5,046 research outputs found

    Universalism and junk

    No full text
    Those who accept the necessity of mereological universalism face what has come to be known as the junk argument due to Bohn [2009], which proceeds from (i) the incompatibility of junk with universalism and (ii) the possibility of junk, to conclude that mereological universalism isn't metaphysically necessary. Most attention has focused on (ii); however, recent authors have cast doubt on (i). This paper undertakes a defence of premise (i) against three main objections. The first is a new objection to the effect that Bohn's defence of that premise presupposes far too much. I show that one can defend premise (i) from a much weaker set of assumptions. The second objection, due to Contessa [2012], is that those who accept unrestricted composition should only accept the existence of binary sums (which are compatible with junk) rather than infinitary fusions. I argue that this conception of unrestricted composition is problematic: it is in conflict with an intuitive remainder principle. The final objection is due to Spencer [2012]. His view is that there is no absolutely unrestricted plural universal quantifier; so any statement of the unrestricted fusion axiom will simply not rule out the existence of junky worlds. I argue that the failure of unrestricted quantification will not be enough by itself to establish the existence of junk. Furthermore, it is not clear whether this view counts as a form of mereological universalism. As a result, I suggest that if one wants to reject the junk argument, premise (ii) is the only viable option.Peer reviewe

    Junk, T. R.

    No full text

    junk wood (junk of wood???)

    No full text
    junk n[PT] But the junks - take a junk about that big, what we call junk wood, for the stool, cut small in junks....YesJ. D. A. WIDDOWSON AUG 1973Used I and SupUsed I and Sup1Not Usedback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 201

    junk

    No full text
    junk nYou carried a junk o' wood an' a few splits under your arm every _ every morning....YesJ. D. A. WIDDOWSONUsed I and SupUsed I and Sup1Not Usedback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 201

    junk

    No full text
    junk n[PT] If it's just a short piece of wood long enough for the firebox of a stove it's called a junk.YesDNE-cit DNE-citJ. WIDDOSONUsed I and SupUsed I and Sup1Used Iback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 201

    junk

    No full text
    junk n[PT] ...it was those big bakin' pans, so long, an' they'd have he full of turrs or_ or rabbits, perhaps a piece o' pork. We killed most[ly] killed a pig for Christmas, an' you'd have your junk o' pork, perhaps in one end o' the pan, and perhaps something else over in th' other.YesDNE-cit J. D. A. WIDDOWSON AUG 1973Used I and SupUsed I and Sup2Used Iback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 201

    junk junks

    No full text
    junk n[PT] [PT] But the junks - take a junk about that big, what we call junk wood, for the stool, cut small in junks...YesJ. D. A. WIDDOWSON AUG 1973Used I and SupUsed I and Sup1Not Usedback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 201

    junk junks

    No full text
    junk n[PT] ...I don't know if /there was fourteen or sixteen hundred feet o' lumber - short junks about this length, you know, drift timber.YesJ. D. A. WIDDOWSONUsed I and SupUsed I and Sup1Not Usedback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 201

    junk junks

    No full text
    junk n[PT] ....they'd cut up the pork, fat back pork, in little squares, little junks, an' mix it up in the flour, an' bake it;YesDNE-cit J. D. A. WIDDOWSON AUG 1973Used I and SupUsed I and Sup2Not Usedback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 2015, stamped but not use

    junk (n)

    No full text
    junk n[PT] An' the drill, an' strike over your head or anywhere else. ....but, you know, 'twasnt refined then. It come out in junk, we'd say, you know, big pieces - thirty pounds, forty pounds, fifty pounds an' less, you know, an'...that's how it was shipped out; the ore was shipped out like that. (large piece; chunk. Said here of large pieces of ore drilled from a mine at Tilt Cove)YesDNE-cit J. D. A. WIDDOWSON MAR 1974Used I and SupUsed I4Used Iback junk, fore junk, middle junk, billet, junk of a boy, junk-buoy, a cold junkChecked by Jordyn Hughes on Tue 18 Aug 201
    corecore