:,,,.n--.,,e 
. ________ .•. -W."!11. ---~""7--· ~;,,;U,"""j·t:t:IJ. N.r.1 "'ltti!/ .& &,-p--/4.,,_.--s h.)_, -e~.re.,, ~FJ 
J, J I rk. . '..J!..t.· . 
. _____ . _ • . lkxH4-"T~.·- ~- _ 0_1,, I .. a..... 'I!' ~ • .c:a,...,s :n..714.1'?~ --~- -.,,._,, ~-.r 11'1-f""" •"'-•iT' 
_____ 7& __ ,:~1.'lW~. ·r~r -'/Le .. 4,~~. 1-v..c..(~«e./.~1..-~n:.... ~--Pl.<€,s:;.:.~ ... cl 
,, 
• AA,J • ~ .,..,,,, ,. I . • /. ~ ,, 
.•;:-_t;_t_,S,e. _____ • _"Nfl.~ __ IY'lt<p 1_1;~71--S / <?fwU,f:£_ .ki·.•rr,..,,../f'-(ZJ_,p'X?_ 7'c 
q""-'1 ,£~,,.__ .. 4 4~......_ :,/,i> ~ l.v~1< --,f!."'Y.111--7.:.r.-✓.'tc' 1.r. d~e,d4..r 
.. __________ ._(I._ .~i/J,tytJd7~~¥.1.,n,i ... ~ , :tCc.;s C~ .... 1-( "'t ~4,1,.,._..,_,b~ ~.,,z.,.,-,._7»,;,,;.___ 
... , --- f---~----~-$-X,,.'Jid .. ~ _t1,1;_,e)..,_:T)...;;._;:._/;_) r.k-~§'-~~• 2,_,c..~ 
-------- --------~ ___ a,_ .. !S('pl ,~d __ c.,.d=c~.rvr.S7"...,~. ~ -~-r""t!!,:,,/ -c-Ni.;..s .-h?~ rt:.,. 
e:i' ~,-!"I ,,v, •~~.,,.'JJ•r,,,! -e X J.. • k.~1'1,;,,.._ ,:'Ro&<-5 S -,4 /;-~ /4.e-1,,-. ~IJ>'CA!)} 5~ 
:,/~_,_,- J 0 O.&-y;?;J:.!,_ °J~l(l.l!t•/1~'',., .... -:-r. 6c ,-._ f.1, h ~:,;,..,-n.;._/ ('/,wf' /1~,.u:~ ~/,._,--.,., /,~. 
_/-,_, __ -7,k _')m--,.,:.L. _-r,ne·12n~ ~, _'. •~ ... ,_ b ,d...,. 
_t11A..1-~~-~.J' -W4*-,"'·b=,·,,.,,at,. 'hJI. ~ /11.'TlZ-,a 
______ h-)- _5_~-_,_,.~ __ d(.,_HJ- _ ,,,._~__,,,,.7- ✓-. i.. -4 .,.,, . /?"~.r..- u/..,,,___ .-n::,. /--t:.~u1~.- ... 
---•·------- ~,..,.,_~-- A_~,,,,~,-~, .. "S.?7-o~--C-'JJ~r---~-j W✓~- ~-~-,/ <>-('>__/$ ~"1-:C 8,.""f1. 
··---- ---- /tJ .. J' .... "'-l rik, ?-,-'_l,-i_2~f.3.::y_L't, .... .,LL~~~)---------·-----·--------------------- -- .... Digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, BYU. 
Machine-generated OCR, may contain errors.
o.,.,,,>_ ;7"5 · ~t!e ,1 No.P.- --~'1/'1/,;r,;,.. hr.; /t!<e. ,s,.,.,s., · /24 . ,, l1.e., . e/rJ-.-.., :,::rr. .. .l,4,1,d} 
- --~ .,-.,..e.o-ri~. 7.\.):. _(', :'-l-/3a.9..J-(},.J (c!) c:~_..,,,,✓._#J ~/,~t:" -~"'7-~.r 
w Iv-.. :e,fl.,14~<1-n;._; . 1- e;..l!rno;,,i.'TC.o.:11w u,-...l'r:-u .",/~ ~- .c.,:,,-,~e.~d ., (4e..,&;z 
,o 1 :1 1 I s..,,. f'Ate <I\ 1 -r, 1,:,.) ::. ~ . 
. -~- . 
1 -~ S7?9~/•·..., ,u,-,.,.,,/ .-n•b:,oeal'/'J~ ''1 1 f,e,-.,q,,._,f d.,/?_;c_.,,~:r 7 . ,._,.,..✓,.') I ... S-,-,.~~.e . ../ ~, '_'i!lt!l?~.'f'1 ~--. 6u.,,RJ.,.~hu::4. ".S: ;u~, ,:a ... ~,,;;,I, Pl> .. ~~-1'-('rJ', -(' 
! d..,,._ :S.~ ,., . .J..,.~ .h'5 :w,~-",...,. 4,_/_ -~e ~;..,;'r.J<N-S ; -4e -h.:,,(,1,,1~,,,/ ...._./'7 ~ 
' I -~ .-£~-r '1 . d..c. ·6 d4/e. fr.Jd-r--,. rt:... .. ,e. ✓"j'·l,r- .·rr> .k,,1>-e. r:r, :1AAd-t!-tt.. 
I 
- - -- · 5' :nii-n-n-c. . . ,ll.. .. c~-.,, -,.,.,n,,,;p../ 
~ . ·? __ &.c-~ .. e4~.~ar, .4,hl.:~ .. '',,._,"~;"? ,, -_~_.,,.,.,J 7-r>·~.-~ .. ~'-t 
- ':_ . /J9'ft. .. 'S"~- -'••"4 IZ!!'A ,._,_ ,fo-12,. e:/.,--~~,.J' ·N,,/.,u.~$ /~ A~~ H. ?l!I ~ 
. ;t'He.sr; .. k-t'~'1 -1.is<..-:~.., ~ "/',,,. 7.,-..,_.:,_1,.,.,._ 7 ./h /';e~;z.77,.,"µ~ 
~IVIU /,,:;,.Id' /4:~-.,,._,,_J Rr-f'hT:J /-<J-t!','%e. i<Je,r V/;,,)IR_,e,1 _ ,X,._> 
·-·~ .£~,-. _..,,-t ___ .l),~17Z-.,,t!r. .. 0-:~~ -~ fl, .1~"~ _..,,._:be,,s,./ 
hls- d,~~~ ~ -~-'<.ie""j· ~~~s----1., -.,-,,/ -~~"2/,c.-.n.,,;.. ... J 
n:, 5"7?9-7;,v',4J ~T7'n.:~h7J ;:;le'~·?>:J ...,~ £~e: 
·. d✓-s-ne..,~:r .. &-,,,1e-;- .,/5'--e;:r,.._, a.s .. ~ A3?~,/ e~'744.,...;s, .. 
_ '_ _::;__v, ~~e,,.),,4" _ ✓ ~t:::.a.r>-T,R-.7';,;_ ~ -~.z:g, .. J...SF~.. 4 .. ~.-.n.;.~~?:. 1-/9-. :al.[; -~'<-_,;; ;::-. 
. •\ ·. 
- l 1._ ~ : ~.nv..-.v 7 ,t?t w. ;,<::;,,z. . AJt?Ti(!,r u (~4.,,,r. ~ .!!. /.,..~~- i.,r.,., 
llt'f"-,::,/ "1A.(. hJ C'TS ,:?) Re ~ ~er1d,<77W Tv S' ~- ~~ q r.?r~•uv,O .S:, 
? 
I ( -~ '5:r~,-< c-.,,.__, c..-d-< .r Sn,:;,-.AJ,""1 ) (6/,r,-t,r,.,,.,,,-J ,..-,- µ., 1 >"'J"'L") 
I- /1 ~r:"~,,._;r Un,--,4 .,c;.,,4d.,..f 0/1'77'?,c·r (;y.,ei- ,:,2,,,, /4·,-J-:; ?.G;HPdlV;?·-t: 
U, uo~ee,,n,r/2 ,;:?,tJ/?_ "'-IL 5r~C..0.'7"'J (5'"-31.--::i,rN''>)) /2,::,.JJJ 
I 
~~-:--."4 tr~•,J.'f.~,_r 6as.,~ j4.-i.> (6.-eA:e V 'l-/5.7 91_.tA.c!/J); -&/"IT./,..,. 
, a.( ... .1./r,-, . ..-d--~eMI~ /·~"-,,/.. P'M .. 4 ,.._"f'/7t/°/;.;.d',_~"fjl .... 11-.p.e. ;,-.::rs ·r'f 
.... A.Pe .A.,~/.. .".1'-' ,:!) , , ~;-.) .e,e J ... (!.gT~Y""' "21 /✓ ./1 ,,..,_e 'f>f"f;? S : ~ ·'- (' <?'IA er 
-- .f"~~-. m-.K ,_,.,, I:, e.:,,.q/44. .. ,":tRd;.lP.H.WC..,,,:7[ V'°".'-<'J fl ..I:;__, V«i"h.~.,.. -~J(j::d .. 'i: I'~- :) :> Digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, BYU. 
Machine-generated OCR, may contain errors.
. ,/ ~- .. "$~~$ t'~TlTlATJ~~ . 'S h&7,i/e,/ 15""5JA.e. / /'£/P4 
····-·· ·-- ...... - . 7:'P._,11~ -:IC.11~ c::,/{J7¥/~ e,,,,;:,y,~ ""1 l!.J?~ dJ :,t(' t&Tr'-'1 ./<11,,c/ vlf.Jj 
..... ·····-· _______ .'11i-c d.c//.,~.r-./ ::J. 7:».n,:,-e. .,,,.,,_,/_,'::rj_ (!,.,,/T~a"1i"f<-r✓ '-J _,., ..._J v--r.,-""c __ . 
. -- --- -- . -- 4__.::,a_d,_~_J d'dc.,,.s:re.d.. /:n'r.- ,6k_,J......_.~ f)qO'N~:n-✓ r'.e✓.;_n~ 
__ -···---- -··-·- _ --~-:,r.~ _/,,-,..,,_;,,/'_/-;;,:1,_,.., p,u,v-,r-7h.., ,,C'~~--rjJ-<~e/4,.,141'.S~e'l"'SJ<M 2· 
~'"'? ; -f!!.J#.1.l!.,,.n~ ~-- .<1'9:"'"-T.1,,-/>'11/45 . .1efJ_ d,,J.,:r~,t;,4 ,_~ '2 ~ 
/4..,4. -1 ~IJ--/7~/,s.,,,,._,t!.. _,,,._~ ~~ ~~PIA.,._.,.//,;,,....,_, d:~ ~ h,,,.-7-P,.S,.. 
··-- .. ... '3 4 c~~ -/ 7 (P~ blo,1.,/ ~~"':':.i"'~ M./x::;__ ~f:..1v!.,.,J) _"'-"1-:#J,,,.,., _ 
___ __ _ ________ . p//1.w..1...,. -~ 5'J>.9n..n-e.s.. <'.J(r',,zdJ _w,,r,:;,/f~ .. hrr.:?X.,~ -~ ~~,tt=r 
. --------------- _{',,.,,.~r,1/"-- -.p~l7 A~ /'"~-? ~ s~1Wre...1/'?~,s,./ d.e. b1"""-6 
!'~el:~ .. :rt, -~.....t'e&.s ~- d~~~,,_s- ;J ,1~ §.a~ "f' 7"-:7),,,~, '11'Ld" 
.. _.,r;,, 1~-L _:,z) .a✓✓A'J'.I -""7 . ~,,._,s_7>_'nf71,,,,._,/ c::;/.,.,M P~ .h>t:r~17.5. ~V✓•/A.J .. 
-? ~ £c.13 . ..b.e.~ ~1t:w r"'f'/¥. ~ £'-:I'~,...- 'J ~. '5'~7k~. >T!9n-.~ 
n,,-,ir -rr,z.-c:,c,S .. R. 11 1, 1 4,,,._r e.,,.,,._,, ~ c'h-.,.,1, -,;C.1/ri.-e../ .. 
_ !8rr./J.z.✓. /1'-. -;;tzr1 e-..12-;- ,·.s .1~-,r ef;.J e.l'/~.I?:~ 11-t--; v,e.w ;?( 
_ 1J...e_ 1$2,et,,1,1 VJc.r ... Aed1~,1,A,_ I '11 f ~ '96 J s 7Vdt- :S-:1'l,9-n.-,)--'.. -~ tt,, ~- fs. 
_.be_,_"1 ,::;<,,,1w""7'1!£/ ,::II nc/ (!""4'~J~Ae7 72:> cl'~7 ~✓.; )r;:J a.r ~,,. /I df; :S . 
. 4/'t!'NJJ 2 ,£',-..d,,;,,,,u....._,./ ~~-,-h7? I~ -h,,/~ 7V ~ re ,1 -4<.1 -"'<"C~~,n,-,,,// 
t::JS C;'T'f'J Ar,lllfl,t!'1'il...,,,J .,;::,, ~,e. ~l'/f--"---t' J,r:,eu,,,_ ....... ~ y /,;,..e ~/.J 
. _____ --f.'~ ~ "'t'/U-IJ,,,,~/ ~nii,,.,:.;1<. J ~.., A>~--e <.a ~~ ,.,.,,~ 4,e:-,.J., Le . .1 r,. 
~ A'S._e'✓~.;ef)., /Z..5petrrC) J7 -:1~ J.m,Jh::'cll, 
~~-----·· 
g-2:'t-/2 
..L. CrPn ') . Z ,..,,_, 1.-.J? e. <77 1 .,-1.u /Z,p 17 ~ ,e;..,,;/ ~ n(; · /-1,-,.,,~7 
. 6~"-L/#.,,.,.,,./ ;t.'["' I 6tJ r. So,::P 5. sr!, .c;_ I 5.L..c; J-?1· 8''7/ I SI -o [f''S'!i') ,6) 
6.lt'ir _ c /.,. H. m,, ;-J ~rs .::/4-.<. #> 
----·· 
Digitized by the Howard W. Hunter Law Library, J. Reuben Clark Law School, BYU. 
Machine-generated OCR, may contain errors.


Mark Elden Erickson, Petitioner/Appellant v.  Alfred Bigelow, Respondent/Appellee.

Worley, Maren

Holding Investment Bankers Liable for Aiding and Abetting Corporate Directors: The Under-deterrent

Myers, Richard S.

The Constitutionality of Laws Banning Physician Assisted Suicide

BYU Law Review
Volume 2017 | Issue 3 Article 2
May 2017
BYU Law School Faculty Listing
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview
This Frontmatter is brought to you for free and open access by the Brigham Young University Law Review at BYU Law Digital Commons. It has been
accepted for inclusion in BYU Law Review by an authorized editor of BYU Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact
hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu.
Recommended Citation
BYU Law School Faculty Listing, 2017 BYU L. Rev. (2018).
Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview/vol2017/iss3/2
 BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY 
J. REUBEN CLARK LAW SCHOOL FACULTY 
 
 
ANDERSON, CURTIS B. (2015), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1991, J.D., 1994, Brigham Young 
University. 
 
ASAY, CLARK D. (2014), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2001, Brigham Young University; M.A., 
2002, University of Cambridge; J.D., 2007, Stanford Law School. 
 
AUGUSTINE-ADAMS, KIF (1995), Charles E. Jones Professor of Law. B.A., 1988, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 1992, Harvard Law School. 
 
BAIR, STEPHANIE PLAMONDON (2015), Associate Professor of Law. B.S., 2001, University of Prince 
Edward Island; Ph.D., 2008, University of Utah; J.D., 2012, Harvard Law School. 
 
CLARK, ELIZABETH A. (2005), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 1994; J.D., 1997, Brigham Young 
University. 
 
COLLINGS, JUSTIN M. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2006, Brigham Young University; 
J.D., 2010, Ph.D., 2013, Yale University. 
 
COOK, BENJAMIN J. (2016), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1998, M.A./M.Ed., 2001, Brigham 
Young University; J.D., 2005, Georgetown University Law Center. 
 
DANIELS, BRIGHAM (2010), Associate Professor of Law. M.P.A., 2000, University of Utah; J.D., 2003, 
Stanford Law School; Ph.D., 2010, Duke University. 
 
DOXEY, GARY B. (2005), Associate Director of International Center for Law and Religion Studies. 
B.A., 1980, J.D., 1984, Brigham Young University; Ph.D., 1992, Cambridge University. 
 
DURHAM, W. COLE JR. (1976), Gates University Professor of Law and Founding Director of                 
International Center for Law and Religion Studies. B.A., 1972, J.D., 1975, Harvard University. 
 
FEE, JOHN E. (2000), Professor of Law. B.A., 1992, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1995,               
University of Chicago. 
 
FLEMING, J. CLIFTON JR. (1974), Ernest L. Wilkinson Chair and Professor of Law. B.S., 1964, 
Brigham Young University; J.D., 1967, George Washington University. 
 
GEDICKS, FREDERICK M. (1990), Guy Anderson Chair and Professor of Law. B.A., 1977, Brigham 
Young University; J.D., 1980, University of Southern California. 
 
GERDY, KRISTIN B. (1995), Teaching Professor and Director, Rex E. Lee Advocacy Program. B.A., 
1992, J.D., 1995, Brigham Young University. 
 
GORDON, JAMES D. III (1984), University Assistant to the President for Planning and Assessment, and 
Marion B. and Rulon A. Earl Professor of Law. B.A., 1977, Brigham Young University; J.D., 
1980, University of California, Berkeley.  
 
HERNANDEZ, CARL III (2001), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1988, J.D./M.P.A., 1992, Brigham 
Young University. 
 
HURT, A. CHRISTINE (2014), Associate Dean and Rex J. and Maureen E. Rawlinson Professor of Law. 
B.A., 1990, Texas Tech University; J.D., 1993, University of Texas School of Law. 
 
JENNEJOHN, MATTHEW C. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2002, Brigham Young              
University; MSc, 2004, London School of Economics; J.D., 2007, Columbia University School 
of Law. 
 
JENSEN, ERIC TALBOT (2011), Professor of Law. B.A., 1989, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1994, 
University of Notre Dame; LL.M., 2001, The Judge Advocate General’s School; LL.M., 2006, 
Yale Law School. 
 
MOORE, DAVID H. (2008), Associate Dean and Wayne M. and Connie C. Hancock Professor of Law. 
B.A., 1992, J.D., 1996, Brigham Young University. 
 
NIELSON, AARON L. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2003, University of Pennsylvania;  
LL.M. 2006, University of Cambridge; J.D., 2007, Harvard Law School. 
 
NÚÑEZ, D. CAROLINA (2007), Associate Dean and Professor of Law. B.A., 2001, J.D., 2004, Brigham 
Young University. 
 
RASBAND, JAMES R. (1995), University Academic Vice President and Hugh W. Colton Professor of 
Law. B.A., 1986, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1989, Harvard Law School. 
 
SCHARFFS, BRETT G. (1997), Francis R. Kirkham Professor of Law and Director of International    
Center for Law and Religion Studies. B.S.B.A., 1986, M.A., 1987, Georgetown University; 
B.Phil., 1989, Oxford University; J.D., 1992, Yale Law School. 
 
SHOBE, GLADRIEL D. (2016), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2003, Brigham Young University; 
J.D., 2010, Yale Law School; LL.M., 2011, New York University. 
 
SHOBE, JARROD E. (2016), Associate Professor of Law. B.S./B.A., 2005, Arizona State University; 
J.D., 2011, Yale Law School. 
 
SMITH, D. GORDON (2007), Dean and Glen L. Farr Professor of Law. B.S., 1986, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 1990, University of Chicago Law School. 
 
STAHELI, KORY D. (2007), Director, Law Library. B.A., 1984, J.D., 1987, M.L.I.S., 1991, Brigham 
Young University. 
 
STANCIL, PAUL J. (2014), Professor of Law. B.A., 1993, University of Virginia; J.D., 1996, University 
of Virginia School of Law. 
 
STEELE, MICHALYN (2011), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 1992, M.A., 1994, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 2001, Georgetown University Law Center. 
 
SUN, LISA GROW (2008), Professor of Law. B.S., 1994, University of Utah; J.D., 1997, Harvard Law 
School. 
 
WARDLE, LYNN D. (1978), Bruce C. Hafen Professor of Law. B.A., 1971, Brigham Young University; 
J.D., 1974, Duke University. 
 
WELCH, JOHN W. (1980), Robert K. Thomas University Professor of Law. B.A., 1970, M.A., 1970, 
Brigham Young University; J.D., 1975, Duke University. 
 
WORTHEN, KEVIN J (1987), University President, and Hugh W. Colton Professor of Law. B.A., 1979, 
J.D., 1982, Brigham Young University. 
ADJUNCT FACULTY 
 
AFFLECK, ADAM S. 
BALLARD, MICHAEL 
BARBER, KATHRYN R. 
BARLOW, MATTHEW A. 
BENSON, DEE V. 
BRADY, EVA M. 
BRAMBLE, CATHERINE E. 
CUNDICK, TED 
DUNN, ALEXANDER P. 
DUTCHER, DAVID 
FERRIN, SCOTT 
GIGGER, JOSHUA G. 
GLADE, LEEANN 
GOODSELL, ERIN E. 
GOODWIN, SCOTT D. 
GRIFFITH, SUSAN W. 
HARDMAN, EMILY 
 
HOPKINS, STEVEN W. 
HORTON, KENNETH 
JENSEN, MARY O. 
KIMBALL, DALE A. 
LEAVITT, PETER D. 
LEE, JORDAN 
LEE, THOMAS R. 
LEWIS, MATTHEW R. 
LINTON, MORRIS D. 
LORIMER, BRENT P. 
MANDERINO, CHASE 
MATIS, GREGORY J. 
MCCULLOUGH, LEE S. 
MURRAY, KEVIN R. 
OWEN, STANFORD B. 
PARKER, KIMBALL 
PEAD, DUSTIN B. 
 
 
PERRY, AUDREY L. 
ROMNEY, VERNON F. 
SCHAERR, GENE C. 
TAYLOR, RYAN J. 
TENNEY, RYAN 
THOMAS, SUSANNAH 
TIPPETT, ROBERT S. JR. 
TODD, DAVID R. 
VAN WOERKOM, DANIEL 
WALKER, JEFFREY N. 
WARNER, PAUL M. 
WATERMAN, STEVEN T. 
WEILER, TODD D. 
WELCH, MEGAN 
WISE, JANE H. 
 
 


BYU Law School Faculty Listing

Peddy, Alexis M.

Dangerous Classroom  App -titude: Protecting Student Privacy from Third-Party Educational Service Providers

Brigham Young University Journal of Public Law
Volume 31 | Issue 2 Article 1
4-1-2017
Frontmatter
Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/jpl
Part of the Law Commons
This Frontmatter is brought to you for free and open access by BYU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Brigham Young
University Journal of Public Law by an authorized editor of BYU Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact
hunterlawlibrary@byu.edu.
Recommended Citation
Frontmatter, 31 BYU J. Pub. L. [vii] (2017).
Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/jpl/vol31/iss2/1
  
 
The BYU Journal of Public Law has been published since 1986 
by the J. Reuben Clark Law School.  
The Journal publishes scholarly articles on topics in public law: 
the relationship between governments and their citizens,  
the association between governments, and  
the effects of governmental entities upon society. 
 
 BYU Journal of Public Law 
Volume 31  Number 2 
2017 
 
The BYU Journal of Public Law publishes two issues per year  at the 
J. Reuben Clark Law School, Provo, Utah. ISSN 0896-2383. Standard 
Mail prepaid at Lincoln, Nebraska, and at additional mailing offices.  
 
Postmaster:  
Send address changes to the BYU Journal of Public Law, Accounting 
Office, 368 JRCB, Provo, Utah 84602. 
 
Subscriptions:  
Rates:  United States: $14/issue, $20/year, $36/2 years, $50/3 years. 
 International:  $17/issue, $25/year, $46/2 years, $65/3 years. 
 
Subscriptions are renewed automatically unless a discontinuance request 
is received. Claims for undelivered issues must be made within three 
months of publication for U.S. subscribers or six months for interna-
tional subscribers. Send all subscriptions correspondence to the BYU 
Journal of Public Law, Accounting Office, 368 JRCB, Provo, Utah 
84602. 
 
Back issues in complete sets, volumes, or single issues may be obtained 
from William S. Hein & Co., Inc., 1285 Main Street, Buffalo, New York 
14209; (800) 828-7571; http://heinonline.org. 
 
Submissions: 
The Journal welcomes manuscript submissions. Each manuscript should 
be in Microsoft Word format, double-spaced, 12-point serif font. Sub-
missions should include the author’s CV and a cover letter with a short 
description of the manuscript. The Journal prefers submissions via  
ExpressO. Authors may also submit manuscripts electronically to 
lawjour@byulaw.net. 
 
Copyright Requests: 
Send all articles communications to the BYU Journal of Public Law, 
471H JRCB, Provo, Utah 84602. Except as indicated in individual arti-
cles, the Journal grants permission for articles to be copied for class-
room use if (1) a proper notice of copyright is affixed to each copy, (2) 
the author and source are identified, (3) copies are distributed at or be-
low cost, and (4) the BYU Journal of Public Law is notified of the use. 
 
Content: 
All views expressed in this publication belong to the authors alone and 
not the BYU Journal of Public Law or the J. Reuben Clark Law School. 
Citations follow the rules of The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Ci-
tation (19th ed. 2010) and The Chicago Manual of Style (16th ed. 
2010). Unless otherwise indicated, all editors are students at the J. Reu-
ben Clark Law School. 
 
Cite as: BYU J. Pub. L. 
 
Copyright © 2017 BYU Journal of Public Law 
  
 BYU Journal of Public Law 
Volume 31  Number 2 
2017 
 
Editor-in-Chief 
Daniel C. Chavez 
Managing Articles Editor 
 
Managing Publication Editor 
Elizabeth Mann  Kathryn Brinton 
Managing Administration 
Editor 
 
Managing Submissions Editor 
Steve Dearing 
John Sellers   
  
  
   
Executive Editors  Lead Editors 
Noah Chamberlain  Alexis King 
Bronwen Dromey  Morgan Luedtke 
Kohei Oman  Stephanie Nielson 
Kristen Overton  David Sexton 
Emily Page  Maurissa Weight 
  Maren Worley 
 
Associate Editors 
 
Chase Andrizzi  Colt Mund 
Jake Barney  Crystal Powell 
Tyler Christensen  Luisa Patoni Rees 
Barbara Finlinson  Ryan Ricks 
Janet Gauvin  Jordan Rex 
Ryan Hughes  Cami Stephenson 
Shad Larson 
Lisha Lisonbee 
Grey Lund 
Cate Mumford 
 
 Chase Terry 
Benjamin Thornell 
Emmanuelle Verdieu 
 
 
 
BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY 
J. REUBEN CLARK LAW SCHOOL FACULTY 
 
 
ANDERSON, CURTIS B. (2015), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1991, J.D., 1994, Brigham Young 
University. 
 
ASAY, CLARK D. (2014), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2001, Brigham Young University; M.A., 
2002, University of Cambridge; J.D., 2007, Stanford Law School. 
 
AUGUSTINE-ADAMS, KIF (1995), Charles E. Jones Professor of Law. B.A., 1988, Brigham Young Univer-
sity; J.D., 1992, Harvard Law School. 
 
BAIR, STEPHANIE PLAMONDON (2015), Associate Professor of Law. B.S., 2001, University of Prince 
Edward Island; Ph.D., 2008, University of Utah; J.D., 2012, Harvard Law School. 
 
COLLINGS, JUSTIN M. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2006, Brigham Young University; J.D., 
2010, Ph.D., 2013, Yale University. 
 
COOK, BENJAMIN J. (2016), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1998, M.A./M.Ed., 2001, Brigham 
Young University; J.D., 2005, Georgetown University Law Center. 
 
DANIELS, BRIGHAM (2010), Associate Professor of Law. M.P.A., 2000, University of Utah; J.D., 2003, 
Stanford Law School; Ph.D., 2010, Duke University. 
 
DOXEY, GARY B. (2005), Associate Director of International Center for Law and Religion Studies. B.A., 
1980, J.D., 1984, Brigham Young University; Ph.D., 1992, Cambridge University. 
 
DURHAM, W. COLE JR. (1976), Gates University Professor of Law and Founding Director of                 
International Center for Law and Religion Studies. B.A., 1972, J.D., 1975, Harvard University. 
 
FEE, JOHN E. (2000), Professor of Law. B.A., 1992, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1995, University of 
Chicago. 
 
FLEMING, J. CLIFTON JR. (1974), Ernest L. Wilkinson Chair and Professor of Law. B.S., 1964, Brigham 
Young University; J.D., 1967, George Washington University. 
 
GEDICKS, FREDERICK M. (1990), Guy Anderson Chair and Professor of Law. B.A., 1977, Brigham Young 
University; J.D., 1980, University of Southern California. 
 
GERDY, KRISTIN B. (1995), Teaching Professor and Director, Rex E. Lee Advocacy Program. B.A., 1992, 
J.D., 1995, Brigham Young University. 
 
GORDON, JAMES D. III (1984), University Assistant to the President for Planning and Assessment, and 
Marion B. and Rulon A. Earl Professor of Law. B.A., 1977, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1980, 
University of California, Berkeley.  
 
HERNANDEZ, CARL III (2001), Associate Teaching Professor. B.A., 1988, J.D./M.P.A., 1992, Brigham 
Young University. 
 
HOAGLAND, MARY H. (1994), Assistant Dean. B.A., 1978, Brigham Young University; M.A., 1982, San 
Diego State University; J.D., 1984, San Joaquin College of Law; Ph.D., 2007, Brigham Young Uni-
versity. 
 
HURT, A. CHRISTINE (2014), Associate Dean and Rex J. and Maureen E. Rawlinson Professor of Law. 
B.A., 1990, Texas Tech University; J.D., 1993, University of Texas School of Law. 
 
JENNEJOHN, MATTHEW C. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2002, Brigham Young University; 
MSc, 2004, London School of Economics; J.D., 2007, Columbia University School of Law. 
 
JENSEN, ERIC TALBOT (2011), Professor of Law. B.A., 1989, Brigham Young University; J.D., 1994, 
University of Notre Dame; LL.M., 2001, The Judge Advocate General’s School; LL.M., 2006, Yale 
Law School. 
 
MOORE, DAVID H. (2008), Associate Dean and Wayne M. and Connie C. Hancock Professor of Law. 
B.A., 1992, J.D., 1996, Brigham Young University. 
 
NIELSON, AARON L. (2013), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2003, University of Pennsylvania;  LL.M. 
2006, University of Cambridge; J.D., 2007, Harvard Law School. 
 
NÚÑEZ, D. CAROLINA (2007), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2001, J.D., 2004, Brigham Young Uni-
versity. 
 
RASBAND, JAMES R. (1995), Hugh W. Colton Professor of Law. B.A., 1986, Brigham Young University; 
J.D., 1989, Harvard Law School. 
 
SCHARFFS, BRETT G. (1997), Francis R. Kirkham Professor of Law and Director of International Center 
for Law and Religion Studies. B.S.B.A., 1986, M.A., 1987, Georgetown University; B.Phil., 1989, 
Oxford University; J.D., 1992, Yale Law School. 
 
 
SHOBE, GLADRIEL D. (2016), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 2003, Brigham Young University; J.D., 
2010, Yale Law School; LL.M., 2011, New York University. 
 
SHOBE, JARROD E. (2016), Associate Professor of Law. B.S./B.A., 2005, Arizona State University; J.D., 
2011, Yale Law School. 
 
SMITH, D. GORDON (2007), Dean and Glen L. Farr Professor of Law. B.S., 1986, Brigham Young Univer-
sity; J.D., 1990, University of Chicago Law School. 
 
STAHELI, KORY D. (2007), Director, Law Library. B.A., 1984, J.D., 1987, M.L.I.S., 1991, Brigham Young 
University. 
 
STANCIL, PAUL J. (2014), Professor of Law. B.A., 1993, University of Virginia; J.D., 1996, University of 
Virginia School of Law. 
 
STEELE, MICHALYN (2011), Associate Professor of Law. B.A., 1992, M.A., 1994, Brigham Young Uni-
versity; J.D., 2001, Georgetown University Law Center. 
 
SUN, LISA GROW (2008), Associate Professor of Law. B.S., 1994, University of Utah; J.D., 1997, Harvard 
Law School. 
 
WARDLE, LYNN D. (1978), Bruce C. Hafen Professor of Law. B.A., 1971, Brigham Young University; 
J.D., 1974, Duke University. 
 
WELCH, JOHN W. (1980), Robert K. Thomas University Professor of Law. B.A., 1970, M.A., 1970, 
Brigham Young University; J.D., 1975, Duke University. 
 
WORTHEN, KEVIN J (1987), University President, and Hugh W. Colton Professor of Law. B.A., 1979, 
J.D., 1982, Brigham Young University. 
ADJUNCT FACULTY 
 
AFFLECK, ADAM S. 
AVERY, ROBERT C. 
BACKMAN, JAMES H. 
BARBER, KATHRYN R. 
BARGER, W. BRAD 
BARLOW, MATTHEW A. 
BELNAP, ALLISON PHILLIPS 
BENSON, DEE V. 
BRADY, EVA M. 
BRAMBLE, CATHERINE E. 
BURDSAL, NATHAN 
CLEMES, KAREN M. 
CUNDICK, TED 
DOMINGUEZ, DAVID 
DUTCHER, DAVID 
FALE, HUTCH U. 
FARMER, LARRY C. 
FERRIN, SCOTT 
GIGGER, JOSHUA G. 
GLADE, LEEANN 
 
 
GRIFFITH, SUSAN W. 
GOODWIN, SCOTT D. 
HANSEN, BETH A. 
HARDMAN, EMILY 
HOWELL, J. DUSTIN 
JANIS, BLAIR E. 
JENKINS, JENS C. 
JENSEN, DANIEL A. 
JENSEN, MARY O. 
JOHNSON, ERIC T. 
KIMBALL, DALE A. 
KULBETH, K. MARIE 
LEAVITT, PETER D. 
LEE, JORDAN 
LEE, THOMAS R. 
LEHNHOF, LANCE S. 
LEWIS, MATTHEW R. 
LINTON, MORRIS D. 
MANDERINO, CHASE 
MATIS, GREGORY J. 
 
 
MCCULLOUGH, LEE S. 
MOURITSEN, STEPHEN C. 
MURRAY, KEVIN R. 
OLDHAM, J. LAVAR 
OWEN, STANFORD B. 
PEAD, DUSTIN B. 
ROMNEY, VERNON F. 
SCHAERR, GENE C. 
TAYLOR, RYAN J. 
TENNEY, RYAN 
TIPPETT, ROBERT S. JR. 
TODD, DAVID R. 
VOGEL, RYAN J. 
WALKER, JEFFREY N. 
WARNER, PAUL M. 
WATERMAN, STEVEN T. 
WEILER, TODD D. 
WELCH, MEGAN 
WISE, JANE H. 
 
 
  
 BYU Journal of Public Law 
Volume 31  Number 2 
2017 
 
Table of Contents 
 
ARTICLES 
 
 
Rebranding Death  
Angela Wentz Faulconer 
 
313 
Legalization of Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia:  
Foundational Issues and Implications 
Sean Murphy 
 
333 
The Constitutionality of Laws Banning Physician Assisted 
Suicide 
Richard S. Myers 
 
395 
 
COMMENTS 
 
 
Drought By Fifth Amendment: Debunking Water Rights as 
“Real” Property  
Jacqueline Carlton 
 
409 
OMG—Not Something to LOL About: The Unintended 
Results of Disallowing Warrantless Searches of Cell Phones 
Incident to a Lawful Arrest 
Parker Jenkins 
437 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


Frontmatter

APPELLEES\u27 BRIEF
Appeal from the Third District Court, Salt Lake County from orders enteredby the Honorable John Paul Kennedy

Heartwood Home Health & Hospice, Llc,, Plaintiff/Appellant,  v. Rita Huber, and Glenna Molyneux, Defendants/Appellees : Brief of Appellee

OPENING BRIEF OF APPELLANT LABOR COMMISSION
Appeal from the Final Order of the Third Judicial District Court inand for Salt Lake County, Honorable Su J. ChonNo. 12691863

Labor Commission Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Derek Price, Defendant-Appellee : Brief of Appellant

BRIEF OF APPELLANT
ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED
On appeal from:The Honorable Ernie W. JonesSecond Judicial District CourtDistrict Court No. 15490143

Brigham Young University

Not a member yet

Utah v. Lopez

Mark Elden Erickson, Petitioner/Appellant v. Alfred Bigelow, Respondent/Appellee.

Holding Investment Bankers Liable for Aiding and Abetting Corporate Directors: The Under-deterrent

The Constitutionality of Laws Banning Physician Assisted Suicide

BYU Law School Faculty Listing

Dangerous Classroom App -titude: Protecting Student Privacy from Third-Party Educational Service Providers

Frontmatter

Heartwood Home Health & Hospice, Llc,, Plaintiff/Appellant, v. Rita Huber, and Glenna Molyneux, Defendants/Appellees : Brief of Appellee

Labor Commission Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Derek Price, Defendant-Appellee : Brief of Appellant

Mary Ellen Robertson Petitioner/Appellee, v. Michael Stevens Respondent/Appellant : Brief of Appellant

41,790

43,674