7 research outputs found
Disaster Risk Reduction in the Built Environment in Sri Lanka- An overview
- Publication venue
- Publication date
- 2013
- Field of study
Natural disasters have long-term implications on sustainable development. They mainly destroy
the built environment thereby hindering economic and social development, and causing
environment degradation. Reducing the risk of natural disasters within the built environment is
therefore critical for ensuring sustainable development. The paper in this context, aims to
assess the current state of disaster risk reduction in the built environment in Sri Lanka.
Empirical data was collected employing semi-structured in-depth interviews which were
conducted with a group of professionals who were involved in disaster risk reduction in the
built environment in Sri Lanka. The data was analysed following thematic analysis. The paper
reveals the current state of disaster risk reduction in the built environment requires to be
improved to achieve a satisfactory level of success whilst highlighting a number of barriers that
hinder the desired progress. Deficient funds and weak regulatory framework are identified as
major barriers for successful implementation. Central and local government authorities are
identified as the primarily responsible parties for disaster risk reduction in the built
environment in Sri Lanka in the paper. The paper further presents various recommendations on
how to improve the current situation
Determinants of morbidity and mortality following emergency abdominal surgery in children in low-income and middle-income countries
- Author
- Nebiyou Seyoum Abebe (16238429)
- Ayman Nabawi (11579146)
- Mostafa Abdelkader (16237742)
- Abebe Bekele Zerihun (12883738)
- Frank Owusu (16238471)
- Yousra El Shoura (16238006)
- Eldaa Prisca Refianti Sutanto (16238597)
- Ourdia Bouali (16238450)
- Ahmed Fahiem (16238354)
- Maria Aguilera (16238519)
- Irene Montes (16237667)
- Sameer Kushwaha (16237655)
- Alaa Abouelnasr (16238195)
- Alexis P Arnaud (14044053)
- Ahmed Mosad (16238144)
- Safwat Al-Nahrawi (16238309)
- Tarek Razek (16237664)
- Mohamed A Baky Fahmy (16237727)
- Assmaa Badwy (16238300)
- Ahmed Ragab Nayel (16238117)
- Mona Rashad (16237898)
- Gehad Tawfik (7110857)
- Abdelrahman Mohammed (16237799)
- Tagang Ebogo Ngwa (16237643)
- Yasser Abd El Salam (16238165)
- Sarah Samy (16237973)
- Sally Elshanwany (16237994)
- Ahmad Abdel Fattah (16237754)
- Ibrahim Elzayyat (16237901)
- Amoudtha Rasendran (16238630)
- Stuart Fergusson (16237475)
- Ahmed Sabry El-Hamouly (16238180)
- Ahmed Ragab Soliman (16238384)
- Nichole Starr (7256987)
- Fred Alexander Naranjo Aristiza Ibal (16237682)
- Chintya Tedjaatmadja (16238603)
- Sara Maria Contreras Merida (16238540)
- Stephen Tabiri (6000194)
- Marilla Dickfos (16237571)
- Nader Abd El Hamid (16237820)
- Paul Kielty (16238651)
- Salma Said Elkolaly (16237853)
- Emad Ali Ahmed (16238228)
- Mario Contreras Urquizu (16238531)
- Ramdan Shaker (16238201)
- Esraa Ghanem (16237997)
- Mohamed Shaalan (13866044)
- Mohamed A Amer (16238174)
- Manuela Mendez (16237673)
- Mohamed Ali Ghoname (16238126)
- Abdalla Gharib (16237763)
- Michael Livingston (782017)
- Nicoleta Panait (13199028)
- Mohamed Ammar (1927399)
- Romeo Guevara (16238516)
- Mahmoud Abdulgawad (16237772)
- Guillaume Podevin (498513)
- Ahmad Almallah (16238129)
- Mohamed Hashish (16238363)
- Mohamed Husseini (16238372)
- Thuraya Alzayat (16238030)
- Afnan Altamimi (16237514)
- Khaled Abozeid (16238348)
- Mahmoud Salma (16237970)
- Mohammad Rashid (732254)
- Arnaud Bonnard (35748)
- Amr Fadel (16238225)
- Mohamad Baheeg (16237775)
- Anand Kirishnan (16238552)
- Miguel Siguantay (16238546)
- Aya Aboarab (16237979)
- Hasan Ismael Ibraheem Al-Hameedi (16238615)
- Gehad Samir El Sayed (16237865)
- Caoimhe Normile (16238636)
- Usama Hantour (16237835)
- Doaa Emadeldin Shafik (16238123)
- Asmaa Abdel-Rahman Al-Aarag (16237988)
- Alexandre Horobjowsky (16237658)
- Ahmad Aldalaq (16238255)
- Hayssam Rashwan (16237748)
- Ahmed Samir (16237982)
- Basma Magdy (12423374)
- Daniel Ardian Soeselo (16238600)
- Mohammed Alhendy (16237778)
- Ahmed Tammam (16238000)
- Omar Alahmady (16237838)
- Aliaa Gamal Toeema (16238057)
- Sebastian Shu (12136965)
- Mohamed Ameen (10795781)
- Soaad Elsobky (16238210)
- Emilie Eyssartier (16238459)
- Yasmin Elfouly (16238381)
- Georges Azzie (16237649)
- Erik Hervieux (12976919)
- Mostafa Gemeah (16237790)
- Ahmed Abdelmotaleb Ghazy (16237952)
- Nermeen Soubhy El-Shahat (16237874)
- Ashraf Morsi (16238168)
- Ewen M Harrison (11606837)
- Shorouk El Mesery (16238330)
- Claudio Fermani (16237538)
- Jason Brown (253739)
- Herman Cruz (16237697)
- Francisco Regalado (16238543)
- Mohamed Ghoneem (16237733)
- Luiz Carlos Barros De Castro Segundo (16237622)
- Mohamed Elzayat (16237883)
- Ahmad Nashaat (16238273)
- Mohammed Nasr (16237814)
- Antonio Leal (3600623)
- Hagar Zidan (16238066)
- Ehab Mamdouh (16238243)
- Karen Bailey (549958)
- Sunil Kumar (102321)
- Monique Moron Munhoz (16237607)
- Mohammad Ghassan Alwafai (16238231)
- Kresimir Zamarin (16237712)
- Maria Marta Modolo (14632463)
- Mai Salama (16237907)
- Billal Mansour (16237841)
- Mohamed Abuseif (16238063)
- Mohammed Ismail (14506799)
- Iman Elkadsh (16238285)
- Ali Mohamed Hammad (16238003)
- Aly Nasr (16238060)
- Mohamed Elfil (10731084)
- Neel Gobin (16237478)
- Ahmed Abo El Magd (16238213)
- Dalia Hemeda (16237904)
- Diaa Moustafa Elbendary Elsawahly (16237937)
- Rajeev Satoskar (16238591)
- Ahmed Sabry (12501380)
- Khalid Salah El-Dien (16237832)
- Rokia Sakr (16238204)
- Hunain Shiwani (9943820)
- Cheng Chun Goh (16237508)
- Giridhar H Devadasar (16237586)
- Amr Hasan (9745484)
- Sung-Hee Kim (11271393)
- Mahmoud Abdelshafy (12410814)
- Ahmed Safwan Marey (16238339)
- Mahmoud Amreia (16238207)
- Maria Isabel Villegas (16237676)
- Joseph Awuku-Asabre (16238474)
- Omar Saleh (825207)
- Kyriakos Psarianos (16238483)
- Hossam Elfeki (8939474)
- Mohamed Elsehimy (16238321)
- Hosni Khairy (16237487)
- Nigel Hall (3404000)
- Ahmed Hassan (3571610)
- Hager Tolba (16238147)
- Maria Clara Mendoza Arango (16237679)
- Robert Karlo (15205357)
- Ahmed Meshref (3620615)
- Aya Hagar (16238318)
- Marwa Elashmawy (16238270)
- Mohammed Mustafa Hassan Mohammed (16238402)
- Mohammed Bukari (8376354)
- Heba Shaker (16238099)
- Ahmed Lasheen (16238162)
- Ahmad Ali (4494817)
- Mostafa Seif (16238120)
- Olivier Abbo (13799447)
- Shravan Nadkami (16238576)
- Mahmoud Morsi (4390996)
- Ibrahim Abdel Fattah (16237781)
- Nermin Mohamed Badwi (16238399)
- J Edward F Fitzgerald (16237472)
- Mennat-Allah Mustafa (16238084)
- Radhian Amandito (7145585)
- Muhammad Rashid Minhas Qadir (16237592)
- Sabine Irtan (13199037)
- Yella Reddy (3479153)
- Marisa Leal (16237631)
- Fitriana Nur Rahmawati (16238606)
- Dan L Deckelbaum (16237661)
- Kwaku Boakye-Yiadom (16238468)
- Cesar Augusto Azmitia Mendizabal (16238525)
- Sara Ayad (16238198)
- Rahma Kamil (16238624)
- Mohamed Zidan (16238360)
- Harish Neelamraju Lakshmi (16238579)
- Ruben Balmaceda (16237541)
- Mohamed Sabry Ammar (16238081)
- Midhun Mohan (3621155)
- Mahmoud Saad (11560769)
- Mohamed Abozaid (16237805)
- Mahmoud Alrahawy (16238093)
- Ahmed Mokhtar (16238192)
- Hassan Ali Mostafa (16238153)
- Maria Mayasari (16238609)
- Osama Mohamed (6166004)
- Abeer Marey (16238216)
- Nikica Pezelj (16237715)
- Amr Tarek (16238219)
- Hatem El-Sheemy (16238246)
- Sriram Bhat (16238558)
- Dushyant Iyer (16237565)
- Alice Faure (3510887)
- Ahmed Abo Elazayem (16238267)
- Aliaa Sadek (16238054)
- Nikolaos Nikoloudis (16238501)
- Sara Abd Elmageed Barakat (16238069)
- Eman Adel Sayma (16238135)
- Ahmed Sakr (9759095)
- Sarah Abdelghany (16237961)
- Mohamed Fadel (12448285)
- Yves Aigrain (35750)
- Lotfy Eldamaty (16238312)
- Hazem Khaled (16237910)
- Mohamed Mustafa (3492749)
- Mohammed Mousa (3620618)
- Omar Khater (12539505)
- Yucel Cengiz (16237532)
- Juana Kabba (16237640)
- Brian Cameron (14177663)
- Ahmed Adel (8809749)
- Areej Tarek (16238111)
- Dmitri Nepogodiev (703061)
- Yasmin Abd Elrasoul (16238075)
- Omar Osman (16237787)
- Arnav Agarwal (649596)
- Daniel Dabessa (16238426)
- Vivien Graffeille (16238438)
- Fatimah I Elgendy (16238042)
- Daniel Youssef (16237568)
- Ahmed Mohamed Afifi (16237925)
- Ana Vega Freitas (16237481)
- Ewan Macdermid (16237544)
- Nicholas Phillips (2015242)
- Abdullah Gouda (16237757)
- Mariam Darweesh (16238288)
- Ahmed Fawzy (9332758)
- Laura Luque (16237511)
- Sebastian King (16237646)
- Angham Solaiman El-Ma'doul (16238141)
- Savni Satoskar (16238588)
- James Brown (425608)
- Walter Forno (16238513)
- Antje Oosterkamp (16237577)
- Hossam Dawoud (16238327)
- Aurelien Scalabre (16238432)
- Victor Manuel Quintero Riaza (16237688)
- Aya Elwaey (16238282)
- Mohamed Abdelraheim (16237886)
- Dmitri A Raptis (16237535)
- Zaynab M Elsayed (16238279)
- Sara Mehrez (16238018)
- Israa Abdullah Aziz Al-Azraqi (16238618)
- Ahmed Hafez El-Badri Kotb (16237808)
- Ahmed Afandy (16238189)
- Mahmoud Elkhadrawi (16237922)
- Yacoubou Imorou Souaibou (16237583)
- Sergio Estupinian (16238510)
- Fernanda Frade (16238435)
- Nesma Elfouly (16238390)
- Jakov Mihanovic (12136842)
- Mahmoud Gomah (16237745)
- Ismail Lawani (12136812)
- Ahmed Abd El Galeel (16237826)
- Samar Saad (12434298)
- Muhammad Saad Ali Muhammad Gohar (16237730)
- Ashrarur Rahman Mitul (12036842)
- Chetan Khatri (644807)
- Hisham Samih (16237955)
- Adesoji O Ademuyiwa (12983220)
- Ahmed Badr (16238297)
- Daniel Estuardo Marroquin Rodriguez (16238534)
- Mahmoud Mohamed Metwally (16237931)
- Linnea Mauro (16238642)
- James C Glasbey (12136746)
- Sherif Shehata (16238345)
- Justas Zilinskas (16237505)
- Abdelrhman Essam (16237895)
- Sarah Rayne (16237526)
- Richard William Gilbert (16238639)
- Sara Ghanem (16238276)
- Omnia Mosalum (16238186)
- Jaime Andres Montoya Botero (16237685)
- Gareth Irwin (4235590)
- Puneet Malik (16238582)
- Anastasia Bamicha (16238486)
- Anjana Sreedharan (16238561)
- Yasmin Makhlouf (16238087)
- Ahmed Gheith (16238378)
- Carlos Morales (9269296)
- Mohammad Abdulkhalek Habeeb (16238405)
- Gamal Shimy (16237724)
- Mohammad Abo-ryia (16238324)
- Cecile Muller (16238465)
- Jehad Hassan Youssif (16237868)
- Ivan Mendoza (3853423)
- Mohamed Asal (16237739)
- Jiheon Song (837627)
- Mohammed Osman Dablouk (16238645)
- Ahamed Hassan (16237721)
- Mohammed Hanafy (16237766)
- Ola Sherief Abd El Hameed (16238159)
- Sahlu Wondimu (16238414)
- Amira Atef Omar (16238156)
- Abdalrahman Adel (16237793)
- Ahmed Elgebaly (3500423)
- Khaled Naser El Deen (16237892)
- Abdullah Al-Mallah (16237769)
- Mohamed Etman (16238090)
- Abdelfatah Hussein (16237919)
- Caio Vinicius Barroso de Lima (16237634)
- Thomas M Drake (11606831)
- Luiza Sarmento Tatagiba (5552507)
- Khalid Mahmud (16237574)
- Mohamed Elazoul (16238306)
- Yasmein Hani (16238387)
- Abdelrahman Alkammash (16237817)
- Marwan Shawki (16237499)
- Sara Kharsa (16238240)
- Fathia Abd El-Salam (16238045)
- Valentine Parent (7581455)
- Ahmed Khyrallh (16237718)
- Mahmoud Ahmed Fathi Abozyed (16237859)
- Scott K D'amours (16237562)
- Ahmed Elkholy (16237991)
- Roxanne Chenn (16237550)
- Basem Sieda (16238396)
- Lucile Fievet (16238456)
- Abeer El Gendy (16238333)
- Abdelrahman Haroun (16237985)
- Nidhi Gyanchandani (16238555)
- Samuel Nigo (16237637)
- Abdelrhman Osama Elsebaaye (16237880)
- Abid Bin Mahamood (16238585)
- Mihael Radic (16237709)
- Ahmed Elkelany (16238105)
- Hager Ahmed (16238171)
- Maira Cassa Careta (16237628)
- Ibrahim Alyoussef (16238249)
- Jacqueline Sheehan (5990483)
- Pablo Ramazzini (16238528)
- Kjetil Soreide (8715852)
- Mona Hosh (16238024)
- Fatma Elkady (16237967)
- Salim Anderson Khouri Ferreira (16237625)
- Frehun Ayele Asele (16238423)
- Francis Abantanga (3494846)
- Aneel Bhangu (4320508)
- Mohammed Ubaid Alsaggaf (16237517)
- Eman Nofal (16237943)
- April Camilla Roslani (8367699)
- Sofia Mouttalib (16238447)
- Abdullah Dwydar (16238237)
- Mohamed Abbas (834428)
- Ahmad Elbatahgy (16238138)
- Rafael Araujo (162519)
- Dan Poenaru (3281121)
- Emad Mohamed Saeed Taha (16237847)
- Mohamed Moamen Mohamed (16238222)
- Juliana Menegussi (5552504)
- Jakeline Restrepo (16237691)
- Osama Seifelnasr (16238048)
- Lubna Sabeeh (16238621)
- Soliman Magdy Ahmed (16237871)
- Dimitrios Lytras (16238480)
- Augusto Zani (6278387)
- Nadin Elsayed (16238072)
- Ruqaya Kadhim Mohammed Jawad Al-Hasani (16238612)
- Amany Abouzahra (16238036)
- Muhammad El-Saied Ahmad Muhammad Gohar (16237736)
- Mohamed Abd El Slam (16238303)
- Mohamed Seisa (16237913)
- SS Prasad (16238549)
- Athar Eysa (16238051)
- Esraa Abdalmageed Kasem (16238375)
- Stephen J Chapman (16237493)
- Alejandro Munera (16237700)
- Nehal Yosri Elsayed Abdel-Wahab (16237856)
- Ehab Alnawam (16238258)
- Shaimaa Aql (16238366)
- Mario Lopez (6817022)
- Gustavo Recinos (16237496)
- Mostafa Allam (16238342)
- Ali Amin Ahmed Ata (16237811)
- Carlos Ivan Perez Velsquez (16238537)
- Francesco Pata (8715885)
- Osama Saadeldeen Ebrahim (16237928)
- Quentin Alimi (16238444)
- Ahmed Maher Menshawy Mesreb (16237796)
- Michael Hanrahan (16237502)
- Francoise Schmitt (16238462)
- Nebyou Seyoum Abebe (16238417)
- Sebastian Sierra (16237670)
- Gehad El Ashal (16238009)
- Dalia Alkhabbaz (16238261)
- Ahmed Fouad (8343690)
- Ahmed Raslan (11776126)
- Abouelatta Khairy Aly (16238252)
- Marwa Elshobary (16238351)
- Pamphile A Assouto (16237580)
- Ahmed El-Kelany (16238078)
- Attia Mohamed Attia (16237823)
- Reem Fakher (16237976)
- Vanessa Dina Palomino Castillo (16237604)
- Elodie Gaignard (16238441)
- Metwally Abo Raya (16237949)
- Nathalie Botto (16238453)
- Edgar Domini (16237706)
- Mohamed Elbermawy (16237946)
- Abd El-Rahman Hegazy Khedr (16237877)
- Ehab Abdulkader Hemida Ghazy Alnawam (16238234)
- Ahmed Gomaa (4115773)
- Eslam Elbanby (16237829)
- SV Kinnera (16238564)
- Gisele Moreira (16237610)
- Ahmed Mohammed (7004726)
- Semay Desta (16238411)
- Matthieu Peycelon (4458907)
- Abdalla Kenibar (16237784)
- Amel Hashish (15228034)
- Hisham Safa (16237940)
- Kyaw Phyo Aung (16237595)
- Monty Khajanchi (529773)
- Kholod Tarek Lasheen (16237850)
- Ayman Elwan (16238114)
- Hager Elwakil (16238096)
- Martin Jarmin (16237559)
- Richard Spence (16237523)
- Elsayed Gamaly (16238033)
- Hussein El-Kashef (16238108)
- Robert Kerley (16238633)
- Emad Abdallah (16238027)
- Ahmed Mohameden (16238291)
- Christos Anthoulakis (16238498)
- Caranj Venugopal (16238594)
- Ahmed Moustafa Saeed (16237862)
- Ahmed Negeida (16237484)
- Abdelaziz Osman Abdelaziz Elhendawy (16238369)
- Michael Edye (16237556)
- Lee Shi Yeo (16237598)
- Sarah Antar (16238015)
- Napoleon Mendez (16238522)
- Ahmed Abdelkareem (16238336)
- Amandine Martin (3106992)
- Abd Elrahman Elshafay (16237760)
- Rowida Elmelegy (16237934)
- Kareem Elshaer (16237916)
- Nikolaos Mitroudis (16238504)
- Shereen Elsheikh (16238039)
- Mohammed Firdouse (16237652)
- Mengistu Worku (16238408)
- Lemuel Davies Bray (16238477)
- Chean Leung Chong (16237589)
- Ibrahim Elzayat (16237889)
- Maha Gamal Mohamad Hamad (16238021)
- Efeson Thomas (16238420)
- Mahmoud Warda (4671655)
- Omar Salah (11367852)
- Abdallah Salah Elsherbiny (16238393)
- Abdelrahman Sayed (16237802)
- Diaa Eldin Abdelazeem Amin Elsorogy (16238150)
- Ahmed El Kholy (16237964)
- Sameh Sarsik (16238357)
- Shady Hussein (16238264)
- Zahra Jaffry (16237490)
- Amr Muhammad Elkorashy (16237844)
- Fathee Nada (16238315)
- Mohamed Karkeet (16237751)
- Noura Attallah (16238183)
- Asmaa Abdelgelil (16237958)
- Jenifa Jeyakumar (16237529)
- Mennaallah Hafez (16238294)
- Cheryl Ou Yong (16237553)
- Mohammed Saeed (3411002)
- Publication venue
- Publication date
- 2016
- Field of study
Determinants of morbidity and mortality following emergency abdominal surgery in children in low-income and middle-income countrie
Pooled analysis of WHO Surgical Safety Checklist use and mortality after emergency laparotomy
- Author
- Ayman Nabawi (11579146)
- Mostafa Abdelkader (16237742)
- Junyeong Oh (16238774)
- Yousra El Shoura (16238006)
- Isaac Hanley (16238693)
- Irene Montes (16237667)
- Sameer Kushwaha (16237655)
- Carolina Oliveira Felipe (16238732)
- Alexis P Arnaud (14044053)
- Ahmed Mosad (16238144)
- Tarek Razek (16237664)
- Mohamed A Baky Fahmy (16237727)
- Al Faifi Jubran (16239167)
- Ahmed Ragab Nayel (16238117)
- Mona Rashad (16237898)
- Gehad Tawfik (7110857)
- Andrew Kirby (47075)
- Abdelrahman Mohammed (16237799)
- Hosni Khairy Salem (16239011)
- Tagang Ebogo Ngwa (16237643)
- Clemens Nawara (16238696)
- Yasser Abd El Salam (16238165)
- Sarah Samy (16237973)
- Sally Elshanwany (16237994)
- Ana Vega Carreiro De Freitas (16238723)
- Ahmad Abdel Fattah (16237754)
- Ibrahim Elzayyat (16237901)
- Robert George (151235)
- Ahmed Sabry El-Hamouly (16238180)
- Mohamed Ali Ghonaim (16238813)
- Stephen Tabiri (6000194)
- Marilla Dickfos (16237571)
- Ahmad Gudal (16239164)
- Salma Said Elkolaly (16237853)
- Nicole D'aguzan (16238768)
- Sukrit Suresh (16239194)
- Esraa Ghanem (16237997)
- Mohamed Shaalan (13866044)
- Mohamed A Amer (16238174)
- Manuela Mendez (16237673)
- Yong Yong Tew (16239125)
- Abdalla Gharib (16237763)
- Michael Livingston (782017)
- Mohamed Ammar (1927399)
- Kithsiri J Senanayake (16239173)
- Mahmoud Abdulgawad (16237772)
- Ahmad Almallah (16238129)
- Thuraya Alzayat (16238030)
- Afnan Altamimi (16237514)
- Andre L Mihaljevic (16239020)
- Mahmoud Salma (16237970)
- Mohamad Baheeg (16237775)
- Piotr Major (3873568)
- Aung Kyaw Tun (16238708)
- Aya Aboarab (16237979)
- Gehad Samir El Sayed (16237865)
- Barbara Pereira Silvestre (16238726)
- Usama Hantour (16237835)
- Asmaa Abdel-Rahman Al-Aarag (16237988)
- Alexandre Horobjowsky (16237658)
- Hayssam Rashwan (16237748)
- Ahmed Samir (16237982)
- Basma Magdy (12423374)
- Alyne Daltri Lazzarini Cury (16238717)
- Mohammed Alhendy (16237778)
- Ahmed Tammam (16238000)
- Omar Alahmady (16237838)
- Cherry Koh (9983701)
- Aliaa Gamal Toeema (16238057)
- Sebastian Shu (12136965)
- Gustavo Pereira Fraga (5886425)
- Catherine A Shaw (16239032)
- Georges Azzie (16237649)
- Mostafa Gemeah (16237790)
- Ahmed Abdelmotaleb Ghazy (16237952)
- Vanessa Dina Palomino Castillo (16237613)
- Michael Stoddart (16239188)
- Nermeen Soubhy El-Shahat (16237874)
- Ashraf Morsi (16238168)
- Ewen M Harrison (11606837)
- Claudio Fermani (16237538)
- Stuart J Fergusson (16238687)
- Matei Bratu (16239155)
- Manuel Hache-Marliere (16238780)
- Abdulaziz Altwijri (16239161)
- Jason Brown (253739)
- Yasmin Abd-Elrasoul (16238807)
- Herman Cruz (16237697)
- Mohamed Ghoneem (16237733)
- Luiz Carlos Barros De Castro Segundo (16237622)
- Zhongtao Zhang (1355454)
- Mohamed Elzayat (16237883)
- Diogo Vinicius dos Santos (16238756)
- Mohammed Nasr (16237814)
- Amar Kourdouli (16239158)
- Bettina Lieske (15040031)
- Antonio Leal (3600623)
- Hagar Zidan (16238066)
- Afnan Altamini (16239044)
- Alphonse Zeta Mutabazi (16239023)
- Sunil Kumar (102321)
- Karen Bailey (549958)
- Monique Moron Munhoz (16237607)
- Alexia Farrugia (16239128)
- Kresimir Zamarin (16237712)
- Ahmed Menshawy (11154322)
- Mai Salama (16237907)
- Billal Mansour (16237841)
- Mohamed Abuseif (16238063)
- Mohammed Ismail (14506799)
- Ali Mohamed Hammad (16238003)
- James Glasbey (703059)
- Aly Nasr (16238060)
- Vanessa Msosa (16239122)
- Mohamed Elfil (10731084)
- Neel Gobin (16237478)
- Lawani Ismail (16239008)
- Sara W Al-Saqqa (16238999)
- Doaa Emadeldin (16238810)
- Dalia Hemeda (16237904)
- Diaa Moustafa Elbendary Elsawahly (16237937)
- Ahmed Sabry (12501380)
- Khalid Salah El-Dien (16237832)
- Hunain Shiwani (9943820)
- Cheng Chun Goh (16237508)
- Giridhar H Devadasar (16237586)
- Amr Hasan (9745484)
- Sung-Hee Kim (11271393)
- Ahmed Rslan (16238804)
- Juan Camilo Correa (16239104)
- Thiago Fernandes Giuriato (16238747)
- Mahmoud Abdelshafy (12410814)
- Giuliano Borda-Luque (16239002)
- Maria Isabel Villegas (16237676)
- Omar Saleh (825207)
- Mayaba Maimbo (16239203)
- Hossam Elfeki (8939474)
- Hosni Khairy (16237487)
- Nigel Hall (3404000)
- Hager Tolba (16238147)
- Cameron Fairfield (16238990)
- Maria Clara Mendoza Arango (16237679)
- Robert Karlo (15205357)
- Katherine Gash (16239197)
- Heba Shaker (16238099)
- Ahmed Lasheen (16238162)
- Mostafa Seif (16238120)
- Mahmoud Morsi (4390996)
- Rakan Kabariti (16239191)
- Mennat-Allah Mustafa (16238084)
- Radhian Amandito (7145585)
- Ragavan Narayanan (16239200)
- JC Allen Ingabire (12983229)
- John Whitaker (3524462)
- Dietmar Ofner (16239206)
- Richard Lilford (18779)
- Boris Marinkovic (16238762)
- Muhammad Rashid Minhas Qadir (16237592)
- Marisa Leal (16237631)
- Dan L Deckelbaum (16237661)
- Faustin Ntirenganya (11559270)
- Ruben Balmaceda (16237541)
- Mohamed Sabry Ammar (16238081)
- Midhun Mohan (3621155)
- Marie Carmela Lapitan (16239017)
- Mohamed Abozaid (16237805)
- Thomas G Weiser (12983232)
- Mahmoud Alrahawy (16238093)
- Hassan Ali Mostafa (16238153)
- Nikica Pezelj (16237715)
- Azmina Verjee (3496640)
- Sam Seisay (16239170)
- Dushyant Iyer (16237565)
- Tomas Poskus (9244740)
- Aliaa Sadek (16238054)
- Maria Marta Modolo (12136797)
- Sara Abd Elmageed Barakat (16238069)
- Eman Adel Sayma (16238135)
- Ahmed Sakr (9759095)
- Dmitri Raptis (16239179)
- Sarah Abdelghany (16237961)
- Hazem Khaled (16237910)
- Vassilis Kalles (16239110)
- Elaine Borg (9556817)
- Dion Morton (83420)
- Irene Ortega (11482761)
- Yucel Cengiz (16237532)
- Juana Kabba (16237640)
- Brian Cameron (14177663)
- Ahmed Adel (8809749)
- Areej Tarek (16238111)
- Dmitri Nepogodiev (703061)
- Yasmin Abd Elrasoul (16238075)
- Omar Osman (16237787)
- Arnav Agarwal (649596)
- Fatimah I Elgendy (16238042)
- Daniel Youssef (16237568)
- Ahmed Mohamed Afifi (16237925)
- Ana Vega Freitas (16237481)
- Ewan Macdermid (16237544)
- Nicholas Phillips (2015242)
- Abdullah Gouda (16237757)
- Laura Luque (16237511)
- Sebastian King (16237646)
- Romeo Lages Simoes (16238759)
- Angham Solaiman El-Ma'doul (16238141)
- James Brown (425608)
- Ruben Rivas (16238786)
- Antje Oosterkamp (16237577)
- Victor Manuel Quintero Riaza (16237688)
- Zineb Bentounsi (16239134)
- Mohamed Abdelraheim (16237886)
- Dmitri A Raptis (16237535)
- Ella Teasdale (16239185)
- Sara Mehrez (16238018)
- Ahmed Hafez El-Badri Kotb (16237808)
- Mahmoud Elkhadrawi (16237922)
- Thomas Pinkney (467511)
- Yacoubou Imorou Souaibou (16237583)
- Hannah S Thomas (16238984)
- Luis Alberto Valente Laufer (16238735)
- Anyomih Theophilus Teddy Kojo (16239014)
- Jakov Mihanovic (12136842)
- Mahmoud Gomah (16237745)
- Ismail Lawani (12136812)
- Ahmed Abd El Galeel (16237826)
- Yasmin Hegazy (16238801)
- Samar Saad (12434298)
- Donatas Venskutonis (16239119)
- Ashrarur Rahman Mitul (12036842)
- Omar Abdulbagi (16239176)
- Chetan Khatri (644807)
- Hisham Samih (16237955)
- Adesoji O Ademuyiwa (12983220)
- Mahmoud Mohamed Metwally (16237931)
- James C Glasbey (12136746)
- Osaid H Alser (16239143)
- Yuksel Altinel (8931545)
- Ahmed Altibi (3500429)
- Justas Zilinskas (16237505)
- Nader Abd El Hamid (16238792)
- Sarah Rayne (16237526)
- Alexandre Venancio De Sousa (16238714)
- Stella Binna Kim (16238711)
- Jaime Andres Montoya Botero (16237685)
- Antonio Ramos-De la Medina (16239029)
- Gareth Irwin (4235590)
- Peep Talving (4320574)
- Carlos Morales (9269296)
- Gamal Shimy (16237724)
- Haya Tahboub (16239140)
- Jehad Hassan Youssif (16237868)
- Jen Cornick (14761678)
- Ivan Mendoza (3853423)
- Roy Quek (16239116)
- Mohamed Asal (16237739)
- Fred Alexander Naranjo Aristizaibal (16239212)
- Ahamed Hassan (16237721)
- Mohammed Hanafy (16237766)
- Jessica Souza Luiz (16238753)
- Ola Sherief Abd El Hameed (16238159)
- Amira Atef Omar (16238156)
- Abdalrahman Adel (16237793)
- Ahmed Elgebaly (3500423)
- Khaled Naser El Deen (16237892)
- Abdullah Al-Mallah (16237769)
- Mohamed Etman (16238090)
- Abdelfatah Hussein (16237919)
- Caio Vinicius Barroso de Lima (16237634)
- Thomas M Drake (11606831)
- Luiza Sarmento Tatagiba (5552507)
- Stephen R Knight (16238987)
- Khalid Mahmud (16237574)
- Hager Ahmed El-badawy (16238816)
- Abdelrahman Alkammash (16237817)
- Marwan Shawki (16237499)
- Sayeda Nazmum Nahar (16239089)
- Fathia Abd El-Salam (16238045)
- Ahmed Khyrallh (16237718)
- Mahmoud Ahmed Fathi Abozyed (16237859)
- Scott K D'amours (16237562)
- Metwally Aboraya (16238798)
- Ahmed Elkholy (16237991)
- Roxanne Chenn (16237550)
- Abdelrahman Haroun (16237985)
- Samuel Nigo (16237637)
- Abdelrhman Osama Elsebaaye (16237880)
- Michael Walsh (49565)
- Wei Guo (86150)
- Mihael Radic (16237709)
- Ahmed Elkelany (16238105)
- Simon Stock (6683147)
- Maira Cassa Careta (16237628)
- Julia Guasti Pinto Vianna (16239209)
- Kjetil Soreide (8715852)
- Mona Hosh (16238024)
- Fatma Elkady (16237967)
- Salim Anderson Khouri Ferreira (16237625)
- Ibrahim AbdelFattah (16238789)
- Aneel Bhangu (4320508)
- Mohammed Ubaid Alsaggaf (16237517)
- Eman Nofal (16237943)
- April Camilla Roslani (8367699)
- Aneel Bhang (16239083)
- Fei Zheng (193006)
- Mohamed Abbas (834428)
- Ahmad Elbatahgy (16238138)
- Rafael Araujo (162519)
- Tom Arthur (16239086)
- Tyler Rouse (16239098)
- Emad Mohamed Saeed Taha (16237847)
- Juliana Menegussi (5552504)
- Jakeline Restrepo (16237691)
- Osama Seifelnasr (16238048)
- Soliman Magdy Ahmed (16237871)
- Augusto Zani (6278387)
- Nadin Elsayed (16238072)
- Sebestian Shu (16239149)
- Amany Abouzahra (16238036)
- Muhammad El-Saied Ahmad Muhammad Gohar (16237736)
- Mohamed Seisa (16237913)
- Luana Ayres Da Silva (16238741)
- Athar Eysa (16238051)
- Adewale O Adisa (16239026)
- Stephen J Chapman (16237493)
- Alejandro Munera (16237700)
- Nehal Yosri Elsayed Abdel-Wahab (16237856)
- Neil Smart (3837253)
- Gustavo Peixoto Soares Miguel (16238720)
- Gustavo Recinos (16237496)
- Luca Ansaloni (3568310)
- Diego Romani (16239146)
- Cutting Edge Manipal (16238690)
- Ali Amin Ahmed Ata (16237811)
- Francesco Pata (8715885)
- Osama Saadeldeen Ebrahim (16237928)
- Basant Kumar (14835478)
- Michael Hanrahan (16237502)
- Marina Luiza Pimenta (16238744)
- Sebastian Sierra (16237670)
- Gehad El Ashal (16238009)
- Tapan Kumar (9764999)
- Ahmed Fouad (8343690)
- Ahmed Raslan (11776126)
- Eugenio Grasset (16238765)
- Ahmad Uzair Qureshi (13433328)
- Pamphile A Assouto (16237580)
- Ahmed Negida (4390993)
- Fernanda Altoe (16238738)
- Attia Mohamed Attia (16237823)
- Reem Fakher (16237976)
- Philip Alexander (16238996)
- Maria Lorena Aguilera (16238993)
- Hafiz Hakim (16238705)
- Edgar Domini (16237706)
- Mohamed Elbermawy (16237946)
- Abd El-Rahman Hegazy Khedr (16237877)
- Ahmed Gomaa (4115773)
- Eslam Elbanby (16237829)
- Gisele Moreira (16237610)
- Ahmed Mohammed (7004726)
- Abdalla Kenibar (16237784)
- Hisham Safa (16237940)
- Alexis Arnaud (11516434)
- Kyaw Phyo Aung (16237595)
- Kholod Tarek Lasheen (16237850)
- Ayman Elwan (16238114)
- Hager Elwakil (16238096)
- Martin Jarmin (16237559)
- Richard Spence (16237523)
- Elsayed Gamaly (16238033)
- Hussein El-Kashef (16238108)
- Margub Hussain (16238702)
- Aurel Mironescu (16239152)
- Emad Abdallah (16238027)
- Ahmed Moustafa Saeed (16237862)
- Ibrahim Al-Slaibi (11514234)
- Michael Edye (16237556)
- Lee Shi Yeo (16237598)
- Sarah Antar (16238015)
- Paulo Alves Bezerra Morais (16238750)
- Emmy Runigamugabo (16239035)
- Oliver Warren (4386268)
- Abd Elrahman Elshafay (16237760)
- Rowida Elmelegy (16237934)
- Kareem Elshaer (16237916)
- Qinyang Liu (16239101)
- Florian Primavesi (6786002)
- Riinu Ots (7485878)
- Shereen Elsheikh (16238039)
- J Edward Fitzgerald (16239005)
- Mohammed Firdouse (16237652)
- Tanzeela Gala (16239137)
- Mengistu Worku (16238408)
- Roberto Macchiavello (16238771)
- Chean Leung Chong (16237589)
- Ibrahim Elzayat (16237889)
- Maha Gamal Mohamad Hamad (16238021)
- Ade Waterman (16239092)
- Chia Kong (16239182)
- Sylvia Batista Lemaire (16239215)
- Mahmoud Warda (4671655)
- Omar Salah (11367852)
- Abdelrahman Sayed (16237802)
- Abdelrhman Essam Elnemr (16238795)
- Diaa Eldin Abdelazeem Amin Elsorogy (16238150)
- Ahmed El Kholy (16237964)
- Zahra Jaffry (16237490)
- Aliyu Ndajiwo (12256673)
- Julio Jimenez (789609)
- Amr Muhammad Elkorashy (16237844)
- Mohamed Karkeet (16237751)
- Ainhoa Costas-Chavarri (5204594)
- Asmaa Abdelgelil (16237958)
- Jenifa Jeyakumar (16237529)
- Cheryl Ou Yong (16237553)
- Mohammed Saeed (3411002)
- Publication venue
- Publication date
- 2019
- Field of study
Abstract
Background
The World Health Organization (WHO) Surgical Safety Checklist has fostered safe practice for 10 years, yet its place in emergency surgery has not been assessed on a global scale. The aim of this study was to evaluate reported checklist use in emergency settings and examine the relationship with perioperative mortality in patients who had emergency laparotomy.
Methods
In two multinational cohort studies, adults undergoing emergency laparotomy were compared with those having elective gastrointestinal surgery. Relationships between reported checklist use and mortality were determined using multivariable logistic regression and bootstrapped simulation.
Results
Of 12 296 patients included from 76 countries, 4843 underwent emergency laparotomy. After adjusting for patient and disease factors, checklist use before emergency laparotomy was more common in countries with a high Human Development Index (HDI) (2455 of 2741, 89·6 per cent) compared with that in countries with a middle (753 of 1242, 60·6 per cent; odds ratio (OR) 0·17, 95 per cent c.i. 0·14 to 0·21, P < 0·001) or low (363 of 860, 42·2 per cent; OR 0·08, 0·07 to 0·10, P < 0·001) HDI. Checklist use was less common in elective surgery than for emergency laparotomy in high-HDI countries (risk difference −9·4 (95 per cent c.i. −11·9 to −6·9) per cent; P < 0·001), but the relationship was reversed in low-HDI countries (+12·1 (+7·0 to +17·3) per cent; P < 0·001). In multivariable models, checklist use was associated with a lower 30-day perioperative mortality (OR 0·60, 0·50 to 0·73; P < 0·001). The greatest absolute benefit was seen for emergency surgery in low- and middle-HDI countries.
Conclusion
Checklist use in emergency laparotomy was associated with a significantly lower perioperative mortality rate. Checklist use in low-HDI countries was half that in high-HDI countries
Laparoscopy in management of appendicitis in high-, middle-, and low-income countries: a multicenter, prospective, cohort study
- Author
- Nebiyou Seyoum Abebe (16238429)
- Ayman Nabawi (11579146)
- Mostafa Abdelkader (16237742)
- Abebe Bekele Zerihun (12883738)
- Frank Owusu (16238471)
- Junyeong Oh (16238774)
- Yousra El Shoura (16238006)
- Ourdia Bouali (16238450)
- Ahmed Fahiem (16238354)
- Isaac Hanley (16238693)
- Maria Aguilera (16238519)
- Irene Montes (16237667)
- Sameer Kushwaha (16237655)
- Carolina Oliveira Felipe (16238732)
- Alaa Abouelnasr (16238195)
- Alexis P Arnaud (14044053)
- Ahmed Mosad (16238144)
- Julian Camilleri-Brennan (13789312)
- Safwat Al-Nahrawi (16238309)
- Tarek Razek (16237664)
- Mohamed A Baky Fahmy (16237727)
- Assmaa Badwy (16238300)
- Ahmed Ragab Nayel (16238117)
- Mona Rashad (16237898)
- Gehad Tawfik (7110857)
- Abdelrahman Mohammed (16237799)
- Tagang Ebogo Ngwa (16237643)
- Clemens Nawara (16238696)
- Yasser Abd El Salam (16238165)
- Sarah Samy (16237973)
- Emanuel Barrios (16238891)
- Sally Elshanwany (16237994)
- Ana Vega Carreiro De Freitas (16238723)
- Ahmad Abdel Fattah (16237754)
- Ibrahim Elzayyat (16237901)
- Robert George (151235)
- Ville Sallinen (6529403)
- Stuart Fergusson (16237475)
- Ahmed Sabry El-Hamouly (16238180)
- Ahmed Ragab Soliman (16238384)
- Nichole Starr (7256987)
- Mohamed Ali Ghonaim (16238813)
- Stephen Tabiri (6000194)
- Marilla Dickfos (16237571)
- Salma Said Elkolaly (16237853)
- Emad Ali Ahmed (16238228)
- Mario Contreras Urquizu (16238882)
- Nicole D'aguzan (16238768)
- Ramdan Shaker (16238201)
- Esraa Ghanem (16237997)
- Mohamed Shaalan (13866044)
- Mohamed A Amer (16238174)
- Manuela Mendez (16237673)
- Abdalla Gharib (16237763)
- Michael Livingston (782017)
- Nicoleta Panait (13199028)
- Mohamed Ammar (1927399)
- Romeo Guevara (16238516)
- Mahmoud Abdulgawad (16237772)
- Guillaume Podevin (498513)
- Ahmad Almallah (16238129)
- Mohamed Hashish (16238363)
- Mohamed Husseini (16238372)
- Thuraya Alzayat (16238030)
- Afnan Altamimi (16237514)
- Khaled Abozeid (16238348)
- Mahmoud Salma (16237970)
- Panu Mentula (64907)
- Mohammad Rashid (732254)
- Arnaud Bonnard (35748)
- Amr Fadel (16238225)
- Mohamad Baheeg (16237775)
- Yasmein Ibrahim (16238840)
- Miguel Siguantay (16238546)
- Aung Kyaw Tun (16238708)
- Aya Aboarab (16237979)
- Gehad Samir El Sayed (16237865)
- Barbara Pereira Silvestre (16238726)
- Usama Hantour (16237835)
- Asmaa Abdel-Rahman Al-Aarag (16237988)
- Alexandre Horobjowsky (16237658)
- Ahmad Aldalaq (16238255)
- Hayssam Rashwan (16237748)
- Ahmed Samir (16237982)
- Basma Magdy (12423374)
- Alyne Daltri Lazzarini Cury (16238717)
- Mohammed Alhendy (16237778)
- Ahmed Tammam (16238000)
- Omar Alahmady (16237838)
- Cherry Koh (9983701)
- Aliaa Gamal Toeema (16238057)
- Sebastian Shu (12136965)
- Mohamed Ameen (10795781)
- Gustavo Pereira Fraga (5886425)
- Soaad Elsobky (16238210)
- Emilie Eyssartier (16238459)
- Yasmin Elfouly (16238381)
- Rafael Soley (16238888)
- Georges Azzie (16237649)
- Erik Hervieux (12976919)
- Mostafa Gemeah (16237790)
- Ahmed Abdelmotaleb Ghazy (16237952)
- Vanessa Dina Palomino Castillo (16237613)
- Nermeen Soubhy El-Shahat (16237874)
- Ashraf Morsi (16238168)
- Ewen M Harrison (11606837)
- Shorouk El Mesery (16238330)
- Claudio Fermani (16237538)
- Stuart J Fergusson (16238687)
- Manuel Hache-Marliere (16238780)
- Jason Brown (253739)
- Yasmin Abd-Elrasoul (16238807)
- Herman Cruz (16237697)
- Francisco Regalado (16238543)
- Mohamed Ghoneem (16237733)
- Luiz Carlos Barros De Castro Segundo (16237622)
- Zhongtao Zhang (1355454)
- Mohamed Elzayat (16237883)
- Diogo Vinicius dos Santos (16238756)
- Ahmad Nashaat (16238273)
- Mohammed Nasr (16237814)
- Antonio Leal (3600623)
- Hagar Zidan (16238066)
- Ehab Mamdouh (16238243)
- Julia Guasti Pinto Vianna (16238729)
- Jose Rene Arevalo Azmitia (16238873)
- Karen Bailey (549958)
- Monique Moron Munhoz (16237607)
- Mohammad Ghassan Alwafai (16238231)
- Kresimir Zamarin (16237712)
- Ahmed Menshawy (11154322)
- Maria Marta Modolo (14632463)
- Mai Salama (16237907)
- Billal Mansour (16237841)
- Mohamed Abuseif (16238063)
- Mohammed Ismail (14506799)
- Iman Elkadsh (16238285)
- Ali Mohamed Hammad (16238003)
- Aly Nasr (16238060)
- Mohammad Aboraya (16238834)
- Mohamed Elfil (10731084)
- Neel Gobin (16237478)
- Ahmed Abo El Magd (16238213)
- Doaa Emadeldin (16238810)
- Dalia Hemeda (16237904)
- Diaa Moustafa Elbendary Elsawahly (16237937)
- Ahmed Sabry (12501380)
- Khalid Salah El-Dien (16237832)
- Rokia Sakr (16238204)
- Cesar Augusto Azmitia Mendizabal (16238879)
- Hunain Shiwani (9943820)
- Cheng Chun Goh (16237508)
- Giridhar H Devadasar (16237586)
- Amr Hasan (9745484)
- Sung-Hee Kim (11271393)
- Ahmed Rslan (16238804)
- Thiago Fernandes Giuriato (16238747)
- Mahmoud Abdelshafy (12410814)
- Ahmed Safwan Marey (16238339)
- Mahmoud Amreia (16238207)
- Maria Isabel Villegas (16237676)
- Joseph Awuku-Asabre (16238474)
- Omar Saleh (825207)
- Kyriakos Psarianos (16238483)
- Hossam Elfeki (8939474)
- Mohamed Elsehimy (16238321)
- Hosni Khairy (16237487)
- Esraa Kasem (16238837)
- Nigel Hall (3404000)
- Ahmed Hassan (3571610)
- Hager Tolba (16238147)
- Fred Alexander Naranjo Aristizabal (16238777)
- Maria Clara Mendoza Arango (16237679)
- Robert Karlo (15205357)
- Ahmed Meshref (3620615)
- Aya Hagar (16238318)
- Marwa Elashmawy (16238270)
- Mohammed Mustafa Hassan Mohammed (16238402)
- Mohammed Bukari (8376354)
- Heba Shaker (16238099)
- Ahmed Lasheen (16238162)
- Ahmad Ali (4494817)
- Mostafa Seif (16238120)
- Olivier Abbo (13799447)
- Mahmoud Morsi (4390996)
- J Edward F Fitzgerald (16237472)
- Mennat-Allah Mustafa (16238084)
- Radhian Amandito (7145585)
- Boris Marinkovic (16238762)
- Muhammad Rashid Minhas Qadir (16237592)
- Sabine Irtan (13199037)
- Dimitrios Karousos (16238867)
- Marisa Leal (16237631)
- Dan L Deckelbaum (16237661)
- Kwaku Boakye-Yiadom (16238468)
- Sara Ayad (16238198)
- Mohamed Zidan (16238360)
- Ruben Balmaceda (16237541)
- Mohamed Sabry Ammar (16238081)
- Midhun Mohan (3621155)
- Mahmoud Saad (11560769)
- Nermin M Badwi (16238843)
- Mohamed Abozaid (16237805)
- Mahmoud Alrahawy (16238093)
- Ahmed Mokhtar (16238192)
- Hassan Ali Mostafa (16238153)
- Osama Mohamed (6166004)
- Abeer Marey (16238216)
- Nikica Pezelj (16237715)
- Hatem El-Sheemy (16238246)
- Dushyant Iyer (16237565)
- Alice Faure (3510887)
- Ahmed Abo Elazayem (16238267)
- Aliaa Sadek (16238054)
- Nikolaos Nikoloudis (16238501)
- Sara Abd Elmageed Barakat (16238069)
- Eman Adel Sayma (16238135)
- Ahmed Sakr (9759095)
- Sarah Abdelghany (16237961)
- Yves Aigrain (35750)
- Lotfy Eldamaty (16238312)
- Hazem Khaled (16237910)
- Mohamed Mustafa (3492749)
- Constantinos Marinos (7156115)
- Mohammed Mousa (3620618)
- Yucel Cengiz (16237532)
- Juana Kabba (16237640)
- Brian Cameron (14177663)
- Ahmed Adel (8809749)
- Areej Tarek (16238111)
- Dmitri Nepogodiev (703061)
- Yasmin Abd Elrasoul (16238075)
- Omar Osman (16237787)
- Arnav Agarwal (649596)
- Daniel Dabessa (16238426)
- Vivien Graffeille (16238438)
- Fatimah I Elgendy (16238042)
- Daniel Youssef (16237568)
- Ahmed Mohamed Afifi (16237925)
- Ana Vega Freitas (16237481)
- Ewan Macdermid (16237544)
- Nicholas Phillips (2015242)
- Abdullah Gouda (16237757)
- Mariam Darweesh (16238288)
- Ahmed Fawzy (9332758)
- Laura Luque (16237511)
- Romeo Lages Simoes (16238759)
- Sebastian King (16237646)
- Angham Solaiman El-Ma'doul (16238141)
- James Brown (425608)
- Walter Forno (16238513)
- Ruben Rivas (16238786)
- Antje Oosterkamp (16237577)
- Hossam Dawoud (16238327)
- Aurelien Scalabre (16238432)
- Victor Manuel Quintero Riaza (16237688)
- Aya Elwaey (16238282)
- Mohamed Abdelraheim (16237886)
- Dmitri A Raptis (16237535)
- Zaynab M Elsayed (16238279)
- Sara Mehrez (16238018)
- Ahmed Hafez El-Badri Kotb (16237808)
- Ahmed Afandy (16238189)
- Mahmoud Elkhadrawi (16237922)
- Yacoubou Imorou Souaibou (16237583)
- Sergio Estupinian (16238510)
- Fernanda Frade (16238435)
- Luis Alberto Valente Laufer (16238735)
- Nesma Elfouly (16238390)
- Jakov Mihanovic (12136842)
- Mahmoud Gomah (16237745)
- Ismail Lawani (12136812)
- Ahmed Abd El Galeel (16237826)
- Yasmin Hegazy (16238801)
- Samar Saad (12434298)
- Ashrarur Rahman Mitul (12036842)
- Vivien Graffieille (16238846)
- Noura A Attallah (16238819)
- Chetan Khatri (644807)
- Georgios Gemenetzis (11870834)
- Hisham Samih (16237955)
- Ibrahim AlYoussef (16238831)
- Adesoji O Ademuyiwa (12983220)
- Ahmed Badr (16238297)
- Mahmoud Mohamed Metwally (16237931)
- Daniel Estuardo Marroquin Rodriguez (16238897)
- James C Glasbey (12136746)
- Sherif Shehata (16238345)
- Dietmar Oefner (16238699)
- Justas Zilinskas (16237505)
- Nader Abd El Hamid (16238792)
- Sarah Rayne (16237526)
- Alexandre Venancio De Sousa (16238714)
- Sara Ghanem (16238276)
- Stella Binna Kim (16238711)
- Omnia Mosalum (16238186)
- Jaime Andres Montoya Botero (16237685)
- Gareth Irwin (4235590)
- Anastasia Bamicha (16238486)
- Ahmed Gheith (16238378)
- Nikolaos Gouvas (16238858)
- Carlos Morales (9269296)
- Mohammad Abdulkhalek Habeeb (16238405)
- Gamal Shimy (16237724)
- Cecile Muller (16238465)
- Jehad Hassan Youssif (16237868)
- Ivan Mendoza (3853423)
- Mohamed Asal (16237739)
- Ahamed Hassan (16237721)
- Mohammed Hanafy (16237766)
- Jessica Souza Luiz (16238753)
- Ola Sherief Abd El Hameed (16238159)
- Sahlu Wondimu (16238414)
- Amira Atef Omar (16238156)
- Abdalrahman Adel (16237793)
- Ahmed Elgebaly (3500423)
- Khaled Naser El Deen (16237892)
- Abdullah Al-Mallah (16237769)
- Mohamed Etman (16238090)
- Abdelfatah Hussein (16237919)
- Caio Vinicius Barroso de Lima (16237634)
- Thomas M Drake (11606831)
- Luiza Sarmento Tatagiba (5552507)
- Khalid Mahmud (16237574)
- Mohamed Elazoul (16238306)
- Sara Maria Contreras Merida (16238903)
- Hager Ahmed El-badawy (16238816)
- Abdelrahman Alkammash (16237817)
- Marwan Shawki (16237499)
- Sara Kharsa (16238240)
- Fathia Abd El-Salam (16238045)
- Valentine Parent (7581455)
- Ahmed Khyrallh (16237718)
- Mahmoud Ahmed Fathi Abozyed (16237859)
- Scott K D'amours (16237562)
- Metwally Aboraya (16238798)
- Ari Leppaniemi (3688021)
- Ahmed Elkholy (16237991)
- Roxanne Chenn (16237550)
- Basem Sieda (16238396)
- Lucile Fievet (16238456)
- Michail Kontos (16238864)
- Abeer El Gendy (16238333)
- Abdelrahman Haroun (16237985)
- Carla Cecilia Ramarez Cabrera (16238876)
- Samuel Nigo (16237637)
- Abdelrhman Osama Elsebaaye (16237880)
- Wei Guo (86150)
- Mihael Radic (16237709)
- Ahmed Elkelany (16238105)
- Simon Stock (6683147)
- Maira Cassa Careta (16237628)
- Pablo Ramazzini (16238528)
- Kjetil Soreide (8715852)
- Mona Hosh (16238024)
- Fatma Elkady (16237967)
- Salim Anderson Khouri Ferreira (16237625)
- Frehun Ayele Asele (16238423)
- Francis Abantanga (3494846)
- Ibrahim AbdelFattah (16238789)
- Aneel Bhangu (4320508)
- Carlos Ivan Perez Velasquez (16238900)
- Mohammed Ubaid Alsaggaf (16237517)
- Eman Nofal (16237943)
- April Camilla Roslani (8367699)
- Sofia Mouttalib (16238447)
- Fei Zheng (193006)
- Christos Agalianos (16238861)
- Abdullah Dwydar (16238237)
- Fernando Tale (16238885)
- Mohamed Abbas (834428)
- Ahmad Elbatahgy (16238138)
- Rafael Araujo (162519)
- Emad Mohamed Saeed Taha (16237847)
- Mohamed Moamen Mohamed (16238222)
- Juliana Menegussi (5552504)
- Jakeline Restrepo (16237691)
- Osama Seifelnasr (16238048)
- Soliman Magdy Ahmed (16237871)
- Dimitrios Lytras (16238480)
- Augusto Zani (6278387)
- Nadin Elsayed (16238072)
- Amany Abouzahra (16238036)
- Muhammad El-Saied Ahmad Muhammad Gohar (16237736)
- Mohamed Abd El Slam (16238303)
- Christos Dervenis (16238855)
- Mohamed Seisa (16237913)
- Luana Ayres Da Silva (16238741)
- Athar Eysa (16238051)
- Stephen J Chapman (16237493)
- Alejandro Munera (16237700)
- Nehal Yosri Elsayed Abdel-Wahab (16237856)
- Ehab Alnawam (16238258)
- Shaimaa Aql (16238366)
- Mario Lopez (6817022)
- Gustavo Peixoto Soares Miguel (16238720)
- Gustavo Recinos (16237496)
- Cutting Edge Manipal (16238690)
- Mostafa Allam (16238342)
- Ali Amin Ahmed Ata (16237811)
- Francesco Pata (8715885)
- Osama Saadeldeen Ebrahim (16237928)
- Quentin Alimi (16238444)
- Michael Hanrahan (16237502)
- Marina Luiza Pimenta (16238744)
- Francoise Schmitt (16238462)
- Nebyou Seyoum Abebe (16238417)
- Sebastian Sierra (16237670)
- Gehad El Ashal (16238009)
- Dalia Alkhabbaz (16238261)
- Tapan Kumar (9764999)
- Sylvia Batista Lemaire (16238783)
- Ahmed Fouad (8343690)
- Ahmed Raslan (11776126)
- Eugenio Grasset (16238765)
- Abouelatta Khairy Aly (16238252)
- Marwa Elshobary (16238351)
- Pamphile A Assouto (16237580)
- Ahmed Negida (4390993)
- Fernanda Altoe (16238738)
- Attia Mohamed Attia (16237823)
- Reem Fakher (16237976)
- Hafiz Hakim (16238705)
- Elodie Gaignard (16238441)
- Nathalie Botto (16238453)
- Edgar Domini (16237706)
- Mohamed Elbermawy (16237946)
- Abd El-Rahman Hegazy Khedr (16237877)
- Ahmed Gomaa (4115773)
- Eslam Elbanby (16237829)
- Gisele Moreira (16237610)
- Ahmed Mohammed (7004726)
- Semay Desta (16238411)
- Matthieu Peycelon (4458907)
- Abdalla Kenibar (16237784)
- Amel Hashish (15228034)
- Hisham Safa (16237940)
- Kyaw Phyo Aung (16237595)
- Kholod Tarek Lasheen (16237850)
- Ayman Elwan (16238114)
- Hager Elwakil (16238096)
- Eirini Kefalidi (16238852)
- Martin Jarmin (16237559)
- Richard Spence (16237523)
- Elsayed Gamaly (16238033)
- Hussein El-Kashef (16238108)
- Margub Hussain (16238702)
- Emad Abdallah (16238027)
- Ahmed Mohameden (16238291)
- Christos Anthoulakis (16238498)
- Ahmed Moustafa Saeed (16237862)
- Abdelaziz Osman Abdelaziz Elhendawy (16238369)
- Michael Edye (16237556)
- Lee Shi Yeo (16237598)
- Sarah Antar (16238015)
- Alexis Pierre Arnaud (16238849)
- Ramadan Shaker (16238822)
- Napoleon Mendez (16238522)
- Paulo Alves Bezerra Morais (16238750)
- Ahmed Abdelkareem (16238336)
- Amandine Martin (3106992)
- Oliver Warren (4386268)
- Abd Elrahman Elshafay (16237760)
- Rowida Elmelegy (16237934)
- Amr Tarek Hafez (16238825)
- Kareem Elshaer (16237916)
- Emmanuel Barrios (16238894)
- Florian Primavesi (6786002)
- Nikolaos Mitroudis (16238504)
- Shereen Elsheikh (16238039)
- Mohammed Firdouse (16237652)
- Mengistu Worku (16238408)
- Lemuel Davies Bray (16238477)
- Roberto Macchiavello (16238771)
- Chean Leung Chong (16237589)
- Stylianos Germanos (16238870)
- Ibrahim Elzayat (16237889)
- Maha Gamal Mohamad Hamad (16238021)
- Efeson Thomas (16238420)
- Gregory Kouraklis (817877)
- Mahmoud Warda (4671655)
- Omar Salah (11367852)
- Abdallah Salah Elsherbiny (16238393)
- Abdelrahman Sayed (16237802)
- Abdelrhman Essam Elnemr (16238795)
- Diaa Eldin Abdelazeem Amin Elsorogy (16238150)
- Ahmed El Kholy (16237964)
- Sameh Sarsik (16238357)
- Shady Hussein (16238264)
- Zahra Jaffry (16237490)
- Julio Jimenez (789609)
- Amr Muhammad Elkorashy (16237844)
- Fathee Nada (16238315)
- Mohamed Karkeet (16237751)
- Asmaa Abdelgelil (16237958)
- Jenifa Jeyakumar (16237529)
- Mennaallah Hafez (16238294)
- Cheryl Ou Yong (16237553)
- Mohammed Saeed (3411002)
- Mohamed F Zalabia (16238828)
- Publication venue
- Publication date
- 2018
- Field of study
Abstract
Background
Appendicitis is the most common abdominal surgical emergency worldwide. Differences between high- and low-income settings in the availability of laparoscopic appendectomy, alternative management choices, and outcomes are poorly described. The aim was to identify variation in surgical management and outcomes of appendicitis within low-, middle-, and high-Human Development Index (HDI) countries worldwide.
Methods
This is a multicenter, international prospective cohort study. Consecutive sampling of patients undergoing emergency appendectomy over 6 months was conducted. Follow-up lasted 30 days.
Results
4546 patients from 52 countries underwent appendectomy (2499 high-, 1540 middle-, and 507 low-HDI groups). Surgical site infection (SSI) rates were higher in low-HDI (OR 2.57, 95% CI 1.33–4.99, p = 0.005) but not middle-HDI countries (OR 1.38, 95% CI 0.76–2.52, p = 0.291), compared with high-HDI countries after adjustment. A laparoscopic approach was common in high-HDI countries (1693/2499, 67.7%), but infrequent in low-HDI (41/507, 8.1%) and middle-HDI (132/1540, 8.6%) groups. After accounting for case-mix, laparoscopy was still associated with fewer overall complications (OR 0.55, 95% CI 0.42–0.71, p < 0.001) and SSIs (OR 0.22, 95% CI 0.14–0.33, p < 0.001). In propensity-score matched groups within low-/middle-HDI countries, laparoscopy was still associated with fewer overall complications (OR 0.23 95% CI 0.11–0.44) and SSI (OR 0.21 95% CI 0.09–0.45).
Conclusion
A laparoscopic approach is associated with better outcomes and availability appears to differ by country HDI. Despite the profound clinical, operational, and financial barriers to its widespread introduction, laparoscopy could significantly improve outcomes for patients in low-resource environments.
Trial registration: NCT02179112
Laparoscopy in management of appendicitis in high-, middle-, and low-income countries: a multicenter, prospective, cohort study
- Author
- Nebiyou Seyoum Abebe (16238429)
- Ayman Nabawi (11579146)
- Mostafa Abdelkader (16237742)
- Abebe Bekele Zerihun (12883738)
- Frank Owusu (16238471)
- Junyeong Oh (16238774)
- Yousra El Shoura (16238006)
- Ourdia Bouali (16238450)
- Ahmed Fahiem (16238354)
- Isaac Hanley (16238693)
- Maria Aguilera (16238519)
- Irene Montes (16237667)
- Sameer Kushwaha (16237655)
- Carolina Oliveira Felipe (16238732)
- Alaa Abouelnasr (16238195)
- Alexis P Arnaud (14044053)
- Ahmed Mosad (16238144)
- Julian Camilleri-Brennan (13789312)
- Safwat Al-Nahrawi (16238309)
- Tarek Razek (16237664)
- Mohamed A Baky Fahmy (16237727)
- Assmaa Badwy (16238300)
- Ahmed Ragab Nayel (16238117)
- Mona Rashad (16237898)
- Gehad Tawfik (7110857)
- Abdelrahman Mohammed (16237799)
- Tagang Ebogo Ngwa (16237643)
- Clemens Nawara (16238696)
- Yasser Abd El Salam (16238165)
- Sarah Samy (16237973)
- Emanuel Barrios (16238891)
- Sally Elshanwany (16237994)
- Ana Vega Carreiro De Freitas (16238723)
- Ahmad Abdel Fattah (16237754)
- Ibrahim Elzayyat (16237901)
- Robert George (151235)
- Ville Sallinen (6529403)
- Stuart Fergusson (16237475)
- Ahmed Sabry El-Hamouly (16238180)
- Ahmed Ragab Soliman (16238384)
- Nichole Starr (7256987)
- Mohamed Ali Ghonaim (16238813)
- Stephen Tabiri (6000194)
- Marilla Dickfos (16237571)
- Salma Said Elkolaly (16237853)
- Emad Ali Ahmed (16238228)
- Mario Contreras Urquizu (16238882)
- Nicole D'aguzan (16238768)
- Ramdan Shaker (16238201)
- Esraa Ghanem (16237997)
- Mohamed Shaalan (13866044)
- Mohamed A Amer (16238174)
- Manuela Mendez (16237673)
- Abdalla Gharib (16237763)
- Michael Livingston (782017)
- Nicoleta Panait (13199028)
- Mohamed Ammar (1927399)
- Romeo Guevara (16238516)
- Mahmoud Abdulgawad (16237772)
- Guillaume Podevin (498513)
- Ahmad Almallah (16238129)
- Mohamed Hashish (16238363)
- Mohamed Husseini (16238372)
- Thuraya Alzayat (16238030)
- Afnan Altamimi (16237514)
- Khaled Abozeid (16238348)
- Mahmoud Salma (16237970)
- Panu Mentula (64907)
- Mohammad Rashid (732254)
- Arnaud Bonnard (35748)
- Amr Fadel (16238225)
- Mohamad Baheeg (16237775)
- Yasmein Ibrahim (16238840)
- Miguel Siguantay (16238546)
- Aung Kyaw Tun (16238708)
- Aya Aboarab (16237979)
- Gehad Samir El Sayed (16237865)
- Barbara Pereira Silvestre (16238726)
- Usama Hantour (16237835)
- Asmaa Abdel-Rahman Al-Aarag (16237988)
- Alexandre Horobjowsky (16237658)
- Ahmad Aldalaq (16238255)
- Hayssam Rashwan (16237748)
- Ahmed Samir (16237982)
- Basma Magdy (12423374)
- Alyne Daltri Lazzarini Cury (16238717)
- Mohammed Alhendy (16237778)
- Ahmed Tammam (16238000)
- Omar Alahmady (16237838)
- Cherry Koh (9983701)
- Aliaa Gamal Toeema (16238057)
- Sebastian Shu (12136965)
- Mohamed Ameen (10795781)
- Gustavo Pereira Fraga (5886425)
- Soaad Elsobky (16238210)
- Emilie Eyssartier (16238459)
- Yasmin Elfouly (16238381)
- Rafael Soley (16238888)
- Georges Azzie (16237649)
- Erik Hervieux (12976919)
- Mostafa Gemeah (16237790)
- Ahmed Abdelmotaleb Ghazy (16237952)
- Vanessa Dina Palomino Castillo (16237613)
- Nermeen Soubhy El-Shahat (16237874)
- Ashraf Morsi (16238168)
- Ewen M Harrison (11606837)
- Shorouk El Mesery (16238330)
- Claudio Fermani (16237538)
- Stuart J Fergusson (16238687)
- Manuel Hache-Marliere (16238780)
- Jason Brown (253739)
- Yasmin Abd-Elrasoul (16238807)
- Herman Cruz (16237697)
- Francisco Regalado (16238543)
- Mohamed Ghoneem (16237733)
- Luiz Carlos Barros De Castro Segundo (16237622)
- Zhongtao Zhang (1355454)
- Mohamed Elzayat (16237883)
- Diogo Vinicius dos Santos (16238756)
- Ahmad Nashaat (16238273)
- Mohammed Nasr (16237814)
- Antonio Leal (3600623)
- Hagar Zidan (16238066)
- Ehab Mamdouh (16238243)
- Julia Guasti Pinto Vianna (16238729)
- Jose Rene Arevalo Azmitia (16238873)
- Karen Bailey (549958)
- Monique Moron Munhoz (16237607)
- Mohammad Ghassan Alwafai (16238231)
- Kresimir Zamarin (16237712)
- Ahmed Menshawy (11154322)
- Maria Marta Modolo (14632463)
- Mai Salama (16237907)
- Billal Mansour (16237841)
- Mohamed Abuseif (16238063)
- Mohammed Ismail (14506799)
- Iman Elkadsh (16238285)
- Ali Mohamed Hammad (16238003)
- Aly Nasr (16238060)
- Mohammad Aboraya (16238834)
- Mohamed Elfil (10731084)
- Neel Gobin (16237478)
- Ahmed Abo El Magd (16238213)
- Doaa Emadeldin (16238810)
- Dalia Hemeda (16237904)
- Diaa Moustafa Elbendary Elsawahly (16237937)
- Ahmed Sabry (12501380)
- Khalid Salah El-Dien (16237832)
- Rokia Sakr (16238204)
- Cesar Augusto Azmitia Mendizabal (16238879)
- Hunain Shiwani (9943820)
- Cheng Chun Goh (16237508)
- Giridhar H Devadasar (16237586)
- Amr Hasan (9745484)
- Sung-Hee Kim (11271393)
- Ahmed Rslan (16238804)
- Thiago Fernandes Giuriato (16238747)
- Mahmoud Abdelshafy (12410814)
- Ahmed Safwan Marey (16238339)
- Mahmoud Amreia (16238207)
- Maria Isabel Villegas (16237676)
- Joseph Awuku-Asabre (16238474)
- Omar Saleh (825207)
- Kyriakos Psarianos (16238483)
- Hossam Elfeki (8939474)
- Mohamed Elsehimy (16238321)
- Hosni Khairy (16237487)
- Esraa Kasem (16238837)
- Nigel Hall (3404000)
- Ahmed Hassan (3571610)
- Hager Tolba (16238147)
- Fred Alexander Naranjo Aristizabal (16238777)
- Maria Clara Mendoza Arango (16237679)
- Robert Karlo (15205357)
- Ahmed Meshref (3620615)
- Aya Hagar (16238318)
- Marwa Elashmawy (16238270)
- Mohammed Mustafa Hassan Mohammed (16238402)
- Mohammed Bukari (8376354)
- Heba Shaker (16238099)
- Ahmed Lasheen (16238162)
- Ahmad Ali (4494817)
- Mostafa Seif (16238120)
- Olivier Abbo (13799447)
- Mahmoud Morsi (4390996)
- J Edward F Fitzgerald (16237472)
- Mennat-Allah Mustafa (16238084)
- Radhian Amandito (7145585)
- Boris Marinkovic (16238762)
- Muhammad Rashid Minhas Qadir (16237592)
- Sabine Irtan (13199037)
- Dimitrios Karousos (16238867)
- Marisa Leal (16237631)
- Dan L Deckelbaum (16237661)
- Kwaku Boakye-Yiadom (16238468)
- Sara Ayad (16238198)
- Mohamed Zidan (16238360)
- Ruben Balmaceda (16237541)
- Mohamed Sabry Ammar (16238081)
- Midhun Mohan (3621155)
- Mahmoud Saad (11560769)
- Nermin M Badwi (16238843)
- Mohamed Abozaid (16237805)
- Mahmoud Alrahawy (16238093)
- Ahmed Mokhtar (16238192)
- Hassan Ali Mostafa (16238153)
- Osama Mohamed (6166004)
- Abeer Marey (16238216)
- Nikica Pezelj (16237715)
- Hatem El-Sheemy (16238246)
- Dushyant Iyer (16237565)
- Alice Faure (3510887)
- Ahmed Abo Elazayem (16238267)
- Aliaa Sadek (16238054)
- Nikolaos Nikoloudis (16238501)
- Sara Abd Elmageed Barakat (16238069)
- Eman Adel Sayma (16238135)
- Ahmed Sakr (9759095)
- Sarah Abdelghany (16237961)
- Yves Aigrain (35750)
- Lotfy Eldamaty (16238312)
- Hazem Khaled (16237910)
- Mohamed Mustafa (3492749)
- Constantinos Marinos (7156115)
- Mohammed Mousa (3620618)
- Yucel Cengiz (16237532)
- Juana Kabba (16237640)
- Brian Cameron (14177663)
- Ahmed Adel (8809749)
- Areej Tarek (16238111)
- Dmitri Nepogodiev (703061)
- Yasmin Abd Elrasoul (16238075)
- Omar Osman (16237787)
- Arnav Agarwal (649596)
- Daniel Dabessa (16238426)
- Vivien Graffeille (16238438)
- Fatimah I Elgendy (16238042)
- Daniel Youssef (16237568)
- Ahmed Mohamed Afifi (16237925)
- Ana Vega Freitas (16237481)
- Ewan Macdermid (16237544)
- Nicholas Phillips (2015242)
- Abdullah Gouda (16237757)
- Mariam Darweesh (16238288)
- Ahmed Fawzy (9332758)
- Laura Luque (16237511)
- Romeo Lages Simoes (16238759)
- Sebastian King (16237646)
- Angham Solaiman El-Ma'doul (16238141)
- James Brown (425608)
- Walter Forno (16238513)
- Ruben Rivas (16238786)
- Antje Oosterkamp (16237577)
- Hossam Dawoud (16238327)
- Aurelien Scalabre (16238432)
- Victor Manuel Quintero Riaza (16237688)
- Aya Elwaey (16238282)
- Mohamed Abdelraheim (16237886)
- Dmitri A Raptis (16237535)
- Zaynab M Elsayed (16238279)
- Sara Mehrez (16238018)
- Ahmed Hafez El-Badri Kotb (16237808)
- Ahmed Afandy (16238189)
- Mahmoud Elkhadrawi (16237922)
- Yacoubou Imorou Souaibou (16237583)
- Sergio Estupinian (16238510)
- Fernanda Frade (16238435)
- Luis Alberto Valente Laufer (16238735)
- Nesma Elfouly (16238390)
- Jakov Mihanovic (12136842)
- Mahmoud Gomah (16237745)
- Ismail Lawani (12136812)
- Ahmed Abd El Galeel (16237826)
- Yasmin Hegazy (16238801)
- Samar Saad (12434298)
- Ashrarur Rahman Mitul (12036842)
- Vivien Graffieille (16238846)
- Noura A Attallah (16238819)
- Chetan Khatri (644807)
- Georgios Gemenetzis (11870834)
- Hisham Samih (16237955)
- Ibrahim AlYoussef (16238831)
- Adesoji O Ademuyiwa (12983220)
- Ahmed Badr (16238297)
- Mahmoud Mohamed Metwally (16237931)
- Daniel Estuardo Marroquin Rodriguez (16238897)
- James C Glasbey (12136746)
- Sherif Shehata (16238345)
- Dietmar Oefner (16238699)
- Justas Zilinskas (16237505)
- Nader Abd El Hamid (16238792)
- Sarah Rayne (16237526)
- Alexandre Venancio De Sousa (16238714)
- Sara Ghanem (16238276)
- Stella Binna Kim (16238711)
- Omnia Mosalum (16238186)
- Jaime Andres Montoya Botero (16237685)
- Gareth Irwin (4235590)
- Anastasia Bamicha (16238486)
- Ahmed Gheith (16238378)
- Nikolaos Gouvas (16238858)
- Carlos Morales (9269296)
- Mohammad Abdulkhalek Habeeb (16238405)
- Gamal Shimy (16237724)
- Cecile Muller (16238465)
- Jehad Hassan Youssif (16237868)
- Ivan Mendoza (3853423)
- Mohamed Asal (16237739)
- Ahamed Hassan (16237721)
- Mohammed Hanafy (16237766)
- Jessica Souza Luiz (16238753)
- Ola Sherief Abd El Hameed (16238159)
- Sahlu Wondimu (16238414)
- Amira Atef Omar (16238156)
- Abdalrahman Adel (16237793)
- Ahmed Elgebaly (3500423)
- Khaled Naser El Deen (16237892)
- Abdullah Al-Mallah (16237769)
- Mohamed Etman (16238090)
- Abdelfatah Hussein (16237919)
- Caio Vinicius Barroso de Lima (16237634)
- Thomas M Drake (11606831)
- Luiza Sarmento Tatagiba (5552507)
- Khalid Mahmud (16237574)
- Mohamed Elazoul (16238306)
- Sara Maria Contreras Merida (16238903)
- Hager Ahmed El-badawy (16238816)
- Abdelrahman Alkammash (16237817)
- Marwan Shawki (16237499)
- Sara Kharsa (16238240)
- Fathia Abd El-Salam (16238045)
- Valentine Parent (7581455)
- Ahmed Khyrallh (16237718)
- Mahmoud Ahmed Fathi Abozyed (16237859)
- Scott K D'amours (16237562)
- Metwally Aboraya (16238798)
- Ari Leppaniemi (3688021)
- Ahmed Elkholy (16237991)
- Roxanne Chenn (16237550)
- Basem Sieda (16238396)
- Lucile Fievet (16238456)
- Michail Kontos (16238864)
- Abeer El Gendy (16238333)
- Abdelrahman Haroun (16237985)
- Carla Cecilia Ramarez Cabrera (16238876)
- Samuel Nigo (16237637)
- Abdelrhman Osama Elsebaaye (16237880)
- Wei Guo (86150)
- Mihael Radic (16237709)
- Ahmed Elkelany (16238105)
- Simon Stock (6683147)
- Maira Cassa Careta (16237628)
- Pablo Ramazzini (16238528)
- Kjetil Soreide (8715852)
- Mona Hosh (16238024)
- Fatma Elkady (16237967)
- Salim Anderson Khouri Ferreira (16237625)
- Frehun Ayele Asele (16238423)
- Francis Abantanga (3494846)
- Ibrahim AbdelFattah (16238789)
- Aneel Bhangu (4320508)
- Carlos Ivan Perez Velasquez (16238900)
- Mohammed Ubaid Alsaggaf (16237517)
- Eman Nofal (16237943)
- April Camilla Roslani (8367699)
- Sofia Mouttalib (16238447)
- Fei Zheng (193006)
- Christos Agalianos (16238861)
- Abdullah Dwydar (16238237)
- Fernando Tale (16238885)
- Mohamed Abbas (834428)
- Ahmad Elbatahgy (16238138)
- Rafael Araujo (162519)
- Emad Mohamed Saeed Taha (16237847)
- Mohamed Moamen Mohamed (16238222)
- Juliana Menegussi (5552504)
- Jakeline Restrepo (16237691)
- Osama Seifelnasr (16238048)
- Soliman Magdy Ahmed (16237871)
- Dimitrios Lytras (16238480)
- Augusto Zani (6278387)
- Nadin Elsayed (16238072)
- Amany Abouzahra (16238036)
- Muhammad El-Saied Ahmad Muhammad Gohar (16237736)
- Mohamed Abd El Slam (16238303)
- Christos Dervenis (16238855)
- Mohamed Seisa (16237913)
- Luana Ayres Da Silva (16238741)
- Athar Eysa (16238051)
- Stephen J Chapman (16237493)
- Alejandro Munera (16237700)
- Nehal Yosri Elsayed Abdel-Wahab (16237856)
- Ehab Alnawam (16238258)
- Shaimaa Aql (16238366)
- Mario Lopez (6817022)
- Gustavo Peixoto Soares Miguel (16238720)
- Gustavo Recinos (16237496)
- Cutting Edge Manipal (16238690)
- Mostafa Allam (16238342)
- Ali Amin Ahmed Ata (16237811)
- Francesco Pata (8715885)
- Osama Saadeldeen Ebrahim (16237928)
- Quentin Alimi (16238444)
- Michael Hanrahan (16237502)
- Marina Luiza Pimenta (16238744)
- Francoise Schmitt (16238462)
- Nebyou Seyoum Abebe (16238417)
- Sebastian Sierra (16237670)
- Gehad El Ashal (16238009)
- Dalia Alkhabbaz (16238261)
- Tapan Kumar (9764999)
- Sylvia Batista Lemaire (16238783)
- Ahmed Fouad (8343690)
- Ahmed Raslan (11776126)
- Eugenio Grasset (16238765)
- Abouelatta Khairy Aly (16238252)
- Marwa Elshobary (16238351)
- Pamphile A Assouto (16237580)
- Ahmed Negida (4390993)
- Fernanda Altoe (16238738)
- Attia Mohamed Attia (16237823)
- Reem Fakher (16237976)
- Hafiz Hakim (16238705)
- Elodie Gaignard (16238441)
- Nathalie Botto (16238453)
- Edgar Domini (16237706)
- Mohamed Elbermawy (16237946)
- Abd El-Rahman Hegazy Khedr (16237877)
- Ahmed Gomaa (4115773)
- Eslam Elbanby (16237829)
- Gisele Moreira (16237610)
- Ahmed Mohammed (7004726)
- Semay Desta (16238411)
- Matthieu Peycelon (4458907)
- Abdalla Kenibar (16237784)
- Amel Hashish (15228034)
- Hisham Safa (16237940)
- Kyaw Phyo Aung (16237595)
- Kholod Tarek Lasheen (16237850)
- Ayman Elwan (16238114)
- Hager Elwakil (16238096)
- Eirini Kefalidi (16238852)
- Martin Jarmin (16237559)
- Richard Spence (16237523)
- Elsayed Gamaly (16238033)
- Hussein El-Kashef (16238108)
- Margub Hussain (16238702)
- Emad Abdallah (16238027)
- Ahmed Mohameden (16238291)
- Christos Anthoulakis (16238498)
- Ahmed Moustafa Saeed (16237862)
- Abdelaziz Osman Abdelaziz Elhendawy (16238369)
- Michael Edye (16237556)
- Lee Shi Yeo (16237598)
- Sarah Antar (16238015)
- Alexis Pierre Arnaud (16238849)
- Ramadan Shaker (16238822)
- Napoleon Mendez (16238522)
- Paulo Alves Bezerra Morais (16238750)
- Ahmed Abdelkareem (16238336)
- Amandine Martin (3106992)
- Oliver Warren (4386268)
- Abd Elrahman Elshafay (16237760)
- Rowida Elmelegy (16237934)
- Amr Tarek Hafez (16238825)
- Kareem Elshaer (16237916)
- Emmanuel Barrios (16238894)
- Florian Primavesi (6786002)
- Nikolaos Mitroudis (16238504)
- Shereen Elsheikh (16238039)
- Mohammed Firdouse (16237652)
- Mengistu Worku (16238408)
- Lemuel Davies Bray (16238477)
- Roberto Macchiavello (16238771)
- Chean Leung Chong (16237589)
- Stylianos Germanos (16238870)
- Ibrahim Elzayat (16237889)
- Maha Gamal Mohamad Hamad (16238021)
- Efeson Thomas (16238420)
- Gregory Kouraklis (817877)
- Mahmoud Warda (4671655)
- Omar Salah (11367852)
- Abdallah Salah Elsherbiny (16238393)
- Abdelrahman Sayed (16237802)
- Abdelrhman Essam Elnemr (16238795)
- Diaa Eldin Abdelazeem Amin Elsorogy (16238150)
- Ahmed El Kholy (16237964)
- Sameh Sarsik (16238357)
- Shady Hussein (16238264)
- Zahra Jaffry (16237490)
- Julio Jimenez (789609)
- Amr Muhammad Elkorashy (16237844)
- Fathee Nada (16238315)
- Mohamed Karkeet (16237751)
- Asmaa Abdelgelil (16237958)
- Jenifa Jeyakumar (16237529)
- Mennaallah Hafez (16238294)
- Cheryl Ou Yong (16237553)
- Mohammed Saeed (3411002)
- Mohamed F Zalabia (16238828)
- Publication venue
- Publication date
- 2018
- Field of study
Abstract
Background
Appendicitis is the most common abdominal surgical emergency worldwide. Differences between high- and low-income settings in the availability of laparoscopic appendectomy, alternative management choices, and outcomes are poorly described. The aim was to identify variation in surgical management and outcomes of appendicitis within low-, middle-, and high-Human Development Index (HDI) countries worldwide.
Methods
This is a multicenter, international prospective cohort study. Consecutive sampling of patients undergoing emergency appendectomy over 6 months was conducted. Follow-up lasted 30 days.
Results
4546 patients from 52 countries underwent appendectomy (2499 high-, 1540 middle-, and 507 low-HDI groups). Surgical site infection (SSI) rates were higher in low-HDI (OR 2.57, 95% CI 1.33–4.99, p = 0.005) but not middle-HDI countries (OR 1.38, 95% CI 0.76–2.52, p = 0.291), compared with high-HDI countries after adjustment. A laparoscopic approach was common in high-HDI countries (1693/2499, 67.7%), but infrequent in low-HDI (41/507, 8.1%) and middle-HDI (132/1540, 8.6%) groups. After accounting for case-mix, laparoscopy was still associated with fewer overall complications (OR 0.55, 95% CI 0.42–0.71, p < 0.001) and SSIs (OR 0.22, 95% CI 0.14–0.33, p < 0.001). In propensity-score matched groups within low-/middle-HDI countries, laparoscopy was still associated with fewer overall complications (OR 0.23 95% CI 0.11–0.44) and SSI (OR 0.21 95% CI 0.09–0.45).
Conclusion
A laparoscopic approach is associated with better outcomes and availability appears to differ by country HDI. Despite the profound clinical, operational, and financial barriers to its widespread introduction, laparoscopy could significantly improve outcomes for patients in low-resource environments.
Trial registration: NCT02179112
Determinants of morbidity and mortality following emergency abdominal surgery in children in low-income and middle-income countries
- Author
- Nebiyou Seyoum Abebe (16238429)
- Ayman Nabawi (11579146)
- Mostafa Abdelkader (16237742)
- Abebe Bekele Zerihun (12883738)
- Frank Owusu (16238471)
- Yousra El Shoura (16238006)
- Eldaa Prisca Refianti Sutanto (16238597)
- Ourdia Bouali (16238450)
- Ahmed Fahiem (16238354)
- Maria Aguilera (16238519)
- Irene Montes (16237667)
- Sameer Kushwaha (16237655)
- Alaa Abouelnasr (16238195)
- Alexis P Arnaud (14044053)
- Ahmed Mosad (16238144)
- Safwat Al-Nahrawi (16238309)
- Tarek Razek (16237664)
- Mohamed A Baky Fahmy (16237727)
- Assmaa Badwy (16238300)
- Ahmed Ragab Nayel (16238117)
- Mona Rashad (16237898)
- Gehad Tawfik (7110857)
- Abdelrahman Mohammed (16237799)
- Tagang Ebogo Ngwa (16237643)
- Yasser Abd El Salam (16238165)
- Sarah Samy (16237973)
- Sally Elshanwany (16237994)
- Ahmad Abdel Fattah (16237754)
- Ibrahim Elzayyat (16237901)
- Amoudtha Rasendran (16238630)
- Stuart Fergusson (16237475)
- Ahmed Sabry El-Hamouly (16238180)
- Ahmed Ragab Soliman (16238384)
- Nichole Starr (7256987)
- Fred Alexander Naranjo Aristiza Ibal (16237682)
- Chintya Tedjaatmadja (16238603)
- Sara Maria Contreras Merida (16238540)
- Stephen Tabiri (6000194)
- Marilla Dickfos (16237571)
- Nader Abd El Hamid (16237820)
- Paul Kielty (16238651)
- Salma Said Elkolaly (16237853)
- Emad Ali Ahmed (16238228)
- Mario Contreras Urquizu (16238531)
- Ramdan Shaker (16238201)
- Esraa Ghanem (16237997)
- Mohamed Shaalan (13866044)
- Mohamed A Amer (16238174)
- Manuela Mendez (16237673)
- Mohamed Ali Ghoname (16238126)
- Abdalla Gharib (16237763)
- Michael Livingston (782017)
- Nicoleta Panait (13199028)
- Mohamed Ammar (1927399)
- Romeo Guevara (16238516)
- Mahmoud Abdulgawad (16237772)
- Guillaume Podevin (498513)
- Ahmad Almallah (16238129)
- Mohamed Hashish (16238363)
- Mohamed Husseini (16238372)
- Thuraya Alzayat (16238030)
- Afnan Altamimi (16237514)
- Khaled Abozeid (16238348)
- Mahmoud Salma (16237970)
- Mohammad Rashid (732254)
- Arnaud Bonnard (35748)
- Amr Fadel (16238225)
- Mohamad Baheeg (16237775)
- Anand Kirishnan (16238552)
- Miguel Siguantay (16238546)
- Aya Aboarab (16237979)
- Hasan Ismael Ibraheem Al-Hameedi (16238615)
- Gehad Samir El Sayed (16237865)
- Caoimhe Normile (16238636)
- Usama Hantour (16237835)
- Doaa Emadeldin Shafik (16238123)
- Asmaa Abdel-Rahman Al-Aarag (16237988)
- Alexandre Horobjowsky (16237658)
- Ahmad Aldalaq (16238255)
- Hayssam Rashwan (16237748)
- Ahmed Samir (16237982)
- Basma Magdy (12423374)
- Daniel Ardian Soeselo (16238600)
- Mohammed Alhendy (16237778)
- Ahmed Tammam (16238000)
- Omar Alahmady (16237838)
- Aliaa Gamal Toeema (16238057)
- Sebastian Shu (12136965)
- Mohamed Ameen (10795781)
- Soaad Elsobky (16238210)
- Emilie Eyssartier (16238459)
- Yasmin Elfouly (16238381)
- Georges Azzie (16237649)
- Erik Hervieux (12976919)
- Mostafa Gemeah (16237790)
- Ahmed Abdelmotaleb Ghazy (16237952)
- Nermeen Soubhy El-Shahat (16237874)
- Ashraf Morsi (16238168)
- Ewen M Harrison (11606837)
- Shorouk El Mesery (16238330)
- Claudio Fermani (16237538)
- Jason Brown (253739)
- Herman Cruz (16237697)
- Francisco Regalado (16238543)
- Mohamed Ghoneem (16237733)
- Luiz Carlos Barros De Castro Segundo (16237622)
- Mohamed Elzayat (16237883)
- Ahmad Nashaat (16238273)
- Mohammed Nasr (16237814)
- Antonio Leal (3600623)
- Hagar Zidan (16238066)
- Ehab Mamdouh (16238243)
- Karen Bailey (549958)
- Sunil Kumar (102321)
- Monique Moron Munhoz (16237607)
- Mohammad Ghassan Alwafai (16238231)
- Kresimir Zamarin (16237712)
- Maria Marta Modolo (14632463)
- Mai Salama (16237907)
- Billal Mansour (16237841)
- Mohamed Abuseif (16238063)
- Mohammed Ismail (14506799)
- Iman Elkadsh (16238285)
- Ali Mohamed Hammad (16238003)
- Aly Nasr (16238060)
- Mohamed Elfil (10731084)
- Neel Gobin (16237478)
- Ahmed Abo El Magd (16238213)
- Dalia Hemeda (16237904)
- Diaa Moustafa Elbendary Elsawahly (16237937)
- Rajeev Satoskar (16238591)
- Ahmed Sabry (12501380)
- Khalid Salah El-Dien (16237832)
- Rokia Sakr (16238204)
- Hunain Shiwani (9943820)
- Cheng Chun Goh (16237508)
- Giridhar H Devadasar (16237586)
- Amr Hasan (9745484)
- Sung-Hee Kim (11271393)
- Mahmoud Abdelshafy (12410814)
- Ahmed Safwan Marey (16238339)
- Mahmoud Amreia (16238207)
- Maria Isabel Villegas (16237676)
- Joseph Awuku-Asabre (16238474)
- Omar Saleh (825207)
- Kyriakos Psarianos (16238483)
- Hossam Elfeki (8939474)
- Mohamed Elsehimy (16238321)
- Hosni Khairy (16237487)
- Nigel Hall (3404000)
- Ahmed Hassan (3571610)
- Hager Tolba (16238147)
- Maria Clara Mendoza Arango (16237679)
- Robert Karlo (15205357)
- Ahmed Meshref (3620615)
- Aya Hagar (16238318)
- Marwa Elashmawy (16238270)
- Mohammed Mustafa Hassan Mohammed (16238402)
- Mohammed Bukari (8376354)
- Heba Shaker (16238099)
- Ahmed Lasheen (16238162)
- Ahmad Ali (4494817)
- Mostafa Seif (16238120)
- Olivier Abbo (13799447)
- Shravan Nadkami (16238576)
- Mahmoud Morsi (4390996)
- Ibrahim Abdel Fattah (16237781)
- Nermin Mohamed Badwi (16238399)
- J Edward F Fitzgerald (16237472)
- Mennat-Allah Mustafa (16238084)
- Radhian Amandito (7145585)
- Muhammad Rashid Minhas Qadir (16237592)
- Sabine Irtan (13199037)
- Yella Reddy (3479153)
- Marisa Leal (16237631)
- Fitriana Nur Rahmawati (16238606)
- Dan L Deckelbaum (16237661)
- Kwaku Boakye-Yiadom (16238468)
- Cesar Augusto Azmitia Mendizabal (16238525)
- Sara Ayad (16238198)
- Rahma Kamil (16238624)
- Mohamed Zidan (16238360)
- Harish Neelamraju Lakshmi (16238579)
- Ruben Balmaceda (16237541)
- Mohamed Sabry Ammar (16238081)
- Midhun Mohan (3621155)
- Mahmoud Saad (11560769)
- Mohamed Abozaid (16237805)
- Mahmoud Alrahawy (16238093)
- Ahmed Mokhtar (16238192)
- Hassan Ali Mostafa (16238153)
- Maria Mayasari (16238609)
- Osama Mohamed (6166004)
- Abeer Marey (16238216)
- Nikica Pezelj (16237715)
- Amr Tarek (16238219)
- Hatem El-Sheemy (16238246)
- Sriram Bhat (16238558)
- Dushyant Iyer (16237565)
- Alice Faure (3510887)
- Ahmed Abo Elazayem (16238267)
- Aliaa Sadek (16238054)
- Nikolaos Nikoloudis (16238501)
- Sara Abd Elmageed Barakat (16238069)
- Eman Adel Sayma (16238135)
- Ahmed Sakr (9759095)
- Sarah Abdelghany (16237961)
- Mohamed Fadel (12448285)
- Yves Aigrain (35750)
- Lotfy Eldamaty (16238312)
- Hazem Khaled (16237910)
- Mohamed Mustafa (3492749)
- Mohammed Mousa (3620618)
- Omar Khater (12539505)
- Yucel Cengiz (16237532)
- Juana Kabba (16237640)
- Brian Cameron (14177663)
- Ahmed Adel (8809749)
- Areej Tarek (16238111)
- Dmitri Nepogodiev (703061)
- Yasmin Abd Elrasoul (16238075)
- Omar Osman (16237787)
- Arnav Agarwal (649596)
- Daniel Dabessa (16238426)
- Vivien Graffeille (16238438)
- Fatimah I Elgendy (16238042)
- Daniel Youssef (16237568)
- Ahmed Mohamed Afifi (16237925)
- Ana Vega Freitas (16237481)
- Ewan Macdermid (16237544)
- Nicholas Phillips (2015242)
- Abdullah Gouda (16237757)
- Mariam Darweesh (16238288)
- Ahmed Fawzy (9332758)
- Laura Luque (16237511)
- Sebastian King (16237646)
- Angham Solaiman El-Ma'doul (16238141)
- Savni Satoskar (16238588)
- James Brown (425608)
- Walter Forno (16238513)
- Antje Oosterkamp (16237577)
- Hossam Dawoud (16238327)
- Aurelien Scalabre (16238432)
- Victor Manuel Quintero Riaza (16237688)
- Aya Elwaey (16238282)
- Mohamed Abdelraheim (16237886)
- Dmitri A Raptis (16237535)
- Zaynab M Elsayed (16238279)
- Sara Mehrez (16238018)
- Israa Abdullah Aziz Al-Azraqi (16238618)
- Ahmed Hafez El-Badri Kotb (16237808)
- Ahmed Afandy (16238189)
- Mahmoud Elkhadrawi (16237922)
- Yacoubou Imorou Souaibou (16237583)
- Sergio Estupinian (16238510)
- Fernanda Frade (16238435)
- Nesma Elfouly (16238390)
- Jakov Mihanovic (12136842)
- Mahmoud Gomah (16237745)
- Ismail Lawani (12136812)
- Ahmed Abd El Galeel (16237826)
- Samar Saad (12434298)
- Muhammad Saad Ali Muhammad Gohar (16237730)
- Ashrarur Rahman Mitul (12036842)
- Chetan Khatri (644807)
- Hisham Samih (16237955)
- Adesoji O Ademuyiwa (12983220)
- Ahmed Badr (16238297)
- Daniel Estuardo Marroquin Rodriguez (16238534)
- Mahmoud Mohamed Metwally (16237931)
- Linnea Mauro (16238642)
- James C Glasbey (12136746)
- Sherif Shehata (16238345)
- Justas Zilinskas (16237505)
- Abdelrhman Essam (16237895)
- Sarah Rayne (16237526)
- Richard William Gilbert (16238639)
- Sara Ghanem (16238276)
- Omnia Mosalum (16238186)
- Jaime Andres Montoya Botero (16237685)
- Gareth Irwin (4235590)
- Puneet Malik (16238582)
- Anastasia Bamicha (16238486)
- Anjana Sreedharan (16238561)
- Yasmin Makhlouf (16238087)
- Ahmed Gheith (16238378)
- Carlos Morales (9269296)
- Mohammad Abdulkhalek Habeeb (16238405)
- Gamal Shimy (16237724)
- Mohammad Abo-ryia (16238324)
- Cecile Muller (16238465)
- Jehad Hassan Youssif (16237868)
- Ivan Mendoza (3853423)
- Mohamed Asal (16237739)
- Jiheon Song (837627)
- Mohammed Osman Dablouk (16238645)
- Ahamed Hassan (16237721)
- Mohammed Hanafy (16237766)
- Ola Sherief Abd El Hameed (16238159)
- Sahlu Wondimu (16238414)
- Amira Atef Omar (16238156)
- Abdalrahman Adel (16237793)
- Ahmed Elgebaly (3500423)
- Khaled Naser El Deen (16237892)
- Abdullah Al-Mallah (16237769)
- Mohamed Etman (16238090)
- Abdelfatah Hussein (16237919)
- Caio Vinicius Barroso de Lima (16237634)
- Thomas M Drake (11606831)
- Luiza Sarmento Tatagiba (5552507)
- Khalid Mahmud (16237574)
- Mohamed Elazoul (16238306)
- Yasmein Hani (16238387)
- Abdelrahman Alkammash (16237817)
- Marwan Shawki (16237499)
- Sara Kharsa (16238240)
- Fathia Abd El-Salam (16238045)
- Valentine Parent (7581455)
- Ahmed Khyrallh (16237718)
- Mahmoud Ahmed Fathi Abozyed (16237859)
- Scott K D'amours (16237562)
- Ahmed Elkholy (16237991)
- Roxanne Chenn (16237550)
- Basem Sieda (16238396)
- Lucile Fievet (16238456)
- Abeer El Gendy (16238333)
- Abdelrahman Haroun (16237985)
- Nidhi Gyanchandani (16238555)
- Samuel Nigo (16237637)
- Abdelrhman Osama Elsebaaye (16237880)
- Abid Bin Mahamood (16238585)
- Mihael Radic (16237709)
- Ahmed Elkelany (16238105)
- Hager Ahmed (16238171)
- Maira Cassa Careta (16237628)
- Ibrahim Alyoussef (16238249)
- Jacqueline Sheehan (5990483)
- Pablo Ramazzini (16238528)
- Kjetil Soreide (8715852)
- Mona Hosh (16238024)
- Fatma Elkady (16237967)
- Salim Anderson Khouri Ferreira (16237625)
- Frehun Ayele Asele (16238423)
- Francis Abantanga (3494846)
- Aneel Bhangu (4320508)
- Mohammed Ubaid Alsaggaf (16237517)
- Eman Nofal (16237943)
- April Camilla Roslani (8367699)
- Sofia Mouttalib (16238447)
- Abdullah Dwydar (16238237)
- Mohamed Abbas (834428)
- Ahmad Elbatahgy (16238138)
- Rafael Araujo (162519)
- Dan Poenaru (3281121)
- Emad Mohamed Saeed Taha (16237847)
- Mohamed Moamen Mohamed (16238222)
- Juliana Menegussi (5552504)
- Jakeline Restrepo (16237691)
- Osama Seifelnasr (16238048)
- Lubna Sabeeh (16238621)
- Soliman Magdy Ahmed (16237871)
- Dimitrios Lytras (16238480)
- Augusto Zani (6278387)
- Nadin Elsayed (16238072)
- Ruqaya Kadhim Mohammed Jawad Al-Hasani (16238612)
- Amany Abouzahra (16238036)
- Muhammad El-Saied Ahmad Muhammad Gohar (16237736)
- Mohamed Abd El Slam (16238303)
- Mohamed Seisa (16237913)
- SS Prasad (16238549)
- Athar Eysa (16238051)
- Esraa Abdalmageed Kasem (16238375)
- Stephen J Chapman (16237493)
- Alejandro Munera (16237700)
- Nehal Yosri Elsayed Abdel-Wahab (16237856)
- Ehab Alnawam (16238258)
- Shaimaa Aql (16238366)
- Mario Lopez (6817022)
- Gustavo Recinos (16237496)
- Mostafa Allam (16238342)
- Ali Amin Ahmed Ata (16237811)
- Carlos Ivan Perez Velsquez (16238537)
- Francesco Pata (8715885)
- Osama Saadeldeen Ebrahim (16237928)
- Quentin Alimi (16238444)
- Ahmed Maher Menshawy Mesreb (16237796)
- Michael Hanrahan (16237502)
- Francoise Schmitt (16238462)
- Nebyou Seyoum Abebe (16238417)
- Sebastian Sierra (16237670)
- Gehad El Ashal (16238009)
- Dalia Alkhabbaz (16238261)
- Ahmed Fouad (8343690)
- Ahmed Raslan (11776126)
- Abouelatta Khairy Aly (16238252)
- Marwa Elshobary (16238351)
- Pamphile A Assouto (16237580)
- Ahmed El-Kelany (16238078)
- Attia Mohamed Attia (16237823)
- Reem Fakher (16237976)
- Vanessa Dina Palomino Castillo (16237604)
- Elodie Gaignard (16238441)
- Metwally Abo Raya (16237949)
- Nathalie Botto (16238453)
- Edgar Domini (16237706)
- Mohamed Elbermawy (16237946)
- Abd El-Rahman Hegazy Khedr (16237877)
- Ehab Abdulkader Hemida Ghazy Alnawam (16238234)
- Ahmed Gomaa (4115773)
- Eslam Elbanby (16237829)
- SV Kinnera (16238564)
- Gisele Moreira (16237610)
- Ahmed Mohammed (7004726)
- Semay Desta (16238411)
- Matthieu Peycelon (4458907)
- Abdalla Kenibar (16237784)
- Amel Hashish (15228034)
- Hisham Safa (16237940)
- Kyaw Phyo Aung (16237595)
- Monty Khajanchi (529773)
- Kholod Tarek Lasheen (16237850)
- Ayman Elwan (16238114)
- Hager Elwakil (16238096)
- Martin Jarmin (16237559)
- Richard Spence (16237523)
- Elsayed Gamaly (16238033)
- Hussein El-Kashef (16238108)
- Robert Kerley (16238633)
- Emad Abdallah (16238027)
- Ahmed Mohameden (16238291)
- Christos Anthoulakis (16238498)
- Caranj Venugopal (16238594)
- Ahmed Moustafa Saeed (16237862)
- Ahmed Negeida (16237484)
- Abdelaziz Osman Abdelaziz Elhendawy (16238369)
- Michael Edye (16237556)
- Lee Shi Yeo (16237598)
- Sarah Antar (16238015)
- Napoleon Mendez (16238522)
- Ahmed Abdelkareem (16238336)
- Amandine Martin (3106992)
- Abd Elrahman Elshafay (16237760)
- Rowida Elmelegy (16237934)
- Kareem Elshaer (16237916)
- Nikolaos Mitroudis (16238504)
- Shereen Elsheikh (16238039)
- Mohammed Firdouse (16237652)
- Mengistu Worku (16238408)
- Lemuel Davies Bray (16238477)
- Chean Leung Chong (16237589)
- Ibrahim Elzayat (16237889)
- Maha Gamal Mohamad Hamad (16238021)
- Efeson Thomas (16238420)
- Mahmoud Warda (4671655)
- Omar Salah (11367852)
- Abdallah Salah Elsherbiny (16238393)
- Abdelrahman Sayed (16237802)
- Diaa Eldin Abdelazeem Amin Elsorogy (16238150)
- Ahmed El Kholy (16237964)
- Sameh Sarsik (16238357)
- Shady Hussein (16238264)
- Zahra Jaffry (16237490)
- Amr Muhammad Elkorashy (16237844)
- Fathee Nada (16238315)
- Mohamed Karkeet (16237751)
- Noura Attallah (16238183)
- Asmaa Abdelgelil (16237958)
- Jenifa Jeyakumar (16237529)
- Mennaallah Hafez (16238294)
- Cheryl Ou Yong (16237553)
- Mohammed Saeed (3411002)
- Publication venue
- Publication date
- 2016
- Field of study
Determinants of morbidity and mortality following emergency abdominal surgery in children in low-income and middle-income countrie
Pooled analysis of WHO Surgical Safety Checklist use and mortality after emergency laparotomy
- Author
- Ayman Nabawi (11579146)
- Mostafa Abdelkader (16237742)
- Junyeong Oh (16238774)
- Yousra El Shoura (16238006)
- Isaac Hanley (16238693)
- Irene Montes (16237667)
- Sameer Kushwaha (16237655)
- Carolina Oliveira Felipe (16238732)
- Alexis P Arnaud (14044053)
- Ahmed Mosad (16238144)
- Tarek Razek (16237664)
- Mohamed A Baky Fahmy (16237727)
- Al Faifi Jubran (16239167)
- Ahmed Ragab Nayel (16238117)
- Mona Rashad (16237898)
- Gehad Tawfik (7110857)
- Andrew Kirby (47075)
- Abdelrahman Mohammed (16237799)
- Hosni Khairy Salem (16239011)
- Tagang Ebogo Ngwa (16237643)
- Clemens Nawara (16238696)
- Yasser Abd El Salam (16238165)
- Sarah Samy (16237973)
- Sally Elshanwany (16237994)
- Ana Vega Carreiro De Freitas (16238723)
- Ahmad Abdel Fattah (16237754)
- Ibrahim Elzayyat (16237901)
- Robert George (151235)
- Ahmed Sabry El-Hamouly (16238180)
- Mohamed Ali Ghonaim (16238813)
- Stephen Tabiri (6000194)
- Marilla Dickfos (16237571)
- Ahmad Gudal (16239164)
- Salma Said Elkolaly (16237853)
- Nicole D'aguzan (16238768)
- Sukrit Suresh (16239194)
- Esraa Ghanem (16237997)
- Mohamed Shaalan (13866044)
- Mohamed A Amer (16238174)
- Manuela Mendez (16237673)
- Yong Yong Tew (16239125)
- Abdalla Gharib (16237763)
- Michael Livingston (782017)
- Mohamed Ammar (1927399)
- Kithsiri J Senanayake (16239173)
- Mahmoud Abdulgawad (16237772)
- Ahmad Almallah (16238129)
- Thuraya Alzayat (16238030)
- Afnan Altamimi (16237514)
- Andre L Mihaljevic (16239020)
- Mahmoud Salma (16237970)
- Mohamad Baheeg (16237775)
- Piotr Major (3873568)
- Aung Kyaw Tun (16238708)
- Aya Aboarab (16237979)
- Gehad Samir El Sayed (16237865)
- Barbara Pereira Silvestre (16238726)
- Usama Hantour (16237835)
- Asmaa Abdel-Rahman Al-Aarag (16237988)
- Alexandre Horobjowsky (16237658)
- Hayssam Rashwan (16237748)
- Ahmed Samir (16237982)
- Basma Magdy (12423374)
- Alyne Daltri Lazzarini Cury (16238717)
- Mohammed Alhendy (16237778)
- Ahmed Tammam (16238000)
- Omar Alahmady (16237838)
- Cherry Koh (9983701)
- Aliaa Gamal Toeema (16238057)
- Sebastian Shu (12136965)
- Gustavo Pereira Fraga (5886425)
- Catherine A Shaw (16239032)
- Georges Azzie (16237649)
- Mostafa Gemeah (16237790)
- Ahmed Abdelmotaleb Ghazy (16237952)
- Vanessa Dina Palomino Castillo (16237613)
- Michael Stoddart (16239188)
- Nermeen Soubhy El-Shahat (16237874)
- Ashraf Morsi (16238168)
- Ewen M Harrison (11606837)
- Claudio Fermani (16237538)
- Stuart J Fergusson (16238687)
- Matei Bratu (16239155)
- Manuel Hache-Marliere (16238780)
- Abdulaziz Altwijri (16239161)
- Jason Brown (253739)
- Yasmin Abd-Elrasoul (16238807)
- Herman Cruz (16237697)
- Mohamed Ghoneem (16237733)
- Luiz Carlos Barros De Castro Segundo (16237622)
- Zhongtao Zhang (1355454)
- Mohamed Elzayat (16237883)
- Diogo Vinicius dos Santos (16238756)
- Mohammed Nasr (16237814)
- Amar Kourdouli (16239158)
- Bettina Lieske (15040031)
- Antonio Leal (3600623)
- Hagar Zidan (16238066)
- Afnan Altamini (16239044)
- Alphonse Zeta Mutabazi (16239023)
- Sunil Kumar (102321)
- Karen Bailey (549958)
- Monique Moron Munhoz (16237607)
- Alexia Farrugia (16239128)
- Kresimir Zamarin (16237712)
- Ahmed Menshawy (11154322)
- Mai Salama (16237907)
- Billal Mansour (16237841)
- Mohamed Abuseif (16238063)
- Mohammed Ismail (14506799)
- Ali Mohamed Hammad (16238003)
- James Glasbey (703059)
- Aly Nasr (16238060)
- Vanessa Msosa (16239122)
- Mohamed Elfil (10731084)
- Neel Gobin (16237478)
- Lawani Ismail (16239008)
- Sara W Al-Saqqa (16238999)
- Doaa Emadeldin (16238810)
- Dalia Hemeda (16237904)
- Diaa Moustafa Elbendary Elsawahly (16237937)
- Ahmed Sabry (12501380)
- Khalid Salah El-Dien (16237832)
- Hunain Shiwani (9943820)
- Cheng Chun Goh (16237508)
- Giridhar H Devadasar (16237586)
- Amr Hasan (9745484)
- Sung-Hee Kim (11271393)
- Ahmed Rslan (16238804)
- Juan Camilo Correa (16239104)
- Thiago Fernandes Giuriato (16238747)
- Mahmoud Abdelshafy (12410814)
- Giuliano Borda-Luque (16239002)
- Maria Isabel Villegas (16237676)
- Omar Saleh (825207)
- Mayaba Maimbo (16239203)
- Hossam Elfeki (8939474)
- Hosni Khairy (16237487)
- Nigel Hall (3404000)
- Hager Tolba (16238147)
- Cameron Fairfield (16238990)
- Maria Clara Mendoza Arango (16237679)
- Robert Karlo (15205357)
- Katherine Gash (16239197)
- Heba Shaker (16238099)
- Ahmed Lasheen (16238162)
- Mostafa Seif (16238120)
- Mahmoud Morsi (4390996)
- Rakan Kabariti (16239191)
- Mennat-Allah Mustafa (16238084)
- Radhian Amandito (7145585)
- Ragavan Narayanan (16239200)
- JC Allen Ingabire (12983229)
- John Whitaker (3524462)
- Dietmar Ofner (16239206)
- Richard Lilford (18779)
- Boris Marinkovic (16238762)
- Muhammad Rashid Minhas Qadir (16237592)
- Marisa Leal (16237631)
- Dan L Deckelbaum (16237661)
- Faustin Ntirenganya (11559270)
- Ruben Balmaceda (16237541)
- Mohamed Sabry Ammar (16238081)
- Midhun Mohan (3621155)
- Marie Carmela Lapitan (16239017)
- Mohamed Abozaid (16237805)
- Thomas G Weiser (12983232)
- Mahmoud Alrahawy (16238093)
- Hassan Ali Mostafa (16238153)
- Nikica Pezelj (16237715)
- Azmina Verjee (3496640)
- Sam Seisay (16239170)
- Dushyant Iyer (16237565)
- Tomas Poskus (9244740)
- Aliaa Sadek (16238054)
- Maria Marta Modolo (12136797)
- Sara Abd Elmageed Barakat (16238069)
- Eman Adel Sayma (16238135)
- Ahmed Sakr (9759095)
- Dmitri Raptis (16239179)
- Sarah Abdelghany (16237961)
- Hazem Khaled (16237910)
- Vassilis Kalles (16239110)
- Elaine Borg (9556817)
- Dion Morton (83420)
- Irene Ortega (11482761)
- Yucel Cengiz (16237532)
- Juana Kabba (16237640)
- Brian Cameron (14177663)
- Ahmed Adel (8809749)
- Areej Tarek (16238111)
- Dmitri Nepogodiev (703061)
- Yasmin Abd Elrasoul (16238075)
- Omar Osman (16237787)
- Arnav Agarwal (649596)
- Fatimah I Elgendy (16238042)
- Daniel Youssef (16237568)
- Ahmed Mohamed Afifi (16237925)
- Ana Vega Freitas (16237481)
- Ewan Macdermid (16237544)
- Nicholas Phillips (2015242)
- Abdullah Gouda (16237757)
- Laura Luque (16237511)
- Sebastian King (16237646)
- Romeo Lages Simoes (16238759)
- Angham Solaiman El-Ma'doul (16238141)
- James Brown (425608)
- Ruben Rivas (16238786)
- Antje Oosterkamp (16237577)
- Victor Manuel Quintero Riaza (16237688)
- Zineb Bentounsi (16239134)
- Mohamed Abdelraheim (16237886)
- Dmitri A Raptis (16237535)
- Ella Teasdale (16239185)
- Sara Mehrez (16238018)
- Ahmed Hafez El-Badri Kotb (16237808)
- Mahmoud Elkhadrawi (16237922)
- Thomas Pinkney (467511)
- Yacoubou Imorou Souaibou (16237583)
- Hannah S Thomas (16238984)
- Luis Alberto Valente Laufer (16238735)
- Anyomih Theophilus Teddy Kojo (16239014)
- Jakov Mihanovic (12136842)
- Mahmoud Gomah (16237745)
- Ismail Lawani (12136812)
- Ahmed Abd El Galeel (16237826)
- Yasmin Hegazy (16238801)
- Samar Saad (12434298)
- Donatas Venskutonis (16239119)
- Ashrarur Rahman Mitul (12036842)
- Omar Abdulbagi (16239176)
- Chetan Khatri (644807)
- Hisham Samih (16237955)
- Adesoji O Ademuyiwa (12983220)
- Mahmoud Mohamed Metwally (16237931)
- James C Glasbey (12136746)
- Osaid H Alser (16239143)
- Yuksel Altinel (8931545)
- Ahmed Altibi (3500429)
- Justas Zilinskas (16237505)
- Nader Abd El Hamid (16238792)
- Sarah Rayne (16237526)
- Alexandre Venancio De Sousa (16238714)
- Stella Binna Kim (16238711)
- Jaime Andres Montoya Botero (16237685)
- Antonio Ramos-De la Medina (16239029)
- Gareth Irwin (4235590)
- Peep Talving (4320574)
- Carlos Morales (9269296)
- Gamal Shimy (16237724)
- Haya Tahboub (16239140)
- Jehad Hassan Youssif (16237868)
- Jen Cornick (14761678)
- Ivan Mendoza (3853423)
- Roy Quek (16239116)
- Mohamed Asal (16237739)
- Fred Alexander Naranjo Aristizaibal (16239212)
- Ahamed Hassan (16237721)
- Mohammed Hanafy (16237766)
- Jessica Souza Luiz (16238753)
- Ola Sherief Abd El Hameed (16238159)
- Amira Atef Omar (16238156)
- Abdalrahman Adel (16237793)
- Ahmed Elgebaly (3500423)
- Khaled Naser El Deen (16237892)
- Abdullah Al-Mallah (16237769)
- Mohamed Etman (16238090)
- Abdelfatah Hussein (16237919)
- Caio Vinicius Barroso de Lima (16237634)
- Thomas M Drake (11606831)
- Luiza Sarmento Tatagiba (5552507)
- Stephen R Knight (16238987)
- Khalid Mahmud (16237574)
- Hager Ahmed El-badawy (16238816)
- Abdelrahman Alkammash (16237817)
- Marwan Shawki (16237499)
- Sayeda Nazmum Nahar (16239089)
- Fathia Abd El-Salam (16238045)
- Ahmed Khyrallh (16237718)
- Mahmoud Ahmed Fathi Abozyed (16237859)
- Scott K D'amours (16237562)
- Metwally Aboraya (16238798)
- Ahmed Elkholy (16237991)
- Roxanne Chenn (16237550)
- Abdelrahman Haroun (16237985)
- Samuel Nigo (16237637)
- Abdelrhman Osama Elsebaaye (16237880)
- Michael Walsh (49565)
- Wei Guo (86150)
- Mihael Radic (16237709)
- Ahmed Elkelany (16238105)
- Simon Stock (6683147)
- Maira Cassa Careta (16237628)
- Julia Guasti Pinto Vianna (16239209)
- Kjetil Soreide (8715852)
- Mona Hosh (16238024)
- Fatma Elkady (16237967)
- Salim Anderson Khouri Ferreira (16237625)
- Ibrahim AbdelFattah (16238789)
- Aneel Bhangu (4320508)
- Mohammed Ubaid Alsaggaf (16237517)
- Eman Nofal (16237943)
- April Camilla Roslani (8367699)
- Aneel Bhang (16239083)
- Fei Zheng (193006)
- Mohamed Abbas (834428)
- Ahmad Elbatahgy (16238138)
- Rafael Araujo (162519)
- Tom Arthur (16239086)
- Tyler Rouse (16239098)
- Emad Mohamed Saeed Taha (16237847)
- Juliana Menegussi (5552504)
- Jakeline Restrepo (16237691)
- Osama Seifelnasr (16238048)
- Soliman Magdy Ahmed (16237871)
- Augusto Zani (6278387)
- Nadin Elsayed (16238072)
- Sebestian Shu (16239149)
- Amany Abouzahra (16238036)
- Muhammad El-Saied Ahmad Muhammad Gohar (16237736)
- Mohamed Seisa (16237913)
- Luana Ayres Da Silva (16238741)
- Athar Eysa (16238051)
- Adewale O Adisa (16239026)
- Stephen J Chapman (16237493)
- Alejandro Munera (16237700)
- Nehal Yosri Elsayed Abdel-Wahab (16237856)
- Neil Smart (3837253)
- Gustavo Peixoto Soares Miguel (16238720)
- Gustavo Recinos (16237496)
- Luca Ansaloni (3568310)
- Diego Romani (16239146)
- Cutting Edge Manipal (16238690)
- Ali Amin Ahmed Ata (16237811)
- Francesco Pata (8715885)
- Osama Saadeldeen Ebrahim (16237928)
- Basant Kumar (14835478)
- Michael Hanrahan (16237502)
- Marina Luiza Pimenta (16238744)
- Sebastian Sierra (16237670)
- Gehad El Ashal (16238009)
- Tapan Kumar (9764999)
- Ahmed Fouad (8343690)
- Ahmed Raslan (11776126)
- Eugenio Grasset (16238765)
- Ahmad Uzair Qureshi (13433328)
- Pamphile A Assouto (16237580)
- Ahmed Negida (4390993)
- Fernanda Altoe (16238738)
- Attia Mohamed Attia (16237823)
- Reem Fakher (16237976)
- Philip Alexander (16238996)
- Maria Lorena Aguilera (16238993)
- Hafiz Hakim (16238705)
- Edgar Domini (16237706)
- Mohamed Elbermawy (16237946)
- Abd El-Rahman Hegazy Khedr (16237877)
- Ahmed Gomaa (4115773)
- Eslam Elbanby (16237829)
- Gisele Moreira (16237610)
- Ahmed Mohammed (7004726)
- Abdalla Kenibar (16237784)
- Hisham Safa (16237940)
- Alexis Arnaud (11516434)
- Kyaw Phyo Aung (16237595)
- Kholod Tarek Lasheen (16237850)
- Ayman Elwan (16238114)
- Hager Elwakil (16238096)
- Martin Jarmin (16237559)
- Richard Spence (16237523)
- Elsayed Gamaly (16238033)
- Hussein El-Kashef (16238108)
- Margub Hussain (16238702)
- Aurel Mironescu (16239152)
- Emad Abdallah (16238027)
- Ahmed Moustafa Saeed (16237862)
- Ibrahim Al-Slaibi (11514234)
- Michael Edye (16237556)
- Lee Shi Yeo (16237598)
- Sarah Antar (16238015)
- Paulo Alves Bezerra Morais (16238750)
- Emmy Runigamugabo (16239035)
- Oliver Warren (4386268)
- Abd Elrahman Elshafay (16237760)
- Rowida Elmelegy (16237934)
- Kareem Elshaer (16237916)
- Qinyang Liu (16239101)
- Florian Primavesi (6786002)
- Riinu Ots (7485878)
- Shereen Elsheikh (16238039)
- J Edward Fitzgerald (16239005)
- Mohammed Firdouse (16237652)
- Tanzeela Gala (16239137)
- Mengistu Worku (16238408)
- Roberto Macchiavello (16238771)
- Chean Leung Chong (16237589)
- Ibrahim Elzayat (16237889)
- Maha Gamal Mohamad Hamad (16238021)
- Ade Waterman (16239092)
- Chia Kong (16239182)
- Sylvia Batista Lemaire (16239215)
- Mahmoud Warda (4671655)
- Omar Salah (11367852)
- Abdelrahman Sayed (16237802)
- Abdelrhman Essam Elnemr (16238795)
- Diaa Eldin Abdelazeem Amin Elsorogy (16238150)
- Ahmed El Kholy (16237964)
- Zahra Jaffry (16237490)
- Aliyu Ndajiwo (12256673)
- Julio Jimenez (789609)
- Amr Muhammad Elkorashy (16237844)
- Mohamed Karkeet (16237751)
- Ainhoa Costas-Chavarri (5204594)
- Asmaa Abdelgelil (16237958)
- Jenifa Jeyakumar (16237529)
- Cheryl Ou Yong (16237553)
- Mohammed Saeed (3411002)
- Publication venue
- Publication date
- 2019
- Field of study
Abstract
Background
The World Health Organization (WHO) Surgical Safety Checklist has fostered safe practice for 10 years, yet its place in emergency surgery has not been assessed on a global scale. The aim of this study was to evaluate reported checklist use in emergency settings and examine the relationship with perioperative mortality in patients who had emergency laparotomy.
Methods
In two multinational cohort studies, adults undergoing emergency laparotomy were compared with those having elective gastrointestinal surgery. Relationships between reported checklist use and mortality were determined using multivariable logistic regression and bootstrapped simulation.
Results
Of 12 296 patients included from 76 countries, 4843 underwent emergency laparotomy. After adjusting for patient and disease factors, checklist use before emergency laparotomy was more common in countries with a high Human Development Index (HDI) (2455 of 2741, 89·6 per cent) compared with that in countries with a middle (753 of 1242, 60·6 per cent; odds ratio (OR) 0·17, 95 per cent c.i. 0·14 to 0·21, P < 0·001) or low (363 of 860, 42·2 per cent; OR 0·08, 0·07 to 0·10, P < 0·001) HDI. Checklist use was less common in elective surgery than for emergency laparotomy in high-HDI countries (risk difference −9·4 (95 per cent c.i. −11·9 to −6·9) per cent; P < 0·001), but the relationship was reversed in low-HDI countries (+12·1 (+7·0 to +17·3) per cent; P < 0·001). In multivariable models, checklist use was associated with a lower 30-day perioperative mortality (OR 0·60, 0·50 to 0·73; P < 0·001). The greatest absolute benefit was seen for emergency surgery in low- and middle-HDI countries.
Conclusion
Checklist use in emergency laparotomy was associated with a significantly lower perioperative mortality rate. Checklist use in low-HDI countries was half that in high-HDI countries
